Review Article Volume 3 Issue 1
1University di Siena, Italy
2Department of Pediatrics, Siriraj Hospital Mahidol University, Thailand
3Novartis Vaccines and Diagnostics, Italy
Correspondence: Sirintip Sricharoenchai, Department of Pediatrics, Siriraj Hospital Mahidol University, Pediatric Infectious Diseases Unit, 2 Prannok Road, Bangkok 10700, Thailand
Received: December 27, 2015 | Published: January 11, 2016
Citation: Sricharoenchai S, Palla E, Sanicas M (2016) Seasonality of Respiratory Syncytial Virus - Lower Respiratory Tract Infection (RSV-LRTI) in Children in Developing Countries. J Hum Virol Retrovirol 3(1): 00076. DOI: 10.15406/jhvrv.2016.03.00076
Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV), an enveloped RNA virus with a non-segmented single-stranded negative-sense genome, is the primary cause of hospitalization in the first year of life for children in most parts of the world. The global estimate in 2005 indicated that at least 33.8 million episodes of RSV associated acute lower respiratory infection (ALRI) occurred worldwide in children younger than 5 years and most of these deaths occurred in developing countries. This study aimed to systematically aggregate and analyze published epidemiological data on the seasonality of RSV lower respiratory tract infections in young children in developing countries. Articles in English published between 2002 and 2014 were identified through literature searches in PubMed, Web of knowledge, and . The season in which RSV epidemics occur typically depends on geographical location and altitude. It is likely that several factors interact in complex ways in the development of epidemics under favorable climatic conditions.
Keywords: respiratory syncytial virus, rsv; seasonality; lower respiratory tract infection; children; developing countries
Lower respiratory tract infection (LRTI) is the leading global cause of death in children between 1 month and 5 years of age.1˗4 Clinical characteristics of RSV infection include upper respiratory infection with rhinorrhea and nasal congestion lasting between 7 and 12 days. Re-infection rates vary between 6% and 83% each year, showing that initial infection does not confer immunity to succeeding infection.5 By the age of 2 years, nearly all children have had RSV infection.6 More serious disease involving the lower respiratory tract may develop in older children especially in immunocompromised and cardiopulmonary disease patients.7,8 RSV season varies over time and from location to location.9,10 The start and end of RSV season can vary year to year, state to state, and can even vary within communities in the same region.9,11
In countries with temperate climates, RSV causes epidemics of LRTI among infants and young children during late fall, winter, and early spring. In temperate climate regions, the RSV epidemic pattern depends on the temperature rather than the rainfall pattern. Most communities with temperate climates have a well-defined season of 3 to 5 months usually starting in the Northern hemisphere in October or November and continuing until February or March, followed by a peak in activity in the Southern hemisphere. In the southern hemisphere, wintertime epidemics occur from May to September. In addition, RSV studies conducted in temperate climates have identified a biannual pattern in the peak of RSV epidemics and RSV hospitalization rates, whereby the severity of RSV seasons alternates between milder and more severe. However, this is not predictable, and the differences may be more related to climatic changes.12
This study aimed to systematically aggregate and analyze published epidemiological data on the seasonality of RSV lower respiratory tract infection in young children in developing countries (Table 1).
Country / Location |
Study Period |
Peaked Season |
Peaked Months |
|||||||||||
JAN |
FEB |
MAR |
APR |
MAY |
JUN |
JUL |
AUG |
SEP |
OCT |
NOV |
DEC |
|||
Mozambique, Manhica 15 |
Feb 99 - Jan 00 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Mozambique, Manhica 16 |
Oct 98 - May 00 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Mozambique, Manhica 17 |
Sep 06 -Sep 07 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Kenya, Kilifi 18 |
Jan 02 -Jan 03 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Kenya, Kilifi 19 |
Jan 02 -Dec 07 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Kenya, Kilifi 20 |
Jan 07 - Dec 07 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
South Africa, Durban 21* |
Jun 99 - May 00 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
South Africa, Johannes berg 22 |
Mar 98 - Dec 04 |
Autumn - winter |
||||||||||||
South Africa, Johannesburg 15* |
Apr 00 -Mar 01 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Nigeria, Ibadan 15* |
Jun 99 - May 01 |
Dry |
||||||||||||
Nigeria, Ibadan 23 |
n/a |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Ghana, Kumasi 24 |
Jan 08 - Dec 08 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Senegal, Sine Saloum 25 |
Jul 07 -Dec 07 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Gambia, Banjul 26* |
Oct 93 - Oct 02 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Gambia, Fajara, Sibanor 27 |
Oct 93 - Dec 97 |
Rainy |
Table 1 Seasonality of RSV respiratory illnesses in Africa RSV peaked months shaded *=detected throughout year.
Potentially relevant published articles were identified through literature searches of the following bibliographic databases: PubMed, Web of knowledge, and Embase. To access publications from developing countries that might not be included in those databases, searches in SciELO, Indian MEDLARS, Bioline International, and African Journals online were also performed. The following combination of MesH terms (Medical Subject Heading terms) and individual search terms were used: (Respiratory Syncytial Viruses OR pneumonia OR bronchiolitis OR respiratory tract infections) AND (developing country OR each individual country of the developing countries) for the epidemiological review, and (Respiratory Syncytial Viruses AND vaccine) for the review of vaccine development updates. The searches were restricted to studies of human subjects that were published in English between 2002 and 2014. Manual searches of reference from potentially relevant articles were also performed to identify additional studies that may have been missed using the computer-assisted strategy. For the purpose of this review, the developing countries were defined as the ones designated as such by either World Bank (low, lower middle and upper middle-income countries) or World Health Organization. Countries with a contradiction of development status classification between World Bank and WHO were included within the developing countries group for this review.
In tropical or semitropical climates, RSV outbreaks are frequently associated with the rainy rather than the colder season. The variation is less apparent in the tropics, where there is small fluctuation in ambient temperature. RSV epidemics appear regularly but with different patterns of seasonality. In northern tropical areas, the seasonality seems to be associated with a decrease in temperature and an increase in rainfall. In the equatorial regions, RSV appears to be present most of the year. There are definitely 7 to 8 months of the year when the prevalence is higher than in the other 4 or 5 months, with some increase during the dry months. Tropical areas south of equator have a seasonality that is associated with decrease in both temperature and rainfall. Geographic and climatic factors are clearly associated with epidemics, but it is uncertain whether this is related to spread of the virus, behavioral factors, or cyclic changes in a population’s immunologic susceptibility.13,14
The concept of RSV epidemic seasonality across continents and within geographic areas has been addressed in some of the reviewed publications. Here we present a summary of the publications from Africa, Latin America, Eastern Mediterranean, Europe, Southeast Asia and Western Pacific.
Africa
Reviewed articles were from Southern Africa, West Africa, and East Africa. No information on seasonality could be obtained from or Central and North Africa. The association of RSV epidemic periods with the wet seasons in tropical African countries is similar to observations of other studies from tropical countries with seasonal rainfall. The typical RSV season corresponded to the cold season in South Africa, where a temperate climate is observed. The discrepancy found within the countries might be due to interannual variation on viral seasonality.
The epidemic peak generally starts early in east African countries (Kenya, Mozambique) and South Africa then progresses to the West African countries (Senegal, Gambia, Ghana, Nigeria). The overall picture of RSV seasonality is in line with a previous publication describing that epidemics start at the very southern coast of Africa during the early period of the year and then move northward during the next 6 months.13 The isolation of RSV throughout the year in some African countries may be explained by the tropical climate and the concurrent HIV epidemic in the population which results in prolonged carriage of RSV and less evident seasonality.
Latin America
The seasonality studies in Latin America are from 4 countries -Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, and Chile. Mexico experiences the earliest RSV season, followed by Argentina and Chile. The seasonality of the RSV epidemics agrees with data from a previous study which found that epidemics occurred from north to south in South America.13 Studies from Brazil have shown a diversified seasonal pattern for RSV, probably related to the wide diversity of climate characteristics in the country. While in the north,15˗31 rainfall is the main climatic determinant, temperature variations play a more significant role in the south. RSV infections peaked in the coldest months in southern Brazil,32 the only region with temperate climate, similar to that observed in Argentina and Chile. In southeast region, the peak of RSV outbreaks have not been associated with rainy seasons nor the coldest months and the epidemics appeared to spread throughout many months33˗40 with one study detecting RSV cases throughout the year41 (Table 2).
Country / Location |
Study Period |
Peaked Season |
Peaked Months |
|||||||||||
JAN |
FEB |
MAR |
APR |
MAY |
JUN |
JUL |
AUG |
SEP |
OCT |
NOV |
DEC |
|||
Mexico, San Luis Potosi 42 |
May 03 - Apr 05 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Mexico, Mexico city 43 |
Jan 97 – Feb 98 |
Spring |
||||||||||||
Mexico, San Luis Potosi 44 |
Apr 09 – Mar 10 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Fortaleza (NE) 30 |
Jan 01 – Jul 04 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Recife (NE) 29 |
Jun 94 – Jun 95 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Salvador (NE) 28 |
Jan 98 – Dec 98 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Salvador (NE) 31 |
Sep 03 – May 05 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Uberlandia (SE) 36 |
2001 – 2004 |
Autumn |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Uberlandia (SE) 34 |
Apr 00 – Jun 03 |
Autumn |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Vitoria (SE) 41** |
Jul 97 – Jun 98 |
Summer to autumn |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Sao Paulo (SE) 39 |
May 04 – Sep 05 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Sao Paulo (SE) 40 |
May 04 – Sep 05 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Sao Paulo (SE) 33 |
Sep 00 – Nov 01 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Sao Paulo (SE) 35 |
Apr 04 – Sep 04 |
Autumn |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Sao Paulo (SE) 37 |
Jan 03 – Dec 03 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Sao Paulo (SE) 38 |
Feb 05 – Sep 06 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Rio Grande do Sul (S) 32 |
May 90 – Sep 90 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Brazil, Rio Grande do Sul (S) 32 |
May 91 – Dec 92 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Argentina, Buenos Aires 45 |
Jan 98 – Dec 02 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Chile, Santiago 46 |
Jan 89 – Dec 00 |
Winter |
Table 2 Seasonality of RSV respiratory illnesses in Latin America
RSV peaked months shaded **=detected throughout year except August and December, N/A = not available.
NE =Northeast Brazil, SE=Southeast Brazil, S=Southern Brazil.
Eastern Mediterranean
In desert climates, RSV infection has been associated with the cold season, a finding consistent with the pattern found in this review.14 The study from United Arab Emirates provided inconclusive data defining RSV seasonality as it was conducted for only 3 months (September to November).54 Seven out of eleven studies from the Eastern Mediterranean were spanned only for short periods less than 12 months, and probably were insufficient to obtain information on seasonality42˗57 (Table 3).
Country / Location |
Study Period |
Peaked Season |
Peaked Months |
|||||||||||
JAN |
FEB |
MAR |
APR |
MAY |
JUN |
JUL |
AUG |
SEP |
OCT |
NOV |
DEC |
|||
Iran, Tehran 47 |
Nov 97 – Mar 98 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Iran, Rasht 48 |
Nov 03 – Mar 04 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Iran, Tehran 49 |
Mar 08 – May 09 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Jordan, Amman 50 |
Sep 02 – Mar 04 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Jordan, Amman 51 |
Dec 03 – May 04 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Jordan, Amman 52 |
Jan 07 – Mar 07 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Kuwait, Kuwait city 53 |
n/a |
Winter |
||||||||||||
UA Emirates, Abu Dhabi 54 |
Sep 01 – Nov 01 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Egypt, Cairo 55 |
Dec 06 – Nov 07 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Pakistan, Islamabad 56 |
Oct 99 – Apr 00 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Yemen, Sana’a 57 |
Oct 02 – May 03 |
Winter |
Table 3 Seasonality of RSV respiratory illnesses in Eastern Mediterranean RSV peaked months shadeds
Europe
The quality and quantity of RSV seasonality information of developing European countries within the past 10 years was poor, and each available study covered only short periods (5-8 months).58˗60 Additionally, a study from Russia reported an unexpected factor of climate abnormality as a reminder that a single season may not be representative of the RSV season from year to year.58 Broader and longer studies should be considered in the developing European region (Table 4).
Country/Location |
Study Period |
Peaked Season |
Peaked Months |
|||||||||||
JAN |
FEB |
MAR |
APR |
MAY |
JUN |
JUL |
AUG |
SEP |
OCT |
NOV |
DEC |
|||
Serbia, Belgrade 59 |
Nov 08 - Mar 09 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Turkey, Istanbul 60 |
Oct 06 - Mar 07 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Russia, St. Petersburg &Tomsk 58 |
Sep 08 -Apr 09 |
Spring |
Table 4 Seasonality of RSV respiratory illnesses in Europe
Southeast Asia and western pacific
In the Southeast Asia region, epidemics occur in the equatorial region first (Indonesia), then appear in the countries above the equator during the following months. (Thailand, Vietnam, Malaysia), similar to the observation in an earlier study.13
In the Indian subcontinent, RSV seasons started from Pune in west India61 and Dhaka in Bangladesh,62 followed by Bhaktapur in Nepal,63,64 New Delhi65,66 and Ballabgarh in north India.67 The epidemics followed a south to north progression as previously described, except one study from Kolkata, India68 where the RSV season was typically earlier during the rainy season.13,14 Nevertheless, this study has shown contradictory results. There is a potential for substantial regional and geographic differences of RSV seasonality in China but only 3 studies were published in English and retrieved from the literature search.69˗72 Huge population, results discrepancy and evidence of climate change in China warrant further studies (Table 5).
Country/Location |
Study Period |
Peaked Season |
Peaked Months |
|||||||||||
JAN |
FEB |
MAR |
APR |
MAY |
JUN |
JUL |
AUG |
SEP |
OCT |
NOV |
DEC |
|||
Indonesia, Cikutra & Ujung berung 68 |
Feb 99- Jan 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Indonesia, Lombok island 69 |
Jan 00-Dec 02 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Indonesia, Cikutra & Ujung berung 70 |
Feb 99-May 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Indonesia, Lombok island 71*** |
Jan 00-Dec 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Indonesia, Lombok island 72 |
Jan 99-Dec 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur 73* |
1982- 2008 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur 74 |
Jan 82- Dec 97 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Malaysia, Kelantan 75 |
Jan 01- Dec 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Thailand, Khon Kaen 76 |
Apr 02-Aug 04 |
Rainy to winter |
||||||||||||
Thailand, Bangkok 77 |
Dec 07- Aug 09 |
Rainy to winter |
||||||||||||
Thailand, Nakhon Sawan 78 |
Nov 98-Feb 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Thailand, Nakhon Sawan 79 |
Nov 98- Feb 01 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Thailand, Sakaeo & Nakorn Panom 80 |
Sep 03- Dec 07 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Thailand, Sakaeo & Nakorn Panom 81 |
Sep 03- Dec 05 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Vietnam, Nha Trang 82 |
Feb 07-Mar 08 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
Vietnam, Ho Chi Minh 83 |
Nov 04 -Jan 08 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
India, Pune 61 |
Feb 02- Dec 04 |
Rainy |
||||||||||||
India, Kolkota 68 |
Jan 07- Dec 08 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
Bangladesh, Dhaka 62 |
1993 – 1996 |
Monsoon |
||||||||||||
Nepal, Kathmandu 63 |
Jul 04- Jun 07 |
Monsoon & winter |
||||||||||||
Nepal, Kathmandu 64 |
Jan 06- Jun 08 |
Monsoon & winter |
||||||||||||
India, New Delhi 66 |
Jan 07 -Dec 07 |
Winter |
||||||||||||
India, New Delhi 65 |
Apr 05- Mar 07 |
Autumn |
||||||||||||
India, Ballabgarh 67**** |
Oct 01-Mar 05 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
China, Lanzhou 84***** |
Dec 06- Mar 09 |
Winter to spring |
||||||||||||
China, Shanghai 85 |
Oct 06- Sep 08 |
Autumn to winter |
||||||||||||
China, Zhejiang 86* |
Jan 01- Dec 06 |
Winter to spring |
Table 5 Seasonality of RSV respiratory illnesses in Asia and Western Pacific
*= detected throughout the year.
*** = detected throughout the year except September to November.
**** = detected throughout the year except July and August (rainy season).
*****= detected throughout the year except July, August and September.
Despite various literature databases utilized to make this review as exhaustive as possible, some limitations exist.73 Only English literature was searched. This likely biased the findings by excluding some studies from certain regions such as China, and some countries in Latin America, Russia, and the Middle East where there may be substantial information in local language publications.74˗76
The season in which RSV epidemics occur typically depends on geographical location and altitude. It is likely that several factors interact in complex ways in the development of epidemics under favorable climatic conditions 77. Despite the increasing number of epidemiological studies of RSV-LRTI published over the past decade in developing countries, there are still clearly many areas that merit further study.78˗80 There is still a need to establish further RSV surveillance studies to improve the incidence estimates and to explore the extent to which national and regional variation in RSV infection rates exist in countries where there is a high burden and high mortality attributable to LRTI but lack of understanding of local RSV epidemiology. Future epidemiological studies should be conducted over adequate time periods to offset bias from temporal variation and to assess the long term variability of RSV seasonality.81˗85 Baseline data on incidence and seasonality of each geographic region can be useful in planning RSV vaccine trials in various geographies.86
SS, EP and MS contributed to the design and interpretation of data for this manuscript. SS, MS and DD were responsible for drafting the work and revising it critically for intellectual content. All authors agree to be fully accountable for ensuring the integrity and accuracy of the work and read and approved the final manuscript.
None.
None.
None.
©2016 Sricharoenchai, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.