Submit manuscript...
International Journal of
eISSN: 2381-1803

Complementary & Alternative Medicine

Review Article Volume 17 Issue 5

Honey and propolis for management of diabetic foot ulcers

Abdul Hafeez MM, Hamouda SM

Animal Health Research Institute, Egypt

Correspondence: Abdul Hafeez MM, Animal Health Research Institute, Assiut Lab. AHRI, ARC, Egypt

Received: October 17, 2024 | Published: November 4, 2024

Citation: Abdul HMM, Hamouda SM. Honey and propolis for management of diabetic foot ulcers. Int J Complement Alt Med. 2024;17(5):240-246. DOI: 10.15406/ijcam.2024.17.00711

Download PDF

Abstract

Diabetes mellitus (DM) hyperglycemia may lead to hyperplasia and micro vascular dysfunction and delays wound healing process by increasing reactive oxygen species (ROS) accompanied by low levels of inflammatory cytokines and an increase in matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs). Consequently, prolonged healing process with the worst complication diabetic foot ulcers (DFUs) as when it fails to heal fating limb amputation. Apitherapeutic (honey and propolis) wound dressing achieved successful accelerated healing with infection control by the action of their antimicrobial, anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties. The present review dealt with their activity with DFUs as study of: in vitro antimicrobial activity against DFUs isolated pathogens, in vitro their activity towards immune cellular wound healing elements and in vivo their application for induced DFUs animal models as well as their topical application for DFUs patients either natural or nanoformulated scaffold dressings. Available literatures proved the synergistic wound healing activity of different mixed apitherapeutic products together and recommended to be used in mixed formula either naturally or nanoformulation.

Keywords: apiterapy, honey, propolis, diabetic wound ulcers, nano apitherapeutic wound

Introduction

Healing of wounds is a complicated process targeting tissue restore begins just after the damage with hemostasis followed by three stages named; inflammation, proliferation and remodeling,1–3 where the proliferative stage occurs after the injury by 2 or 3 days.4 DM is a progressive and chronic endocrine disorder results in hyperglycemia5 and inflammatory state which impairs wound healing through multifactorial mechanisms,6,7 excessive inflammation and reduced angiogenesis.8 Among the worst complications of diabetes, the development of DFUs is one of the major public health challenges usually precedes diabetic foot amputations.9

Diabetic foot ulcers (DFUs) development

DFUs are devastating micro-vascular complications of diabetes10 characterized by delayed wound healing because of decreased collagen concentration of and granulation tissue formation,5 increases reactive oxygen species (ROS) production11 enhancing hypoxia damage12 with decreased myofibroblast formation and increase in matrix MMPs13,14 resulting in weakened wound contraction and delayed healing.15 Fast healing of diabetic wounds remains a major clinical challenge16 as patients whose ulcers failed to heal had higher tumor necrosis factor-a, monocyte chemo attractant protein-1, matrix metallopeptidase 9 (MMP-9), and fibroblast growth factor 2 serum levels – which are the main factors associated with failure to heal DFUs - when compared with those who healed.17 The prolonged inflammation status caused by hyperglycemia in the microcirculation might lead to endothelial hyperplasia and microvascular dysfunction18 and capillary basement membrane thickening,19 neuropathy20,21 and other of deadly complications.11,22 Moreover, DM impairs immuno cellular (neutrophils and macrophages) function,23 including cell adherence, chemotaxis, phagocytosis, and cytokine production and secretion.24 In diabetic wounds, macrophages produce excessive pro-inflammatory cytokines, neutrophils cytotoxic enzymes, free radical spices,4 then further oxidative stress leading to further tissue damage and delayed pathological healing.8

DFUs neuroischemic pathology of the foot

DM is characterized by neuro degenerative disorders of the peripheral nervous system targets sensory, autonomic, and to lesser extension motor neurons19 with neuroischemic pathology of the patient’s foot.25 The main consequence of this neuropathy is the risk of DFUs as any peripheral skin cuts, unaware injuriy, pessure ulcer26 or callus might remain unnoticed6,27 results with unperceived lesion28 with ischemia, hypoxia, decreased angiogenesis predisposing bacterial infection.10 These lesions begin as superficial ulcer, progressing to deep tissue infection with osteomyelitis18 fating limb amputation.20,29 DFUs are still considered a public health challenge promoting microbial biofilm formation by the presence of multidrug-resistant microorganisms (MDR) and microbial biofilm19,30–32 which maximizes resistance,33 leading to foot ulceration and delayed wound healing9 threating high rates of lower-limb amputations.29 Despite recent advances in antimicrobial therapy, DFUs remain serious problem since most of them ultimately turn into diabetic gangrene if left untreated.34 Thus, there is a need for a continued search for affordable agents with speed and no side effects for treating ailments29 especially in developing countries.35

Wound healing bioactivity of honey and propolis

Honey is rediscovered as a potent highly effective medicament in wound dressing with short duration2 and known as an “all in one” remedy for diabetic wound healing34 and affordable secure treatment.29 It is rich in bioactive compounds such as methylglyoxal, hydrogen peroxide, phenolics, and bee defensin-1 peptide31 with low moisture content, high osmolarity, acidity29 and polyphenols that have been found to possess antibacterial properties36 and other different phytochemical and phytopharmaceutical compounds (mainly flavonoids and polyphenols).37–40 These micro compounds reduce the number of mast cells and neutrophils, accelerating the revival process and wound healing.40 As these micro compounds are widely documented exhibited potent antimicrobial activity2,33,38,4143 especially those biofilm producers,2,30–32,36 anti-inflammatory potency,44,45 antioxidant potential46 and free radical scavenging ability formed by polymorph nuclear neutrophils.34 As well as having immunomodulation action at the wound site,29,45 so they are recommended for management of DFUs. Honey47 and propolis48 can reduce the activity of cyclooxygenases I and II that inhibits the synthesis of prostaglandins involved in the inflammatory responses by the lipoxygenase pathway49 aiding in wound healing. Apiproducts with their bioactive micro components have other biological functions as enhancement of the proliferation and migration of skin cells, promotion of vascularization at the site of wound and inflammatory regulation16 by the action of α— actin50 and chrysin,14 where the dysregulation of wound healing phases (Matrix MMPs and their inhibitors13) is an important variance between diabetics and non-diabetic patients.29

In vitro antimicrobial testing of honey and propolis against pathogens isolated from DFUs

The in vitro studies of honey against DFUs isolates - which are mostly MDR bacteria19 revealed potent antimicrobial activity; St aureus,51–55 MRSA, Pseudomonas aeruginosa,53–56 E. coli54,56 Proteus mirabilis,30,54 and Clostredium sp.54 Also, propolis antimicrobial action was obtained in vitro against DFUs isolates; St aureus,57–59 Candida albicans,58 Pseudomonas, E. coli.57

In vitro testing of honey and propolis against DFUs cellular elements

Several studies in vitro honey or propolis healing activity, when diabetic healing human keratinocytes12,60–62 and fibroblasts63 were activated, where the activated fibroblast replaces the fibrin-based provisional matrix with collagen-rich granulation tissue5,27 with collagen deposition50,61,64 which aids in remodling phase in wound healing concluded higher wound closure rates.50,64,65 Activated keratinocytes60 play a role in inflammatory cytokines production during the inflammation phase of wound healing66 as promoted the expression of tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-a), interleukin 1β, transforming growth factor beta (TGF-β),14,67 as well as MMP-9 messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) in primary keratinocytes.66 The prolonged wound healing mainly is due to down-regulation of KGF, IL- 10, PDGF, IGF-1, EGF, as well as HIF cytokines, but up-regulation is due to TNF-a, IL-6, and TGF-b210 which the laters might be suppressed by the action of honey and propolis micro components.68 To investigate the effect of honey with propolis extraction on human dermal fibroblast cells, an in vitro study62 concluded significant impact on wound healing with a higher wound closure percentage and higher cell migration rate. The immunomodulatory action of honey3,23,45 and propolis23 and its constituents at noncytotoxic concentrations, specifically an anti-inflammatory activity in LPS-treated cells by inhibiting cytokine production.69 Honey peroxide and non-peroxide mechanisms are responsible for promoting wound healing19 since in an in vitro study,70 H2O2 produced by diluted honey by the wound exudate can induce the entry of extracellular calcium34 that plays an important role in wound repair and closure.61

Flavonoids and polyphenols (bioactive components present in honey and propolis) have been shown to promote wound healing37,40 by many factors; 1- Lowering inflammatory cell influx in situ. 2- Boosting angiogenesis by stimulating the vascular endothelial growth factor.29 3- Fibroblastic proliferation promotion or speeding up re-epithelization50,62 as they antimicrobial and angiogenesis promoter effects.71 4- Decreasing wound size by collagen deposition and angiogenetic markers (HIF-1a, VEGF).50

In vivo studies of honey and propolis in induced DFUs of animal models

In vivo, to study wound healing action of honey solo dressing on DFUs, standard back or nape wounds were adopted in induced diabetic animal models; mice50,72,73 and rat5,29,68 while topical propolis application was carried for diabetic mice14,22,27 and rat74 accelerated wound contraction with speed healing rate in all above mentioned studies and increased fibroblasts expression in diabetic rats.75 Moreover, similar obtained results were achieved in diabetic male rats with honey combined with royal jelly, olive oil and propolis extract76 due to its antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and antibacterial properties. Honey application in either male14,72,76 or female24 induced diabetic rats obtained the smallest wound surfaces, higher wound contraction and accelerated wound closure.5,19,68,76 Some studies77,84 obtained that topical application of propolis solely for induced diabetic rats77 or mice78 increased the healing of full-thickness wounds, but epithelial closure failed and increased the expression of fibroblasts within the traumatic ulcer healing process in diabetic75 rats with direct signaling FGF- 2 that can enhance the proliferation of fibroblasts and accelerate the healing of ulcers.

Wound dressing with ethanolic extract of propolis in induced diabetic mice14 resulted in wound closure, tensile strength and expression of different molecules such as α—actin,50 which is cytoskeletal and its regulation of is tightly controlled and regulated by the stimulated keratinocytes, fibroblasts, epithelial and endothelial cells.75 Topical application of propolis nano particles for induced diabetic,79 non-diabetic mice80 or non-diabetic rats81–83 accelerated wound healing even single topical propolis cream application.84 Topical application of honey and propolis dressing for DFUs animal models - in the above mentioned studies - resulted in great wound contraction, increased re- epithelialization, high proliferation markers, collagen deposition and angiogenetic markers (HIF-1a, VEGF)50 leading to faster wound healing and wound closure50,78 comparing with classical treatment in the same studies and gave promising apitherapeutic topical management for human clinical diabetic foot ulcer since it is relatively highly effective, free of adverse effects and very cost-effective.35,85

Apitherapeutic mechanisms to manage DFUs

Honey when be diluted by wound exudates – in topical dressing - produces hydrogen peroxide that induces fibroblast infiltration, promotes angiogenesis and stimulates the vascular endothelial growth factor.86 Its acidity and osmotic effects stimulates the activity of phagocytes and lymphocytes at the wound site.87 It has broad spectrum bactericidal activities, helps manage wound infections, promotes the growth of epithelium, and reduces swelling and absorbs edema around wounds88,89 just after four hours post application.19 So, for diabetic patients with either DFUs17,26,90–92 or bed sores,88 honey dressing can reduce the time needed for wound debridement, wound healing, bacterial clearance, speed up wound healing and bacterial clearance rates.34 Honey stimulates monocytes, macrophages,87 neutrophils, keratinocytes, and fibroblasts activities.60 Wide range studies22,27,56,78,82 proved that propolis promotes and accelerates wound healing mainly by the action of chrysin81 and other flavonoids39 through stimulation of both fibroblasts and epithelial cells65 to be increased in numbers resulting in collagen formation38,61,64,80 and granulation tissues.93 Propolis chrysin regulates the expression of MMPs and their tissue inhibitors14 which is the main cause to reduce wound size49 up to wound closure.50,78

Clinical topical apitherapeutic application for DFUs patients

Honey is ideal dressing in cases of diabetic foot wounds particularly in the developing countries35 as it is an environmentally based cost and clinically effective dressing. More importantly, honey is very safe for DFUs patients as it does not result in any complication (local or systemic).19 For DFUs patients, various apitherapeutic (honey or propolis) dressing were applied as topical application of honey either solely,1,21,56,93–99 with olive oil,100,101 with propolis extract25 or with bee venom.102 All these studies, the apitherapeutic wound dressings accelerated DFU healing judged by infection control rates,61,95,96 promotion boosting immune cellular elements,23,45,69,87 reduced the time needed for wound debridement,89 tissue maturation and wound re-epithelization. With all previous studies, honey wound dressing reduced patient hospitalization and amputation rates.19 Honey dressing is safer for treatment of FDUs21,52,95 since topical honey dressing is more effective than conventional pyodine, povidone-iodine85 or betadine103 dressing in terms of recovery time21,90 leadind to complete wound closure.92 Manuka honey topically is widely tried cocluded that it is very effective for wound healing in DFUs patients21,88,97,104–106 and more effective than iodine, paraffin tulle, olive iol, nanocrystalline and silver dressings.107

Topical propolis extract dressing,47,48,57 its extract spray108 or its lotion form109 application for DFUs patients indicated the effectiveness of the intervention in reducing wound size. Topical application of honey with propolis proved synergistic action of healing quality and acceleration in male standard wounded in induced diabetic63,77,95,96 or non-diabetic rats.49 The topical application of honey with propolis for non-diabetic patient’s wounds110 or those with DFUs111,112 proved the decreased wound areas significantly up to complete closure enhancing re-epithelization.2 So it is recommended to use both api-products together for management chronic wounds especially those DFU wounds49,77,104 or when be contaminated with antibiotic resistance pathogens55,56 specially those biofilm producers.19 30–32,36 Either in vitro or in vivo experimental studies rather than clinical apply for diabetic patients,34,111,112,94 honey or propolis accelerated wound healing, it is proved that honey enriched together with propolis extract is an excellent source of antimicrobial33,49,97 and antioxidant113 with synergistic activity2 maximizing the solo action of each.

Nano of single apitherapeutic product for diabetic wound dressing application

Nanomaterials may undergo novel chemical and physical changes in their structure as a result of their smaller size, indicating increased reactivity, solubility114,115 improvement of the drug delivery, absorption and bioavailability having biocompatibility, non-toxicity, and biodegradability properties.116 Wide range studies about apitherapeutic nanoformula scaffold have emerged as a promising therapeutic option in diabetic wound management application117) which was applied using single apiproducts ; honey,34,88,89,92,101,106–121 propolis,3,59,79,119,122–126 bee venom,127,128 bee wax.129 In vitro study of poly diallyldimethyl ammonium chloride / honey nanofiber34 exhibited an excellent antibacterial activity (99.9%) against MRSA,130 S. aureus & E. coli, while in topical application for DFUs achieved the best wound-healing properties with formation of high amounts of fibroblast cells, collagen fibers, and connective fibrils in the treated wounds.34 Another in an in vitro study, nanofiber chitosan loaded honey olive oil cream increased antioxidant wound healin mediators.101 Several propolis nanoformulations have been found and proven to have biological effects.116 These nano particles stimulates fibroblast proliferation in vitro and it be preferable since resulting high rate of wound closure in vivo when be applied for DFUs patients.79 More advanced nano propolis-loaded poly lacticco-glycolic acid124 or polyvinyl-alcohol gelatin nanofibers59 increases human fibroblast cells proliferation, activates antioxidant activity131 and antibacterial agent against E.coli, S. aureus and Candida albicans.124 When prolpolis extract nano particles is loaded (Pro-ZnO NPs) may give inhibitory activity against α-amylase and α-glucosidase with promting antioxidant effects.132 Propolis nano formulation gave positive results comparing with propolis extract cream.3 Topical application of a chitosan-blend film containing bee venom accelerated wound healing in diabetic mice through improvement of cellular elements and antioxidant cytokines.127 Different forms of nano propolis wound dressings, such as foam, polyurethane,82 nano-propolis fibers,133 hydrogels134,135 or chitosan bee venom hydrogel136 were applied.

Wide scale of different honey nano fabrication34,81,131,133 scaffolds were applied for DFUs with the mechanism of different multifunctional bioactive microcomponents120 as honey nanoparticles (smart wound dressings). Honey hydrogels scaffold dressing,137S,138 topical ointments,11 honey loaded nanocrystalline silver,91,139 modified-honeycomb-structure scaffold,140 honey polyvinyl alcohol nanofiber membrane, honey microneedles130 or poly diallyl dimethylammonium chloride / honey nanofiber34 to manufacture wound dressing for human DFUs resulted in complete healing118 exploring its effectiveness in promoting wound healing, tissue regeneration, and antimicrobial activity with complete wound closure (5-12) days.34 Honey nanofibrous bandages, films, hydrogels, hydrocolloids, tulle, foams, or gauzes stimulates cell proliferation and angiogenesis,10,141 while chitosan topical gel and film were effective in promoting tissue granulation and DFU closure.142 Honey nano chitosan hydroge135 and with mixture of different types of propolis,137 higher acceleration of wound re-epithelialization and closure65 was obtained. It is suggested that these safe green nanomaterials fulfill their undoubtedly large therapeutic potentials.108

Nano of mixed apitherapeutic products for diabetic wound dressing application

Some studies proved the synergistic effect of nano application of honey with propolis ointment49 or lotion,109 propolis with bee venom51 or honey with mixture of nano propolis / venom.133 Wound dressing hydrogel loaded with honey bee propolis extract proved to be an antimicrobial wound healing agent,110,134 while pectin, propolis and honey could be combined towards the fabrication of wound‐ healing patches are advantageous compared to traditional techniques,143 mostly it is suggested that apitherapeutic wound dressing especially honey effectively promotes healing in DFU.144 Honey pomegranate bee venom nanofiber wound dressing102 has potent in vitro antimicrobial action against E.coli and S. aureus rather than in vivo study, it increased wound closure percentages.

Conclusion

The study concluded that for DFUs, apitherapeutic wound dressing is a promising alternative chemotherapeutic antimicrobial, wound healing accelerating and promoting agent without any risk of developing resistance or disease complication. The study ascertains the recommendation of using mixture of safe green apiproducts either naturally or nanoformulation to obtain synergistic actions of many apitherapeutic activities.

Acknowledgments

None.

Conflicts of interest

Author declare there are no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. Wang C, Guo M, Zhang N, et al. Effectiveness of honey dressing in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers: a systematic review and meta- analysis. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2019;34:123–131.
  2. Abdul Hafeez MM, Hamouda SM. Honey and propolis for wound healing. International Journal of Complementary & Alternative Medicine. Int J Complement Alt Med. 2023;16(1):12‒17.
  3. Ibrahim N, Hassan A, Ragab W, et al. A Comparative Study on the Effect of Two Topical Formulations of Bee Propolis Cream in Ordinary and Nano Form on Wound Healing in Aged Rats (A Histological and Immunohistochemical Study). The Egypt Journal of Histology. 2024;47(1):38–59.
  4. El Sakhawy, Salama A, Hebat Allah T. Applications of propolis-based materials in wound healing. Arch Dermatol Res. 2024;316(1):61.
  5. Gill R, Poojar B, Bairy LK, et al. Comparative evaluation of wound healing potential of manuka and Acacia honey in diabetic and nondiabetic rats. J Pharm Bioallied Sci. 2019;11(2):116–126.
  6. Patel S, Srivastava S, Singh MR, et al. Mechanistic insight into diabetic wounds: Pathogenesis, molecular targets and treatment strategies to pace wound healing. Biomed Pharmacother. 2019;112:108615.
  7. Chen LY, Cheng HL, Kuan YH, et al. Therapeutic potential of luteolin on impaired wound healing in streptozotocin - induced rats. Biomedicines. 2021;9(7):761.
  8. Dasari N, Jiang A, Skochdopole A, et al. Updates in diabetic wound healing, inflammation, and scarring. Semin Plast Surg. 2021;35(3)153–158.
  9. Edmonds M, Manu C, Vas P. The current burden of diabetic foot disease. J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2021;17:88–93.
  10. Kumar S, Bharali A, Himangshu Sarma H, et al. Traditional complementary and alternative medicine (TCAM) for diabetic foot ulcer management: A systematic review. J Ayurveda Integr Med. 2023;14(4):100745.
  11. Diab S, Tayea N, Elwakil B, et al. Novel Amoxicillin- Loaded Sericin Biopolymeric Nanoparticles: Synthesis, Optimization, Antibacterial and Wound Healing Activities. Int J Mol Sci. 2022;23(19):11654.
  12. Chaudhary A, Bag S, Barui A, et al. Honey dilution impact on in vitro wound healing: normoxic and hypoxic condition. Wound Repair Regen. 2015;23(3):412–422.
  13. Yang C, Zhu P, Yan L, et al.  Dynamic changes in matrix metalloproteinase 9 and tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase 1 levels during wound healing in diabetic rats. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 2009;99(6):489–496.
  14. Canales Alvarez O, Canales Martinez M, Dominguez Verano P, et al. Effect of Mexican Propolis on Wound Healing in a Murine Model of Diabetes Mellitus. Int J Mol Sci. 2024;25(4):2201.
  15. Wan R, Weissman JP, Grundman K, et al. Diabetic  wound healing: The impact of diabetes on myofibroblast activity and its potential therapeutic treatments. Wound Repair Regen. 2021;29(4):573–581.
  16. John J, Sharma N, Tang G, et al.  Nanofiber Aerogels with Precision Macrochannels and LL-37-Mimic Peptides Synergistically Promote Diabetic Wound Healing. Adv Funct Mater. 2024;33(1):2206936.
  17. Dinh T, Tecilazich F, Kafanas A, et al. Mechanisms Involved in the Development and Healing of Diabetic Foot Ulceration. Diabetes. 2012;61(11):2937 – 2947.
  18. Azhar A, Basheer M, Abdelgawad MS, et al.  Prevalence of Peripheral Arterial Disease in Diabetic Foot Ulcer Patients and its Impact in Limb Salvage. Int J Low Extrem Wounds. 2021;22(3):518–523.
  19. Bezerra A, Fonseca H, Rodrigues F, et al.  Honey Therapy in Diabetic Foot Ulcers: A Promising Strategy for Effective Wound Healing. Appl Sci. 2023;13(23):2820.
  20. Forsythe RO, Brownrigg J, Hinchliffe RJ. Peripheral arterial disease and revascularization of the diabetic foot. Diabetes Obes Metab. 2015;17(5):435–444.
  21. Kamaratos AV, Tzirogiannis KN, Iraklianou SA, et al. Manuka honey-impregnated dressings in the treatment of neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers. Int Wound J. 2014;11(3):259–263.
  22. Picolotto A, Perghera D, Pereirab G, et al. Bacterial cellulose membrane associated with red propolis as phytomodulator: Improved healing effects in experimental models of diabetes mellitus. Biomed Pharmacother. 2019;112:108640.
  23. Sayed SM, Abou El Ella GA, Wahba NM, et al. Immune defense of rats immunized with fennel honey, propolis, and bee venom against induced Staphylococcal infection. J Med Food. 2009;12(3):569–575.
  24. Nho YC, Park JS, Lim YM. Preparation of hydrogel by radiation for the healing of diabetic ulcer.  Radiation Physics and Chemistry. 2014;45(46):176–180.
  25. Yang J, Pi A, Yan L, et al. Research Progress on Therapeutic Effect and Mechanism of Propolis on Wound Healing. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2022;5798941.
  26. Koujalagi RS, Uppin VM, Shah S, et al. One year randomized controlled trial to compare the effectiveness of honey dressing versus povidone iodine dressing for diabetic foot ulcer at Dr. Prabhakar Kore Hospital and MRC, Belagavi. International Surgery Journal. 2020;7(2):506–513.
  27. Chylińska Wrzos P, Lis Sochocka M, Jodłowska Jędrych B. Use of propolis in difficult to heal diabetic wounds. Short review. Pol J Public Health. 2017;127(4): 173–175.
  28. Kamaratos A, Tzirogiannis K, Iraklianou S, et al. Manuka honey-impregnated dressings in the treatment of neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers. International Wound Journal. 2012;11(3):259–263.
  29. Agbagwa O, Ekeke C, Israel P. Antibacterial Efficacy and Healing Potential of Honey from Different Zones in Nigeria on Diabetic-Induced Wound Infection in Wistar Rats. International Journal of Microbiology. 2022:1–12.
  30. Kwiecinska Piróg J, Przekwas J, Majkut M, et al. Biofilm Formation Reducing Properties of Manuka Honey and Propolis in Proteus mirabilis Rods Isolated from ChronicWounds. Microorganisms. 2020;8(11):1823.
  31. Sojka M, Valachova I, Bucekova M, et al. Antibiofilm efficacy of honey and bee-derived defensin-1 on multispecies wound biofilm. J Med Microbiol. 2016;65(4):337–344.
  32. Balázs VL, Nagy Radványi L, Bencsik Kerekes E, et al. Antibacterial and Antibiofilm Effect of Unifloral Honeys against Bacteria Isolated from ChronicWound Infections. Microorganisms. 2023;11(2):509.
  33. Hamouda SM, Abd El Rahman MF, Abdul Hafeez MM , et al. Egyptian fennel honey and/or propolis against MRSA harboring both mecA & icaA genes. Int J Complement Alt Med. 2018;11(3):180‒185.
  34. Alam F, Islam MA, Gan SH, et al. Honey: a potential therapeutic agent for managing diabetic wounds. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2014(350):169130.
  35. Moghazy A, Shams M, Adly O, et al. The clinical and cost effectiveness of bee honey dressing in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetes Res Clin Pract. 2010;89(3):276–281.
  36. Skadinš I, Labsvards D, Grava A, et al. Antimicrobial and Antibiofilm Properties of Latvian Honey against Causative Agents of Wound Infections. Antibiotics. 2023;12(5):816.
  37. Carvalho MT, Araújo Filho HG, Barreto AS, et al. Wound healing properties of flavonoids: A systematic review highlighting the mechanisms of action.  Phytomedicine. 2021;90:153636.
  38. Talebi M, Talebi M, Farkhondeh T, et al. Molecular mechanism-based therapeutic properties of honey. Biomed Pharmacother. 2020;130 110590.
  39. Cui J, Duan X, Ke L, et al. Extraction, purification, structural character and biological properties of propolis flavonoids: A review. Fitoterapia. 2022;157:105106.
  40. Zulkefli N, Che Zahari C , Sayuti N , et al. Flavonoids as Potential Wound-Healing Molecules: Emphasis on Pathways Perspective. Int J Mol Sci. 2023;24(5):4607.
  41. Abdul Hafeez M. Testimony for veterinary apitherapy. Int J Complement Alt Med. 2019;12(1):15‒22.
  42. Hamouda S, Kuraa H, Abed Zaher M, et al. Apitherapy of Septic Metacarpal and Metatarsal Wounds (An Experimental Study on Donkeys). Clinical Medicine Research. 2019;8(4):77–84.
  43. Gashti M, Dehdast S, Berenjian A, et al. PDDA/Honey Antibacterial Nanofiber Composites for Diabetic Wound- Healing: Preparation, haracterization, and In Vivo Studies. Gels. 2023;9(3):173.
  44. Navaei Alipour A, Mastali M, Ferns G, et al. The effects of honey on pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines: A narrative review. Phytother Res. 2021;35(7):3690–3701.
  45. El Seedi   H,   Eid   N,   Abd   El Wahed   A, et al. Honey Bee Products: Preclinical and Clinical Studies of Their Anti-inflammatory and Immunomodulatory Properties. Front Nutr. 2022;8:761267.
  46. Pauliuc D, Dranca F, Oroian M. Antioxidant Activity, Total Phenolic Content, Individual Phenolics and Physicochemical Parameters Suitability for Romanian Honey Authentication. Foods. 2020;9(3):306.
  47. Yadav A, Verma S, Keshri GK, et al. Combination of medicinal honey and 904 nm super pulsed laser-mediated photobiomodulation promotes healing and impedes inflammation, pain in full-thickness burn. J Photochem Photobiol B. 2018;186:152–159.
  48. Afkhamizadeh M, Aboutorabi R, Ravari H, et al. Topical propolis improves wound healing in diabetic foot ulcer patients: A randomized controlled trial. Nat Prod Res. 2018;32(17):2096– 2099.
  49. Takzaree N, Hadjiakhondi A, Hassanzadeh G, et al. Synergistic Effect of Honey and Propolis on Cutaneous Wound Healing in Rats. Acta Med Iran. 2016;54(4):233–239.
  50. Chaudhary A, Swarnendu B, Banerjee P, et al. Wound healing efficacy of Jamun honey in diabetic mice model through re- epithelialization, collagen deposition and angiogenesis. J Tradit Complement Med. 2020;10(6):529–543.
  51. Al Waili N, Hozzein W, Badr G, et al. Propolis and bee venom in diabetic wounds; a potential approach that warrants clinical investigation. Afr J Tradit Complement Altern Med. 2015;12(6):1–11.
  52. Kateel R, Adhikari P, Augustine AJ, et al. Topical honey for the treatment of diabetic foot ulcer: a systematic review. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2016;24:130–133.
  53. Kateel R, Bhat G, Baliga S, et al. Antibacterial action of Tropical honey on various bacteria obtained from diabetic foot ulcer. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2018;30:29–32.
  54. Shubar H, Abdul Gawad M, Doro B, et al. Activity of Honey and Propolis on Bacteria Isolated from Diabetic Foot. Journal of Advances in Microbiology. 2018;13(1):1–8.
  55. Mirzaei A, Karamolah KS, Mahnaie MP, et al. Antibacterial Activity of Honey against Methicillin-Resistant and Sensitive Staphylococcus aureus Isolated from Patients with Diabetic Foot Ulcer. The Open Microbiology Journal. 2020;14(1):260–265.
  56. Nair H, Tatavilis N, Pospíšilová I, et al. Medical-Grade Honey Kills Antibiotic- Resistant Bacteria and Prevents Amputation in Diabetics with Infected Ulcers: A Prospective Case Series. Antibiotics. 2020;9(9):529.
  57. Henshaw F, Bolton T, Nube V, et al. Topical application of the bee hive protectant propolis is well tolerated and improves human diabetic foot ulcer healing in a prospective feasibility study. J Diabetes Complications. 2014;28(6):850–857.
  58. Al Waili N. Mixing two different propolis samples potentiates their antimicrobial activity and wound healing property: A novel approach in wound healing and infection. Vet World. 2018;11(8):1188–1195.
  59. Ulag S, Ilhan E, Demirhan R, et al. Propolis-Based Nanofiber Patches to Repair Corneal Microbial Keratitis. Molecules. 2021;26(9):2577.
  60. Chaudhary A, Bag S, Banerjee P, et al. Honey extracted polyphenolics reduce experimental hypoxia in human keratinocytes culture. J Agric Food Chem. 2017;65(17):3460–3473.
  61. Anastasiou IA, Eleftheriadou I, Tentolouris A, et al. The effect of oxidative stress and antioxidant therapies on pancreatic β-cell dysfunction: results from in vitro and in vivo studies. Curr Med Chem. 2021;28(7):1328–1346.
  62. Ebadi P, Fazeli M. Evaluation of the potential in vitro effects of propolis and honey on wound healing in human dermal fibroblast cells. S Afr J Bot. 2021;137(3):414–422.
  63. Salrian A, Behzadi A, Oloumi M, et al. Amplification of Wound Healing by Propolis and Honey Ointment in Healthy and Diabetic Rat Models; Histopathological and Morphometric Findings. Arch Razi Inst. 2022;77(5):1673–1681.
  64. Sarkar S, Chaudhary A, Saha TK, et al. Modulation of collagen population under honey assisted wound healing in diabetic rat model. Wound Med. 2018;20:7–17.
  65. Ranzato E, Martinotti S, Burlando B. Honey exposure stimulates wound repair of human dermal fibroblasts. Burns Trauma. 2013;1(1):32–38.
  66. Majtan J, Kumar P, Majtan T, et al. Effect of honey and its major royal jelly protein 1 on cytokine and MMP-9 mRNA transcripts in human keratinocytes. Exp Dermatol. 2010;19(8):e73–e9.
  67. Nisa K, Kustiawan P. Effectiveness of Honey Bees Propolis Extract in The Treatment of Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus. Jurnal Farmasi Galenika (Galenika Journal of Pharmacy). 2023;9(2):247–256.
  68. Malkoç M, Yaoman SÖ, Imamoğlu Y, et al. Anti-inflammatory, antioxidant and wound- healing effects of mad honey in streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats. Journal of Apicultural Research. 2019;59(4):426–436.
  69. Sartori A, Son N, Honorio M, et al. Effects of caatinga propolis from Mimosa tenuiflora and its constituents (santin, sakuranetin and kaempferide) on human immune cells. J Ethnopharmacol. 2024;319(Pt 2):117297.
  70. Martinotti S, Laforenza U, Patrone M, et al. Honey-mediated wound healing: H2O2 Entry through AQP3 Determines Extracellular Ca2+ Influx. Int J Mol Sci. 2019;20(3):764.
  71. da Rosa C, Bueno I, Quaresma A, et al. Healing Potential of Propolis in Skin Wounds Evidenced by Clinical Studies. Pharmaceuticals. 2022;15(9):1143.
  72. Demir A, Simsek T, Engin MS, et al. The effect of topical honey dressing on wound healing in diabetic mice. Gazi Medical J. 2007;18(3):110–113.
  73. Park J, Sung Jun An, Sung In J, et al. Chestnut Honey Impregnated Carboxymethyl Cellulose Hydrogel for Diabetic Ulcer Healing. Polymers. 2017;9(7):248.
  74. Kitamura H. Effects of propolis extract and propolis-derived compounds on obesity and diabetes: Knowledge from cellular and animal models. Molecules. 2019;24(23):4394.
  75. Puspasari A, Harijanti K, Soebadi B, et al. Effects of topical application of propolis extract on fibroblast growth factor-2 and fibroblast expression in the traumatic ulcers of diabetic Rattus norvegicus. J Oral Maxillofac Pathol. 2018;22(1):54–58.
  76. Rashidi MK, Mirazi N, Hosseini A. Effect of topical mixture of honey, royal jelly and olive oil-propolis extract on skin wound healing in diabetic rats. Wound Medicine. 2016;12:6–9.
  77. Salrian A, Behzadi A, Oloumi M, et al. Amplification of Wound Healing by Propolis and Honey Ointment in Healthy and Diabetic Rat Models; Histopathological and Morphometric Findings. Archives of Razi Institute. 2022;77(5):1673–1681.
  78. Hozzein WN, Badr G, Al Ghamdi AA, et al. Topical Application of Propolis Enhances Cutaneous Wound Healing by Promoting TGF-Beta/Smad-Mediated Collagen Production in a Streptozotocin-Induced Type I Diabetic Mouse Model. Cell Physiol Biochem. 2015;37(3):940–954.
  79. Alberti T, Coelho D, Voytena A, et al. Effect of Propolis Nanoparticles on Early-Stage Wound Healing in a Diabetic Noncontractile Wound Model. Nanotechnology and Advanced Material Science. 2019;2:1–10.
  80. Yang J, He Y, Nan S, et al. Therapeutic effect of propolis nanoparticles on wound healing. Journal of Drug Delivery Science and Technology. 2023;82:104284.
  81. Mohammadi Z, Sharif Zak M, Majdi H, et al. The effect of chrysin-loaded nanofiber on wound healing process in male rat. Chem Biol Drug Des. 2017;90(6):1106–1114.
  82. Khodabakhshi D, Eskandarinia A, Kefayat A, et al. In vitro and in vivo performance of a propolis-coated polyurethane wound dressing with high porosity and antibacterial efficacy. Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces. 2019;178:177–184.
  83. DU P, Chen X, Chen Y, et al. In vivo and in vitro studies of a propolis-enriched silk fibroin-gelatin composite nanofiber wound dressing. Heliyon. 2023;9(3):e13506.
  84. McLennan SV, Bonner J, Milne S, et al. The anti-inflammatory agent Propolis improves wound healing in a rodent model of experimental diabetes. Wound Repair Regen. 2008;16(5):706–713.
  85. Kateel R, Ullal S, Prabhu S, et al. Tropical honey for the treatment of diabetic foot ulcer: A systematic review. Complement Ther Clin Pract. 2016;24:130–133.
  86. Loo AE, Wong YT, Ho R, et al. Effects of hydrogen peroxide on wound healing in mice in relation to oxidative damage. PloS One. 2012;7(11):e49215.
  87. Raynaud A, Ghezali L, Gloaguen V, et al. Honey-induced macrophage stimulation: AP 1 and NF-B activation and cytokine production are unrelated to LPS content of honey. Int Immunopharmacol. 2013;17(3):874–879.
  88. Farida F, Nizar A, Nurlina W, Agus R. Effectiveness of Honey Dressing on Healing of Diabetic Foot Ulcer: Systematic Review. International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation. 2020;24(7).
  89. Li S, Xiao T, Ye N, et al. Effect of honey dressing in the management of diabetic foot ulcers: A meta- analysis. Int Wound J. 2023;20(7)::2626–2633.
  90. Jan WA, Shah H, Khan M, et al. Comparison of conventional pyodine dressing with honey dressing for the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers. J Postgrad Med Inst. 2012;26(4):402–407.
  91. Bahar A, Saeedi M, Kashi Z, et al. The Effect of Aleo vera and Honey Gel in Healing Diabetic Foot Ulcers. Journal of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences. 2015;25(128):113–117.
  92. Al Saeed M. Prospective randomized comparison of controlled release ionic silver hydrophilic dressings and medicated honey impregnated dressings in treating neuropathic diabetic foot ulcer. Saudi J Health Sci. 2019; 8(1):25–30.
  93. Surahio AR, Khan AA, Farooq M, et al. Role of honey in wound dressing in diabetic foot ulcer. J. Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad. 2014;26(3)304–306.
  94. Teobaldi I, Stoico V, Perrone F, et al. Honey dressing on a leg ulcer with tendon exposure in a patient with type 2 diabetes. Endocrinol Diabetis Metab Case Rep. 2018;2018:18–0117.
  95. Imran M, Hussain MB, Baig M. A randomized, controlled clinical trial of honey-impregnated dressing for treating diabetic foot ulcer. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2015;25(10):721–725.
  96. Everett E, Mathioudakis N. Update on management of diabetic foot ulcers. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2018;1411(1):153–165.
  97. Holubová A, Chlupáˇcová L, Krocová J, et al. The Use of Medical Grade Honey on Infected Chronic Diabetic Foot Ulcers—A Prospective Case-Control Study. Antibiotics. 2023;12(9):1364.
  98. Delshad E, Tavakkoli Kakhki M, Motavasselian M. Successful Repair of Diabetic Foot Ulcer with Honey-Based Treatment: A Case Report. Iran Red Crescent Med J. 2017;19(3):e41939.
  99. Nuwa M, Alivian G, Utama J, et al. Effectiveness of honey in treatment of diabetic foot ulcers: A systemic review. The 8th International Nursing Conference. Education, Practice and Research Development in Nursing. 2018.
  100. Karimi Z, Behnammoghadam M, Rafiei H, et al. Impact of olive oil and honey on healing of diabetic foot: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol. 2019:12:347–354.
  101. Satarian F, Ghiyasi Y, Shafiei S, et al. Enhanced hemocompatibility and antioxidant efficacy of chitosan-PCL nanofibrous mats with olive oil and honey nika cream for wound healing applications. Journal of Drug Delivery Science and Technology. 2024;100:106138.
  102. Zekry S, Abdellatif A, Azzazy H. Fabrication of pomegranate/honey nanofibers for use as antibacterial wound dressings. Wound Medicine. 2020;28:100181.
  103. Chauhan H, Meman A, Patel Y. Study of comparison between honey dressing and betadine dressing in diabetic foot patient. IOSR J Dent Med Sci. 2019;19(6):58–65.
  104. Majtan J. Methylglyoxal—a Potential Risk Factor of Manuka Honey in Healing of Diabetic Ulcers. Evid Based Complement Altern Med. 2011:295494.
  105. Al Saeed M. Therapeutic Efficacy of Conventional Treatment Combined with Manuka Honey in the Treatment of Patients with Diabetic Foot Ulcers: A Randomized Controlled Study. Egypt J Hosp Med. 2013; 53:1064–1071.
  106. Tsang K, Kwong E, Chung J, et al. A pilot randomized, controlled study of nanocrystalline silver, manuka honey, and conventional dressing in healing diabetic foot ulcer. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2017;2017:1–15.
  107. Purnama A, Prasetya GK, Andini A, et al. Honey dressing intervention with diabetic foot ulcer: systematic review. SJIK. 2021;10(1):1329–1338.
  108. Mujica V, Orrego R, Fuentealba R, et al. Propolis as an Adjuvant in the Healing of Human Diabetic Foot Wounds Receiving Care in the Diagnostic and Treatment Centre from the Regional Hospital of Talca. J Diabetes Res. 2019;2507578.
  109. Rasoulian, Zandi M, Djavid G, et al. The effect of propolis and honey lotion on improving diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetes Manag. 2021;11(S3):37–43.
  110. Sharaf S, El-Naggar ME. Wound dressing properties of cationized cotton fabric treated with carrageenan/cyclodextrin hydrogel loaded with honey bee propolis extract. Int J Biol Macromol. 2019:133:583–591.
  111. Lotfy M, Badra G, Byrham W, et al. Combined use of honey, bee propolis and myrrh in healing a deep, infected wound in a patient with diabetes mellitus. Br J Biomed Sci. 2006;63(4):171–173.
  112. Astrada A, Nakagami G, Jais S, et al.  Successful treatment of a diabetic foot ulcer with exposed bone using Trigona honey: a case study. J Wound Care. 2019;28(Sup 12):S4–S8.
  113. Habryka C, Socha R, Juszczak L. The Effect of Enriching Honey with Propolis on the Antioxidant Activity, Sensory Characteristics, and Quality Parameters. Molecules. 2020;25(5):1176.
  114. Seven T, Seven I, Baykalir G, et al. Nanotechnology and nano-propolis in animal production and health: An overview. Ital J Anim Sci. 2018; 17(4):921–30.
  115. Barsola B, Kumari P. Green synthesis of nano-propolis and nanoparticles (Se and Ag) from ethanolic extract of propolis, their biochemical characterization: A review. DE Gruyter, Green Processing and Synthesis. 2022;11:659–673.
  116. Kustiawan P, Syaifie P, Siregar K, et al. New insights of propolis nanoformulation and its therapeutic potential in human diseases. ADMET & DMPK. 2024;12(1):1–26.
  117. Alarsan S. From Bees to Bandages: Exploring Honey Nanoparticles for Effective Wound Management. Bee Studies. 2023;15(1):37–40.
  118. Tang AB, Lan Z, Liang C, et al. Honey loaded alginate/PVA nanofibrous membrane as potential bioactive wound dressing. Carbohydrate Polymers. 2019;219:113–120.
  119. Al-Hatamleh, Alshaer W, Hatmal M, et al. Applications of Alginate-Based Nanomaterials in Enhancing the Therapeutic Effects of Bee Products. Frontiers in Molecular Biosciences. 2022;9:865833.
  120. Bahari N, Hashim N, Akim A, et al. Recent Advances in Honey-Based Nanoparticles for Wound Dressing: A Review. Nanomaterials. 2022;12(15):2560.
  121. Liu Y, Li, Feng, et al. Advances in the Preparation of Nanofiber Dressings by Electrospinning for Promoting Diabetic Wound Healing. Biomolecules. 2022;12(12):1727.
  122. Voss GT, Gularte MS, Vogt AG, et al. Polysaccharide-based film loaded with vitamin C and propolis: A promising device to accelerate diabetic wound healing. Int J Pharm. 2018;552(1–2):340–351.
  123. Cesar PHS, Natarelli CVL, Oliveira JED, et al. Development and Characterization of a Poly (Vinyl Alcohol) and Sodium Alginate Blend Foam for Wound Dressing Loaded with Propolis and All- Trans Retinoic Acid. J Appl Polym Sci. 2021;138(21).
  124. Jaldin-Crespo L, Silva N, Martínez J.  Nanomaterials Based on Honey and Propolis for Wound Healing, A Mini-Review. Nanomaterials. 2022;12(24):4409.
  125. Oprică G, Panaitescu D, Brîndu S, et al. Plant-Derived Nanocellulose with Antibacterial Activity for Wound Healing Dressing. Pharmaceutics. 2023;15(12):2672.
  126. Geyik F, Kaya S, Yılmaz D, et al. Propolis-Loaded Poly(lactic-co- glycolic Acid) Nanofibers: An In Vitro Study. ACS Omega. 2024;9(12):14054−14062.
  127. Hozzein W, Badr G, Badr B, et al.  Bee venom improves diabetic wound healing by protecting functional macrophages from apoptosis and enhancing Nrf2, Ang-1 and Tie-2 signaling. Mol Immunol. 2018;103:322–335.
  128. Othman A, Hamada H, Mohamed G, et al. Clinical and histopathological responses to bee venom phonophoresis in treating venous and diabetic ulcers: a single-blind randomized controlled trial. Front Med (Lausanne). 2023;10:1085544.
  129. Souza C, de Freitas L, Campos P. Topical Formulation Containing Beeswax-Based Nanoparticles Improved In Vivo Skin Barrier Function. AAPS Pharm Sci Tech. 2017;18(7):2505–2516.
  130. Frydman GH, Olaleye D, Annamalai D, et al. Manuka honey microneedles for enhanced wound healing and the prevention and/or treatment of Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) surgical site infection. Sci Rep. 2020;10:13229.
  131. Parin FN, Terzioğlu P, Sicak Y, et al. Pine honey–loaded electrospun poly (vinyl alcohol)/gelatin nanofibers with antioxidant properties. J Text Inst. 2021;112(8):1–8.
  132. Ajeng D, Plashintania D, Putri R, et al. Synthesis of zinc oxide nanoparticles using methanol propolis extract (Pro- ZnO NPs) as antidiabetic and antioxidant. PLOS ONE. 2023;18(7):e0289125.
  133. Sarhan W, Azzazi H. Apitherapeutics and phage-loaded Nanofibers As Wound Dressings With Enhanced Wound Healing and Antibacterial Activity. Nanomedicine. 2017;12(17):2055–2067.
  134. Oliveira RN, McGuinness GB, Rouze R, et al. PVA hydrogels loaded with a Brazilian propolis for burn wound healing applications. J Appl Polym Sci. 2015,;132:132.
  135. Chopra H, Bibi S, Kumar S, et al. Preparation and evaluation of chitosan/PVA based hydrogel films loaded with honey for wound healing application. Gels. 2022;8(2):111.
  136. Amin M, Abdel-Raheem I. Accelerated wound healing and anti-inflammatory effects of physically cross linked polyvinyl alcohol–chitosan hydrogel containing honey bee venom in diabetic rats. Arch Pharm Res. 2014;37(8):1016–1031.
  137. Noori S, Kokabi M, Hassan ZM. Poly(vinyl alcohol) / chitosan/ honey/ clay responsive nanocomposite hydrogel wound dressing. J Appl Polym Sci. 2018;135:46311.
  138. Yasin, Said Z, Nadia Halib, et al. Polymer-Based Hydrogel Loaded with Honey in Drug Delivery System for Wound Healing Applications. Polymers. 2023;15:3085.
  139. Tsang K, Kwong E, Shing-Shun T, et al. A Pilot Randomized, Controlled Study of Nanocrystalline Silver, Manuka Honey, and Conventional Dressing in Healing Diabetic Foot Ulcer. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2017;2017:5294890.
  140. Reyes L, Ghim M, Kang N, et al. Development and assessment of modified– honeycomb - structure scaffold for bone tissue engineering. Addit Manuf. 2022;54:102740.
  141. Chopra H, Mohanta Y, Mahanta S, et al. Recent updates in nanotechnological advances for wound healing: A narrative review. Nanotechnology Reviews. 023;12:20230129.
  142. Escárcega-Galaz AA, Cruz-Mercado JLDL, López-Cervantes J, et al. Chitosan treatment for skin ulcers associated with diabetes. Saudi J Biol Sci. 2018;25(1):130–135.
  143. Andriotis EG, Eleftheriadis GK, Karavasili C, et al. Development of bio-active patches based on Pectin for the treatment of Ulcers and wounds using 3D-bioprinting technology. Extrem Wounds. 2021;22(1):518–523.
  144. Karadeniz E, Serin E. Use of honey in diabetic foot ulcer: Systematic review and meta-analysis. J Tissue Viability. 2023;32(2):270–278.
Creative Commons Attribution License

©2024 Abdul, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.