Research Article Volume 5 Issue 3
Physics, Rajamangala, University of Technology Thanyaburi, Thailand
Correspondence: Surarit Pepore, Physics, Rajamangala, University of Technology Thanyaburi, Thailand, Tel 0925202842
Received: November 12, 2021 | Published: November 23, 2021
Citation: Pepore S. The propagators for time-dependent mass harmonic oscillators. Phys Astron Int J. 2021;5(3):93-98. DOI: 10.15406/paij.2021.05.00240
In this paper, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass obeying the function of m(t)=mtan2νt is derived by the Feynman path integral method. The wave function of this oscillator is calculated by expanding the obtained propagator. The propagator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass is evaluated by the Schwinger method. The propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass rapidly growing with time is calculated by applying the integrals of the motion of quantum systems. The comparison between these methods are also discussed.
Keywords: Feynman path integral, Schwinger method, Integrals of the motion,Propagator
The research in deriving quantum solutions for a harmonic oscillator with time-dependent frequencies or with time-dependent masses (or both simultaneously) have intensive studied in the recent years.1–7 The main reasons for time-dependent harmonic oscillator very interesting is the application in many areas of physics such as quantum chemistry, plasma physics, and quantum optics. For example, Colegrave and Abdalla8,9 presented that electromagnetic field intensities in a Fabry-Perot cavity can be described by a harmonic oscillator with time-dependent mass and constant frequency. The standard tool in solving wave function of Schrodinger’s equation for time-dependent harmonic oscillator is the Lewis-Riesenfeld in variant operator method.10 The another method to solve the time-dependent harmonic oscillator problems is Feynman path integral.11,12 The Feynman path integral is the formulation which is invented for calculating the propagator. The propagator represents the transition probability amplitude of the system or Green’s function of the Schrodinger’s equation. The Feynman path integral was applied to derive the propagators for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass (m(t)=mcos2νt) and a harmonic oscillator with mass growing with time (m(t)=m(1+αt)2) by M Sabir and S Raja gopalan in 1991.3 The one aims of this paper is applying the Feynman path integral to calculate the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass obeying the function of m(t)=mtan2νt and then expanding the obtained propagator to evaluate the wave function. The another method in calculating the propagator is the Schwinger method.12 This method was first introduced by Schwinger in 1951 in solving the gauge invariance and vacuum polarization in QED. In 2015 S Pepore and B Sukbot applied the Schwinger method to evaluate the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass growing with time.13The another purposes of this article is employing the Schwinger method to derive the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass. The alternative techniques in deriving the propagator is applying the integrals of the motion of quantum systems. This method was first presented by VV Dodonov, IA Malk in, and V. I. Man’ko in 1975.14 In 2018, S Pepore applied the integrals of the motion of quantum systems to calculate the Green function for time-dependent mass harmonic oscillators,15dual damped oscillators, and coupled harmonic oscillators.16 The final aims of this paper is employing this method to calculate the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass rapidly growing with time (m(t)=m(1+αt)4). The organizations of this paper are as follows. In Section 2, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass having the function of m(t)=mtan2νt is derived by Feynman path integral method. In Section 3, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass is calculated by the Schwinger method. In Section 4, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass rapidly growing with time is evaluated by the application of the integrals of the motion of quantum systems. Finally, the conclusion is presented in Section 5.
The Feynman path integral for a harmonic oscillator with mass obeying the law of m(t)=mtan2νt
Colegrave and Abdalla9 demonstrated that the electromagnetic field intensities in a Fabry-Perot cavity can be described by a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass written by the Hamiltonian of
H(t)=p22msec2νt+12mcos2νtω2x2 (1)
Where m(t)=mcos2νt and is the frequency of a pulsating mass. This paper we will modify the time-dependent mass by imposing m(t)=mtan2νt . The Hamiltonian of this system can be described by
H(t)=p22mcot2νt+12mtan2νtω2x2 (2)
Where ω is the frequency of oscillator.
The Lagrangian corresponding with the Hamiltonian in Eq.(2) can be
expressed as
L(x,˙x,t)=12mtan2νt˙x2−12mtan2νtω2x2 (3)
By using the Euler-Lagrange equation,17 the equation of motion can be
written as
¨x+2νcotνtsec2νt˙x+ω2x=0 (4)
The Eq. (4) has the solution in the form of
x(t)=cotνt[AcosΩt+BsinΩt], (5)
Where A and B are constants and Ω2=ω2+ν2 . By imposing x(t′)=x′ and x(t'')=x'' , the classical path that connects the points (x′,t′) and (x'',t'') can be written as
xcl(t)=cotνtsinΩT{tanνt''sinΩ(t−t′)x''+tanνt'sinΩ(t''−t)x′} (6)
Where T=t''−t′.
The action of the classical systems can be calculated from
S(x,˙x,t)=∫L(x,˙x,t)dt. (7)
Substituting the Lagrangian in Eq. (3) into Eq. (7), the classical action becomes
Scl(t)=m2tan2νt''x''cl˙x''cl−m2tan2νt′x'cl˙x'cl. (8)
Inserting the classical path in Eq. (6) into Eq. (8), the classical action can be obtained as
Scl(t)=mΩ2cotΩT(tan2νt''x''2+tan2νt′x′2)
−mν2(tanνt''sec2νt''x''2−tanνt′sec2νt′x′2)−mΩsinΩTtanνt′tanνt''x′x''
. (9)
As suggested by Feynman [10], the Green function for a quadratic Lagrangian can be written as
K(x'',t'';x′,t′)=F(t'',t′)eiScl(x'',t'';x′,t′)ћ (10)
where the pre-exponential function F(t'',t′) can be calculated from Pauli-Van
Vleck18,19 as
F(t'',t′)=[i2πћ∂2Scl(x'',t'';x′,t′)∂x′∂x'']12. (11)
By applying Eq. (11), the pre-exponential function F(t'',t′) becomes
F(t'',t′)=[mΩtanνt′tanνt''2πiћsinΩT]12 . (12)
Substituting Eqs. (9) and (12) into Eq. (10), the propagator of this oscillator can
be written as
K(x'',t'';x′,t′)=[mΩtanνt′tanνt''2πiћsinΩT]12
×exp(−imν2ћ[tanνt''sec2νt''x''2−tanνt′sec2νt′x′2])
×exp(imΩ2ћsinΩT((tan2νt''x''2+tan2νt′x′2)cosΩT−2tanνt′tanνt''x′x''))
. (13)
The next task is calculating the wave function. Beginning by defining
z=e−iφ,φ=Ω(t''−t′), (14)
sinφ=1−z22iz,cosφ=1+z22z, (15)
α=√mΩћtanνt''x'',β=√mΩћtanνt′x′ (16)
the propagator in Eq. (13) can be rewritten as
K(x'',t'';x′,t′)=[mΩtanνt′tanνt''zπћ]12(1−z2)−12
×exp(−imν2ћ[tanνt''sec2νt''x''2−tanνt′sec2νt′x′2])
×exp{11−z2[2αβz−(α2+β2)(1+z22)]}.
(17)
By using the formula
1+z22(1−z2)=12+z21−z2, (18)
The propagator in Eq. (17) can be modified to
K(x'',t'';x′,t′)=[mΩtanνt′tanνt''zπћ]12(1−z2)−12
×exp(−imν2ћ[tanνt''sec2νt''x''2−tanνt′sec2νt′x′2])
×exp[−12(α2+β2)]×exp[2αβz−(α2+β2)z21−z2].
(19)
The next step is applying the Mehler’s formula [20]
(1−z2)−12exp[2αβz−(α2+β2)z21−z2]=∑∞n=0Hn(α)Hn(β)zn2nn!, (20)
Where Hn(α) and Hn(β) are the Hermite polynomials. The propagator in Eq.(19) becomes
K(x'',t'';x′,t′)=[mΩtanνt′tanνt''πћ]12
×exp(−imν2ћ[tanνt''sec2νt''x''2−tanνt′sec2νt′x′2])
×exp[−mΩ2ћ(tan2νt''x''2+tan2νt′x′2)]
×∑∞n=0Hn(√mΩћtanνt''x'')Hn(√mΩћtanνt′x′)e−iΩ(t''−t′)(n+12)2nn!.
(21)
By using the spectral representation of the propagator
K(x'',t'';x′,t′)=∑∞n=0ψ*n(x'',t'')ψn(x′,t′), (22)
The wave function of this system can be written as
ψn(x,t)=[tanνt2nn!(mΩπћ)12]12exp[−iΩ(n+12)t]exp[imν2ћtanνtsec2νtx2]
×exp[−mΩ2ћtan2νtx2]Hn(√mΩћtanνtx).
(23)
This section is the evaluation of propagator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass by the Schwinger method.12The procedures of Schwinger method are presented in Ref.13The Hamiltonian operator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass can be written as3
ˆH(τ)=ˆp2(τ)2msec2ντ+12mcos2ντω2ˆx2(τ). (24)
By solving the Heisenberg equations
iћdˆx(τ)dτ=[ˆx(τ),ˆH(τ)],iћdˆp(τ)dτ=[ˆp(τ),ˆH(τ)] (25)
and imposing the initial conditions of ˆx(τ=0)=ˆx(0) and ˆp(τ=0)=ˆp(0) ,
the position operator can be expressed as
ˆx(τ)=(secντcosντ′cosΩ(τ−τ′)−νΩsecντsinντ′sinΩ(τ−τ′))ˆx(0)
+1mΩsecντsecντ′sinΩ(τ−τ′)ˆp(0)
. (26)
By using Eq. (26), the momentum operator ˆp(τ)=mcos2ντ˙ˆx(τ) can be written as
ˆp(τ)=(mνsinν(τ−τ′)cosΩ(τ−τ′)−mΩcosντ′cosντsinΩ(τ−τ′)
−mν2Ωsinντ′sinντsinΩ(τ−τ′))ˆx(0)+(secντ′cosντcosΩ(τ−τ′)
+νΩsecντ′sinντsinΩ(τ−τ′))ˆp(0).
(27)
By applying Eq. (26) to eliminate ˆp(0) in Eq. (27), the momentum operator can
be rewritten only in terms of ˆx(τ) and ˆx(0) as ˆp(τ)=(mΩcos2ντcotΩ(τ−τ′)+mνsinντcosντ)ˆx(τ)
−mΩcosντ′cosντcscΩ(τ−τ′)ˆx(0). (28)
Substituting Eq. (28) into Eq. (24) and rewriting each terms of ˆH(τ) in a time ordered form with ˆx(τ) to the left and ˆx(0) ˆx(0) to the right with the helping of the commutator
[ˆx(0),ˆx(τ)]=iћmΩsecντsecντ′sinΩ(τ−τ′), the time ordered Hamiltonian operator ˆHord(τ) can be written as
ˆHord(τ)=(12mΩ2cos2ντcsc2Ω(τ−τ′)+12mν2sin2ντ−12mν2cos2ντ
+12mνΩsinντcosντcotΩ(τ−τ′))ˆx2(τ)−(mΩ2cosντcosντ′cscΩ(τ−τ′)cotΩ(τ−τ′)
+mνΩcosντ′sinντcscΩ(τ−τ′))ˆx(τ)ˆx(0)+12mΩ2cos2ντ′csc2Ω(τ−τ′)ˆx2(0)
−iћΩ2cotΩ(τ−τ′)−iћν2tanντ.
(29)
As presented in Ref.13 the propagator can be calculated by
K(x,x′;τ)=C(x,x′)exp(−iћτ∫0〈x(t)|ˆHord(t)|x′(0)〉〈x(t)|x′(0)〉dt)
=C(x,x′)exp(−iћτ∫0{(12mΩ2cos2νtcsc2Ω(t−τ′)+12mνΩsinνtcosνtcotΩ(t−τ′)
12mν2sin2νt−12mν2cos2νt)x2−(mΩ2cosνtcosντ′cscΩ(t−τ′)cotΩ(t−τ′)
+mνΩcosντ′sinνtcscΩ(t−τ′))xx′+12mΩ2cos2ντ′csc2Ω(t−τ′)x′2
−iћΩ2cotΩ(t−τ′)−iћν2tanνt}dt),
(30)
Where C(x,x′) is the function of x and x′ . The next step is integrating over time each terms of Eq. (30). The integrating of the first term in Eq. (30) can be obtained as
−imx22ћτ∫0(Ω2cos2νtcsc2Ω(t−τ′)+νΩsinνtcosνtcotΩ(t−τ′)+ν2sin2νt
−ν2cos2νt)dt=imν2ћcosντsinντx2+imΩ2ћcos2ντcotΩ(τ−τ′)x2.
(31)
The second term in Eq. (30) can be calculated by
imΩћcosντ′xx′τ∫0(ΩcosνtcscΩ(t−τ′)cotΩ(t−τ′)+νsinνtcscΩ(t−τ′))dt
=−imΩћcosντ′cosντcscΩ(τ−τ′)xx′.
(32)
The third term in Eq. (30) can be integrated as
−imΩ22ћcos2ντ′x′2τ∫0csc2Ω(t−τ′)dt=imΩ2ћcos2ντ′cotΩ(τ−τ′)x′2.
(33)
Finally, the last term in Eq. (30) can be evaluated by
−Ω2τ∫0cotΩ(t−τ′)dt−ν2τ∫0tanνtdt=ln[cosντsinΩ(τ−τ′)]12. (34)
Substituting Eqs. (31)-(34) into Eq. (30), the propagator can be written as
K(x,x′;τ)=C(x,x′)[cosντsinΩ(τ−τ′)]12exp(imν2ћsinντcosντx2)
×exp(imΩ2ћsinΩ(τ−τ′)[(cos2ντx2+cos2ντ′x′2)cosΩ(τ−τ′)−2cosντ′cosντxx′]).
(35)
Substituting the propagator in Eq. (35) into the equation of
iћ∂K(x,x′;τ)∂x′=〈x(τ)|ˆp(0)|x′(0)〉, (36)
the result is
iћ∂C(x,x′)∂x′=mνcosντ′sinντ′x′C(x,x′). (37)
After solving Eq. (37), the function C(x,x′) can be obtained as
C(x,x′)=C(x)exp(−imν2ћsinντ′cosντ′x′2), (38)
Where C(x) is the function of x .
Substituting Eq. (38) into Eq. (35), the propagator becomes
K(x,x′;τ)=C(x)[cosντsinΩ(τ−τ′)]12exp(imν2ћ[sinντcosντx2−sinντ′cosντ′x′2])
×exp(imΩ2ћsinΩ(τ−τ′)[(cos2ντx2+cos2ντ′x′2)cosΩ(τ−τ′)−2cosντ′cosντxx′]).
(39)
The final step is calculating C(x) by substituting Eq. (39) into the equation of
−iћ∂K(x,x′;τ)∂x=〈x(τ)|ˆp(τ)|x′(0)〉. (40)
The obtaining result is
∂C(x)∂x=0, (41)
which imply that C(x)=C=constant . The constant C can be evaluated by
applying the initial condition of the propagator
limτ→0+K(x,x′;τ)=δ(x−x′). (42)
The constant can be obtained as
C=√mΩcosντ′2πiћ. (43)
So, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass can be written as
K(x,x′,τ)=[mΩcosντcosντ′2πiћsinΩ(τ−τ′)]12exp(imν2ћ[sinντcosντx2−sinντ′cosντ′x′2])
×exp(imΩ2ћsinΩ(τ−τ′)[(cos2ντx2+cos2ντ′x′2)cosΩ(τ−τ′)−2cosντ′cosντxx′]).
(44)
This section has an idea from the calculation of the Green function for a harmonic oscillator with mass growing with time by S Pepore in 2018.15This paper will modify the Hamiltonian operator to ˆH(t)=ˆp2(t)2m(1+αt)4+12m(1+αt)4ω2ˆx2(t), (45)
Where α is a constant. The aim of this section is calculating the propagator corresponding to the Hamiltonian operator in Eq. (45) by the application of the integrals of the motion of quantum systems. Beginning by solving Heisenberg’s equation for ˆx(t) and ˆp(t) and imposing the initial conditions of ˆx(0)=ˆx0 and ˆp(0)=ˆp0 , the position operator and momentum operator can be written as
ˆx(t)=1(1+αt)2[cosωt+2αωsinωt]ˆx0+(sinωtmω(1+αt)2)ˆp0, (46)
ˆp(t)=[(2mα(1+αt)2−2mα(1+αt))cosωt−(mω(1+αt)2+4mα2ω(1+αt))sinωt]ˆx0+[(1+αt)2cosωt−2αω(1+αt)sinωt]ˆp0 . (47)
By using Eq. (46) and Eq. (47), the integrals of the motion and can be expressed as
ˆx0(ˆx,ˆp,t)=[(1+αt)2cosωt−2αω(1+αt)sinωt]ˆx−(sinωtmω(1+αt)2)ˆp, (48)
ˆp0(ˆx,ˆp,t)=[(mω(1+αt)2+4mα2ω(1+αt))sinωt−(2mα(1+αt)2−2mα(1+αt))cosωt]ˆx+[cosωt(1+αt)2+2αsinωtω(1+αt)2]ˆp. (49)
The Green function or propagator K(x,x′,t) is an eigen function of the integrals of the motion as
ˆx0(x)K(x,x′,t)=ˆx(x′)K(x,x′,t), (50)
ˆp0(x)K(x,x′,t)=−ˆp(x′)K(x,x′,t) . (51)
By applying Eqs. (48)-(51), we can write
[x((1+αt)2cosωt−2αω(1+αt)sinωt)+iћsinωtmω(1+αt)2∂∂x]K(x,x′,t)=x′K(x,x′,t), (52)
[x((mω(1+αt)2+4mα2ω(1+αt))sinωt−(2mα(1+αt)2−2mα(1+αt))cosωt)
−iћ(cosωt(1+αt)2+2αsinωtω(1+αt)2)∂∂x]K(x,x′,t)=iћ∂K(x,x′,t)∂x′.
(53)
For solving the propagator, we must rewrite Eq. (52) and Eq. (53) to
∂K(x,x′,t)∂x=imωћ{((1+αt)4cotωt−2αω(1+αt)3)x−(1+αt)2cscωtx′}K(x,x′,t), (54)
∂K(x,x′,t)∂x′=−imωћ{(1+αt)2cscωtx−(cotωt+2αω)x′}K(x,x′,t). (55)
Solving Eq. (54), we obtain
K(x,x′,t)=C(x′,t)exp{iћ[mω2(1+αt)4cotωt−mα(1+αt)3)x2−mω(1+αt)2cscωtxx′]}.
(56)
The constant of integration can be calculated by substituting Eq. (56) into Eq. (55) to obtain
∂C(x′,t)∂x′=imωћ(cotωt+2αω)x′C(x′,t). (57)
Solving Eq. (57), the result is
C(x′,t)=C(t)exp[iћ(mω2cotωtx′2+mαx′2)]. (58)
Substituting Eq. (58) into Eq. (56), the propagator can be written as
K(x,x′,t)=C(t)exp[iћ(mω2cotωt((1+αt)4x2+x′2)
−mα((1+αt)3x2−x′2)−mω(1+αt)2cscωtxx′)].
(59)
The next step is calculating C(t). Substituting the propagator in Eq. (59) into the Schrodinger equation
iћ∂K(x,x′,t)∂t=−ћ22m(1+αt)4∂2K(x,x′,t)∂x2+12m(1+αt)4ω2x2K(x,x′,t), (60)
we obtain
dC(t)dt=(−12ωcotωt+α(1+αt))C(t). (61)
Solving Eq. (61), the result is
C(t)=C((1+αt)2sinωt)12. (62)
The final step is finding the constant by using the initial condition of the propagator
limt→0+K(x,x′,t)=δ(x−x′). (63)
The constant becomes
C=√mω2πiћ. (64)
So, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass rapidly growing with time can be written as
K(x,x′,t)=[mω(1+αt)22πiћsinωt]12exp[iћ(mω2cotωt((1+αt)4x2+x′2)−mα((1+αt)3x2−x′2)−mω(1+αt)2cscωtxx′)]. (65)
We have successfully derived the propagator and wave function for a harmonic oscillator with mass obeying the law of m(t)=mtan2νt by Feynman path integral, the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with strongly pulsating mass by Schwinger method, and the propagator for a harmonic oscillator with mass rapidly growing with time by the application of the integrals of the motion of quantum systems. The Feynman formulation base on functional integration. The Schwinger method concern with operator algebra. The method of VV Dodonovet.al is applying the integrals of the motion operators ˆx0 and ˆp0 . The pre-exponential function F(t'',t′) in Feynman path integral comes from the summation over all fluctuation amplitudes of classical paths. In Schwinger method, the pre-exponential function C(x,x′) appears from the commutator of [ˆx(τ),ˆx(0)]. In the method of VV Dodonov et.al, the pre-exponential function C(t) comes from the fact that the propagators is the solution of Schrodinger equation. These differences may shows the nature of classical mechanics which the physical observables are real numbers and the nature of quantum mechanics which the physical quantities are represented by operators. The propagator approaches in this paper are alternative methods comparison with the Schrodinger wave mechanics which base on finding wave function and the Heisenberg formulation which requires applying the creation and annihilation operators to derive the eigen functions of Hamiltonian operator. In propagator method, the wave function can be calculated by expanding the obtained propagator. In the calculation point of views, the Feynman path integral more simply than the Schwinger and Dodonov et. al. methods which some Hamiltonian operators have difficulties in solving the Heisenberg equation. However, having several methods in calculating the propagators may be usefulness.
None.
The author declares there is no conflict of interest.
©2021 Pepore. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.