Submit manuscript...
MOJ
eISSN: 2574-8130

Gerontology & Geriatrics

Research Article Volume 3 Issue 6

Optimization of complex conservative treatment to patients of advanced and old age with atherosclerosis obliterans of lower limb arteries Stage II

Makarov IV, Lukashou AV

Professor, Head of the Department of Surgical Disease, Samara State Medical University, Russia

Correspondence: Igor V Makarov, Doctor of Medical Sciences, Head of the Department of Surgical Disease, Samara State Medical University, Russia

Received: October 17, 2018 | Published: November 9, 2018

Citation: Makarov IV, Lukashou AV. Optimization of complex conservative treatment to patients of advanced and old age with atherosclerosis obliterans of lower limb arteries Stage II. MOJ Gerontol Ger. 2018;3(6):410-412. DOI: 10.15406/mojgg.2018.03.00156

Download PDF

Abstract

The article analyzes the results of treatment of 139 patients with chronic lower limb ischemia stage II in three parallel groups. The first group (n=57) received standard conservative therapy in combination with ozone therapy; when this group was divided into two subgroups: Subgroup 1a patients (n=28) was performed intravenous ozonized saline (ODF), 1b subgroups (n=29) - greater autogemoozonoterapiyu (BAP). Patients of the second group (n=62) underwent a comprehensive treatment comprising medical ozone in addition to gravitational therapy (ADT). In this group as two subgroups were distinguished: 2a subgroup (n=31) - patients receiving standard medical therapy in combination with HT and ODF, 2b subgroup (n=31) - in combination with BAP and HT. The third group, control (n=20) included patients receiving only standard medical therapy. The highest efficiency is noted in subgroup 2a. There was a statistically significant increase in pain-free walking distance by 200%, ankle-brachial index - 47%.In this same subgroup seen most pronounced positive dynamics of indicators of the quality of life of patients, which was confirmed by the most efficient correction scales questionnaire SF-36: physical component index increased by 32%, index of mental health - 29%.

Combined application of ozonated saline and gravitational therapy in patients with chronic lower extremity ischemia II step facilitates a significant increase in pain-free walking distance and ankle-brachial index and effectively improves the quality of life of patients.

Keywords: atherosclerosis, ozone therapy, gravitational therapy

Introduction

In spite of the great achievements of vascular surgery treatment of atherosclerotic lesions of lower limb arteries, still remains an actual problem of modern medicine. The main feature of said pathology is steadily progressive course.1–5

At the present stage nonmedicamental conservative therapies obliterating atherosclerosis lower limb arteries steadily gaining several positions and may even be more effective compared with surgery, especially in patients with II stage disease.6–10 The purpose of this work was to improve the results of complex treatment of patients with stage II atherosclerosis obliterating through the use of non-pharmacological exposure methods combining medical ozone and gravitational therapy.

Materials and methods

It was a prospective controlled study randomiziovannoe in three parallel groups in 139 patients with atherosclerosis obliterans of lower limb arteries IIA - IIB stages were on a planned in-patient treatment in the general surgery department MSH "CST station Samara JSC" Russian Railways ". The average age of patients with obliterating atherosclerosis of the lower extremities stage II was 71,24±8,49 years. The groups were statistically comparable.

All patients included in the study received standard medical therapy. Three groups of patients were allocated. Patients treated with standard medical therapy in combination with ozone therapy constituted the first (1) group (57 men, mean age 71.2±9.3 years). The group was divided into two subgroups: subgroup 1a-28 people - received intravenous administration of ozonated saline 1b subgroup - 29 people - most autogemoozonoterapiyu. In the second (2) group (62 patients, mean age 71.4±7.9 years) complex treatment include, in addition to conservative treatment and standard medical ozone therapy gravity. This group was also divided into two subgroups: subgroup 2a - 31 people - received conservative therapy in combination with ozonated saline and gravitational therapy subgroup 2b - 31 patients - conservative therapy with great autogemoozonoterapiey and gravitational therapy. 3 patients group (20 patients, mean age 71,0±8,4 years) was appointed only the standard conservative therapy. Treatment duration averaged 10,1±0,11 days.

Standard medical therapy in all groups included medical and physiotherapy treatment. To prevent depletion of endogenous antioxidants and avoid side effects during ODF and used BAP concentration gas mixture not exceeding 20mg/l, starting from a minimum (5-10mg/L) at the first two procedures, then passing on the therapeutic dosage. At the same time the introduction of ODF was conducted on a daily basis, and BAT - every other day.

Patients 2a and 2b further subgroups daily from the third treatment ODF and the second session BAT through 1 hour after their closure, gravitational therapy sessions carried (only 8-10 sessions). For optimum adaptation to the gravitational accelerations carried out in therapy started gently with a minimum therapeutic dose1,5 G(32 rev/min) for 5-10minutes. Subsequently the rotation was gradually increased up to 10-15minutes and the number of revolutions to 36-38rev/min with the maximum overdrive level to stop2,5 G (Russian Patents: "Method for the treatment of lower extremity arterial occlusive atherosclerosis» № 2475275 of 08.08.2011 and "method of complex treatment of lower extremity arterial occlusive diseases» № 2523390 from 02/12/2013g).

It was conducted to evaluate the clinical effectiveness of treatments used by the research changes painless walking distance and ABI conducted before and after treatment. In carrying out the gravity centrifuge rotation therapy in conditions we investigated the dynamics of the system and the segmental blood pressure, with subsequent calculation LPI. In addition, patients completed a questionnaire SF36 quality of life.

Results

In the study of pain-free walking distance immediately after treatment there was a statistically significant maximum increase its Wilcoxon test at 200% in the subgroup 2a (P=0.00004), and 122% in the subgroup 2b (p =0.001) (Table 1).

Dates observed denia

Group 1(N = 57) S

Group 2 (N = 62)

Group 3 (N = 20)

Subgroup 1a (n = 28)

Subgroup 1b (n = 29)

2a subgroup (n = 31)

2b subgroup (n = 31)

Before treatment

100 (53,5-150,0)

100 (78,5-243,5)

100 (58,0-201,0)

87 (50,0-120,0)

98 (50,0-130,0)

After treatment

160 (120,5-243,5)

151(117,5-250)

300(200,0-384,0)

194(150,0-310,0)

145(90,0-228,0)

R

0.094

0,057

0.00004

0,001

0.54

Table 1 The distance of painless walking (m) before and after treatment, IU (25-75 quartiles)

Me-median, p-the difference between the indices before and after treatment.

Before treatment, all patients observed a decrease in ABI median when compared with the results obtained in patients without clinical and instrumental signs of atherosclerosis. In all test groups conducted after treatment significantly increased the LPI, LPI but the maximum increase occurred in the subgroup 2a- by 47% (p= 0.00001) and 2b-46% (p=0.00001) (Table 2).

Dates observed denia

Group 1 (N = 57)

Group 2 (N = 62)

Group 3 (N = 20)

Healthy good-volz (N = 17)

Subgroup 1a (n = 28)

Subgroup 1b (n = 29)

2a subgroup (n = 31)

2b subgroup (n = 31)

Before leche-tion

0.51 (0,61-0,66) *

0.5 (0,41-0.55) ^

0.51(0,41-0.58) ^

0.47(0,41-0,49) *

0.48(0.43-0.50) *

1.16(1,11-1,20)

After treatment

0.64(0,52-0.73) ^

0.6 (0,52-0,68) ^

0.75(0,68-0,83) ∞ × # ^

0.68(0,63-0.77) # ^

0.52(0,55-0,49) *

R

0.0002

0.00009

0.00001

0.00001

0,003

-

Table 2 Changing LPI before and after treatment, Me (25-75 quartiles)

Me -median, p-statistically significant differences between the indices before and after treatment, *- statistically significant difference from the group of indicators without clinical and instrumental symptoms of atherosclerosis, #-statistically significant differences with the control group 3,∞ - statistically significant difference from subgroup 1a,× - statistically significant differences with the subgroup 2b. In group 2 patients, the treatment in which included and gravitational therapy and medical ozone were monitored LPI scheme:

  1. lying at rest, when placing the patient on a short radius centrifuge cradle action
  2. during a session gravitational therapy, in the seventh minute rotation
  3. immediately after stopping the centrifuge (Figure 1).

Figure 1 Changes in the ankle-brachial index during the sessions of gravitational therapy, Me (25-75 quartiles), P2A-2b <0.05.

During the first two sessions of gravitational therapy changes in blood flow in the arteries of the lower extremities were not significant, due to the adaptive mode load (1,5 G for 10minutes). Median LPI during adaptation session in the subgroup 2a, where the patients were pretreated with ozonated saline increased by 24% (p=0.04) from 0.58 to 0.72 and immediately after stopping decreased and did not differ significantly from the initial readings (p=0.09). In a subgroup of figure 2b the seventh minute gravitational therapy increased by 18% (p=0.05) from 0.55 to 0.65, and immediately after stopping the centrifuge has not changed significantly (p= 0.12) (Figure 1).

When conducting multiple comparisons during the next sessions of gravitational therapy with nominal modes of rotation of 36-38rpm, the monitoring of ABI showed more significant changes in the macrohemodynamics of the lower extremities. During the third session, a more pronounced increase in the median ABI was noted, with the most significant in subgroup 2a - by 74% (p=0.00001) from 0.61 to 1.06 (during the hypergravity session ), and in subgroup 2b - by 65 % (p=0.002) from 0.57 to 0.94 (during the hypergravity session ). From session to session, there was a trend towards an increase in the median of the ABI indicator, which was measured before the session of gravitational therapy (Figure 1).

Thus, before the course of treatment, all the examined patients had stage II atherosclerosis obliterans of the lower limb arteries, while the majority of patients were in stage IIB-107 people (77%), II A in 32 patients (23%). After the course of treatment, the calculation of the coefficient of association φ was made. In the subgroup 2a, a statistically significant maximum effect was observed, where φ= 0.79, with p=0.01. The number of patients in this subgroup maximally reduced by 37%, not only due to the transition stage in II B IIA, but in step I in 6% of patients.

For the analysis of the SF36 questionnaire before and after treatment, the 8 scales were grouped into two main integral indicators: physical and mental well-being. When studying before the start of treatment, both indicators differed significantly from the data of healthy volunteers ( p>0.05). After treatment in the subgroup 2a, the indicator of the physical component was statistically significant and maximally increased by 32% (at p = 0.001), and in subgroup 2b - by 16% (at p=0.01). A similar trend was observed in the change in the index of mental health (an increase of 29% at p=0.009 and 17% at p=0.02, respectively ).

Conclusion

Considering the findings, it can be argued that the combined use of medical ozone (OFR or BAT) and gravitational therapy as part of complex treatment of patients with obliterating atherosclerosis has a pronounced positive effect on the course of the disease by stimulating the development of collateral peripheral blood flow and microcirculation. As a result of a comparative analysis, the highest efficiency was observed in the subgroup of patients receiving a combination of FEV and HT, where an increase in the distance of painless walking was noted by 200%, and LEP - by 49%.

The proposed method, including the combined use of OFR and HT, was easily tolerated by patients, was technically easy to implement and allowed to achieve good results in the treatment of patients with atherosclerosis obliterans of lower limb artery disease stage II, which allows it to be recommended for widespread use in clinical practice.

Acknowledgements

None.

Conflict of interest

Author declares that there is no conflict of interest.

References

  1. Kazantsev AV. Diagnosis of progressive course of atherosclerosis obliterans of lower limb arteries based on indicators of endothelial dysfunction. Medical Bulletin of Bashkortostan. 2011;1:28–31.
  2. Pizova NV. Atherosclerotic lesion of the carotid arteries in young patients. Clinician. 2014;1:28.
  3. Vinnik, Yu S. Quality of life in patients with obliterating atherosclerosis of the vessels of the lower extremities according to the questionnaire SF-36. Fundamental research. 2015;1−3:467–469.
  4. Zhdanov VS. Epidemiological morphological studies of atherosclerosis. Cardiological Gazette. 2015;1:52–57.
  5. Antozhskaya, Yu S. Lipid metabolism in patients with atherosclerosis, depending on the focal nature of the lesion and the severity of lower limb ischemia. Medicine. 2011;3:85–90.
  6. Polyakov PI. Obliterating atherosclerosis of the lower extremities in the elderly. Bulletin of new medical technologies. 2013;1: 98–101.
  7. Galkin RA. Gravitational therapy in the treatment of patients with obliterating diseases of the arteries of the lower extremities. Samara. 2006. 198 p.
  8. Kotelnikov GP. Gravitational therapy. Medicine. 2003. 244 p.
  9. Kostyuchenko AL. Efferent therapy. AL Kostyuchenko-SPb: Folio; 2003. 432 p.
  10. EI Nazarov, VG Wongai, TA Deaf. Pharmacological profile of ozone in the procedures of large autohemotherapy and intravenous infusion of ozonized saline. Bulletin of physiotherapy and balneology; 2012:6−9.
Creative Commons Attribution License

©2018 Makarov, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.