Review Article Volume 11 Issue 1
Faculty of Ayurveda, Parul University, India
Correspondence: Kshama Gupta, Associate professor, Faculty of Ayurveda, Parul University, Vadodara, Gujarat, 391760, India, Tel 7567222309
Received: January 03, 2018 | Published: January 29, 2018
Citation: Gupta K, Mamidi P. Some efficacious Ayurvedic panchakarma procedures in children with cerebral palsy. Int J Complement Alt Med. 2018;11(1):3-42. DOI: 10.15406/ijcam.2018.11.00344
Cerebral palsy (CP) is defined as a non-progressive neuromotor disorder of cerebral origin. Motor disorders of CP are accompanied by disturbances of sensation, perception, cognition, communication and behavior. In Ayurveda, there is no single condition/disease which exactly show similarity with CP. Most of the authors considered CP as vata vyadhi. Various Panchakarma procedures like Udwartana (medicated powder massage), Sarvaanga abhyanga (full body massage with medicated oil), Baashpa sweda & Naadi sweda (steam bath) and Vasti (oil and decoction enemas) etc are found to be beneficial in the management of CP in children. Present study is focused on panchakarma procedures which are commonly used and found effective in children with CP. Udwartana opens the minute channels and improves blood as well as lymphatic circulation. Udwartana is kapha, vata hara and removes aavarana or srotorodha. It provides a platform for further procedures like abhyanga, swedana and vasti. Sarvanga abhyanga, baashpa & naadi sweda reduce spasticity (especially scissoring phenomenon), improves flexibility of joints, improves circulation and reduces pain. Vasti is the major treatment for CP and it improves gross as well as fine motor functions, provides nourishment, improves overall general condition and quality of life in children with CP.
Keywords: panchakarma, ayurveda, cerebral palsy, vasti, sweda, nasya
Cerebral palsy (CP) is defined as a non-progressive neuromotor disorder of cerebral origin. Motor disorders of CP are often accompanied by disturbances of sensation, perception, cognition, communication and behavior. CP is classified into four types, spastic, ataxic, dyskinetic and mixed. Spastic CP accounts for a major portion of CP.1 In India, the prevalence of CP is estimated around 3 cases per 1000 live births. There is no known cure for all four subtypes of CP.2 Stem cell transplantation procedures, Botulinum toxin injections, intrathecal injection of baclofen, using various orthotic devices, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, neuroplasticity etc are the new advancements evolved for managing CP.1
In Ayurveda, there is no single condition/disease which exactly show similarity with CP. Some conditions explained in Ayurveda, which have shown some similarity with CP are, phakka (a kind of nutritional disorder), pangulya (locomotor disorders), mukatva (dumbness), jadatva (mental disorders), ekanga roga (monoplegia), sarvanga roga (quadriplegia), pakshaghata (hemiparesis) and pakshavadha (hemiplegia) etc., vatavyadhi’s (neurological disorders).13 Spastic CP can be considered as ‘Avarana janya vata vyadhi/Kaphavrita vata’. Vata vyadhi is the most similar condition to CP.3 According to some authors, CP in Ayurveda can be considered as ‘Shiro-Marmabhigathaja Bala Vata Vyadhi’.4
Ayurvedic Panchakarma (five major ayurvedic procedures and many allied procedures which are intended to cleanse the body) therapy along with appropriate internal medication can provide good improvement in quality of life of CP patients.1 It is well known fact that internal medication along with Panchakarma procedures is more effective when compared with only oral medications.2 Various panchakarma procedures like Udwartana (medicated powder massage), Sarvaanga abhyanga (full body massage with medicated oil), Baashpa sweda & Naadi sweda (steam bath) and Vasti (oil and decoction enemas) etc are found to be beneficial in the management of CP in children.5 Present study is focused on various panchakarma procedures which are commonly used and found effective in the management of CP in children.
Electronic database, ‘Google scholar’ has been searched for relevant studies and reviews published/appeared from 2007 to December 2017. The key words used for search are, ‘Udwartana in cerebral palsy children’, ‘Sarvanga abhyanga in cerebral palsy children’, ‘Naadi sweda in cerebral palsy children’, ‘Baashpa sweda in cerebral palsy children’, ‘Shashtika shali pinda sweda in cerebral palsy children’, ‘Vasti in cerebral palsy children’ and ‘Nasya in cerebral palsy children’. Abstracts and full texts of open access articles in English language were only considered.
Panchakarma is a collective term which indicates five major therapeutic procedures of detoxification to cleanse the body channels, along with many other supportive procedures. Literally, Panchakarma is made up of ‘Pancha’ means ‘five’ and ‘karma’ means ‘procedure/action’ (procedures of purification). Ayurveda treats diseases by using two different methods, shodhana (purificatory) and shaman (pacificatory). Shodhana means cleansing or detoxification of the body by expelling the deranged doshas (morbid materials inside the body causing various diseases). Shamana is pacification of symptoms without eliminating the morbid doshas. Typically, all treatment protocols ought to begin with shodhana, followed by shamana for better outcomes. When the body is saturated with toxins, the toxins interfere with the absorption of herbal medicines. Furthermore, it is necessary to eliminate ama (accumulated toxins in the channels) and to re-establish the homeostasis. The five main procedures within panchakarma are: vamana (emesis), virechana (purgation), nasya (nasal instillation of herbal oils/powders), basti or vasti (herbal enema), and raktamokshana (bloodletting). Primarily, these practices are aimed at eliminating ama (toxins) from to body and cleanse the channels. Each procedure is performed in three phases: Poorva karma (preparatory methods), Pradhana karma (main procedure) and Paschat karma (post-cleansing procedures which include dietary and behavioural regimen).6
Panchakarma is the ultimate mind body healing experience for detoxification of the body, for strengthening the immune system, to restore the balance and wellbeing. It is one of the most effective healing modality of ayurveda. Prior to panchakarma, poorva karma like deepana and paachana (appetizers and digestives), snehana (oleation) and swedana (sudation) are given to the patient. Ayurveda considers that the purification of the body is important before the commencement of any other therapy. Shodhana chikitsa (purificatory or cleansing procedures/panchakarma) is considered superior to Shamana chikitsa (treating with internal medicines) because the condition treated with shodhana therapy will never recur, whereas the condition treated with shamana therapy may recur in due course of time.7
Various panchakarma procedures like Udwartana (medicated powder massage), Sarvaanga abhyanga (full body massage with medicated oil), Baashpa sweda & Naadi sweda (steam bath), Shashtika shali pinda sweda – SSPS (sudation with a bolus prepared by boiled rice), Nasya, Shirodhara (oil drip over the forehead) and Vasti (oil and decoction enemas), are found to be beneficial in the management of CP.1‒19 Present study is focused only on few panchakarma procedures which are commonly used and found effective in the management of CP like Udwartana, Sarvaanga abhyanga, Baashpa sweda & Naadi sweda, Shashtika shali pinda sweda, Nasya and Vasti.
Udwartana
Rookshana procedure (dryness inducing procedure) like ‘Udwartana’ seems to be beneficial in reducing the spasticity in CP patients and it is suitable in ‘Amavastha’ (accumulation of waste materials inside the body) or ‘Kapha aadhikya’(predominance of kapha dosha) (Figure 1).5 Considering the Bahya karma (external procedure), the Uudwarthana is the rookshana poorvakarma (preparatory procedure which induces dryness) used with powders of medicines it brings the Rukshana at the level of superficial Dhadhus (tissues) especially at the level of Twak, Raktha, Mamsa and Meda (skin, blood, muscle and fat).11 For ama pachana (metabolizing accumulated toxins in the body) purpose rookshana procedure like udwartanam with ‘kola kuluthadi choornam’ (a medicated powder used for Udwartana) can be used. Udwartana brings lightness in body, improves appetite and relieves pain. After attaining niraamavastha by udwartana, snehana and swedana etc procedures can be started.20 Udvartana helps in reduction of vitiated kapha by its dryness-inducing and blockage-removing properties. Once aavarana (blockage) is removed, vitiated vata can be pacified by further treatment.1 Udwartana opens the minute channels and improves blood as well as lymphatic circulation.
Sarvaanga abhyanga
The term Abhyanga (Figure 2) is used as a synonym of oil bath. This is advised to be practiced daily. Oil in anointed all over the body, especially on the head, in the ears and on the feet. Specific oil should be selected according to the type of the disease or the temperament. For a person with vata temperament medicated oils like ksheerabala, balaguduchyadi, karpasastyadi etc; for pitta temperament oils like bhringamlakadi, manjishtadi, kayyanyadi etc; and for kapha temperament oils like eladi, asanavilwadi, marichadi etc can be used.21Abhyanga provides nourishment due to its snigdha (unctous), mridu (soft) and picchila (sticky) qualities. Vayu resides in sparsanendriya (skin) and massage is said to be as tvachya (good for the skin). Massage directly works on vata to bring it back to normalcy.1 Abhyanga along with swedana and vasti removes aavarana and srotorodha (obstruction of channels). Abhyanga and swedana together divert the dosha’s from shakha to koshta, later from koshta dosha’s can be managed by vasti or other panchakarma procedures. When vata comes to normalcy development of milestones will become normal.2 Abhyanga reduces increased muscle tone, improves muscle bulk and power in CP cases.3
Abhyanga involves cutaneous manipulation and it is considered as one of the prime procedures for mitigating vata. Primarily it acts by two mechanisms i.e., local and central. The local mechanisms include cutaneous stimulation causing the arterioles to dilate and thereby achieving more circulation. It also assists venous and lymphatic drains. This state of hyper circulation also enhances the trans-dermal drug absorption and assimilation. Massage improves blood supply to muscles, relieves muscular fatigue and reduces stiffness. Massage stimulates sensory nerve endings of the skin and gives abundant sensory inputs to the cortical and other centers in central nervous system. Snehana and Svedana are the prime procedures in treating various neurological conditions.4 Abhyanga procedure is the mechanical stimulation more precisely the pressure application during massage. Pressure application done in proper way can help in reduction of motor neuron hyper-excitability by reducing the alpha motor neuron activity. A study reported that in hemiparetic subjects the H-reflex was depressed during both continuous and intermittent tendon pressure. Intermittent pressure was found more effective than continuous. In a study, cerebral palsy symptoms in children were decreased following massage therapy.9
Abhyanga is Kaphavatahara, Pushti (health promoting) and Ayuvardhaka (increases life span). Abhyanga nourishes the superficial and deep muscles and make the muscles strong and joints stable. Abhyanga induce pleasantness and calming effects.10 The strokes used in Abhyanga like kneading; friction etc improves local circulation.13 The procedure which causes unctuousness, fluidity, softness, and moistness in the body is snehana or oleation therapy. Abhyanga and SSPS both cumulatively help in reduction of spasticity and facilitate free movement of joint preventing from deformities and contractures in CP cases.17 Massage of the entire body with medicated oils like Bala tailam, Narayana tailam, Prasarini tailam, and Mashadi tailam are very effective. Massage involving concomitant stretching maneuvers is very beneficial in patients with spastic diplegia resulting from CP.19
Baashpa sweda & Naadi sweda
Swedanam (sweating/diaphoresis/sudation) is a prerequisite for all shamana (pacifying treatments) courses and it provides temporary and lasting relief in many ailments. Many types of swedana are explained; among them ‘Baashpa sweda’ or ‘Ooshma sweda’ (steam bath) and ‘Naadi sweda’ (tube sweating) (Figure 3) are commonly used. In baashpa sweda the patient may sit or lie on a chair or on a wooden table and whole body is exposed to steam. Sweating is induced by means of steam coming from the fluid which may contain many herbs or other liquids such as dhanyamla (an alcoholic beverage prepared from grains) or wine or milk etc in baashpa sweda. In naadi sweda a spouted pitcher or pressure cooker (which should be filled with liquids and herbs) is used and patient is exposed to steam coming out of the spout or a tube which is fitted to a narrow-mouthed vessel (pressure cooker) over the required body part.22
Sudation causes excretion of waste metabolites through diaphoresis.1,8 Swedana along with abhyanga removes aavarana and srotorodha.2 Swedana is sthambhagna (relieves spasticity), Sandhichestakar (improves joint mobility), Srotoshuddhikar (cleanses channels) and Kaphavata nirodhaka (pacifies kapha and vata). Thus by its action the ‘Sroto sanga vighatana’ (removal of obstructions in channels) may take place and stiffness of the joints relieved.10 Swedana relieves heaviness, stiffness and coldness in the body parts.7 The treatment plan should be that of vatashamana in CP, vata being dominant dosha involved. Management of vata disorders includes snehana, swedana and vasti.19 Thus swedana procedures like baashpa sweda and naadi sweda both has an important role and proved their efficacy (especially in reducing spasticity) in the management of CP.
Shashtika shali pinda sweda
In SSPS (Figure 4) heat, massage and pressure are provided which nourishes muscles and stimulate nerve endings. This is the common method of swedana used in paediatric patients in which specific part or whole body made to perspire by the application of shashtika shali (a variety of rice) in the form of pottalis (boluses tied in a cotton cloth). Shashtika shali is cooked with milk and decoction of herbs. This cooked rice is to be kept in pieces of cloth to make pottalis. Remaining decoction and milk should be mixed and heated in low temperature to dip the boluses for warming the Pottali. After creating pottalis, patient is massaged with suitable warm oil and then warm pottalis gently applied. The procedure takes about half to one hour.15
Shashtika rice (Oryza sativa Linn) is Snigdha (unctuous), Bala vardhana (tonic) and Deha dardhyakrita (makes the body strong). The heat provided by bolus of Shashtika shali dipped in Balamula kwatha (roots of Sida cordifolia) with Godugdha increases the blood flow locally, relieve muscle spasm, increase tendon extensibility and provides pain relief. Bala absorbed locally provides nourishment to muscular tissue and prevents from emaciation. Combined effect of Abhyanga and SSPS (Figure 4) along with Physiotherapy helps to reduce spasticity, facilitate the free movement of the joints and to prevent development of deformities and contractures in CP patients. It also provides nutrition to muscular tissue thereby preventing from atrophy and detrimental changes.9 SSPS or Navarakkizhi is the most important sweda method used in hemiplegia, opisthotonus, emprosthotonus, wasting paralysis and other chronic vata diseases.22 SSPS is a Brimhaniya Snehika (tonic) sudation performed by bolus of boiled Shashtika Shali with Vatahara Kwatha (decoction of vatahara herbs) and milk.13 Thus SSPS is one of the most preferred method of swedana for CP patients where muscle wasting and weakness present.
Nasya
Nasya is the process of administration of medicines through nostrils. Nasya is indicated mainly in aggravated and accumulated doshas (disease causing factor) of head and neck. Commonly used medicines for nasya are panchendriyavardhan tailam, dhanvantaram tailam, anu tailam, shadbindu tailam and shunthi churna (powder of Zingiber officinale) for pradhamana nashya (nasal administration of herbal powders). Kashyapa has mentioned two types of nasya; namely Brimhana nasya (nourishing) and Karshana/Shodhana nasya (cleansing). During nasya the patient should sit or lie down in a comfortable posture, then applied gentle massage over the head, forehead and face followed by mild swedana. Slightly warm oil should be instilled in the prescribed dose in each nostril. After that gentle massage is to be performed on the plantar and palmar regions, shoulders and back. After the procedure, oil on the face is to be wiped off and advice to patient for gargling with warm water.15
Nasya karma is mainly intended to cleanse the channels in the head and neck region. The aggravated kapha dosha, which usually blocks the upper respiratory tract, is eliminated with the help of nasal instillation of herbal juices, oils, or powders. Herbal smoke (dhooma) is also used for inhalation through the nose to remove sticky phlegm from the channels.6 Nasya has a definite role in treatment of CP because it is said to be beneficial in various shiro roga’s (diseases of head/brain) according to Acharya Charaka. Pratimarsa nasya (nasya of small dose/nasya used for daily purpose) may have beneficial effects in patients of CP as it provides strength to shira (head) and shirogata indriyas (sense organ in head).19
Vasti:
Vasti is the procedure where the medicines in suspension form are administered through rectum or genitourinary tract using Vasti yantra (enema can or specific apparatus). Among all therapeutic procedures, vasti is superior because it is like amruta (nectar) for child patient and the most appropriate remedial measure for vata dosha. Vasti is prepared by using various medicated oils, kwatha (decoction) & kalka (paste prepared by herbs), madhu (honey) and saindhava (rock-salt) (Figure 5). The patient is advised to lie down in left lateral position. Small amount of oil is applied on patient’s anus and also on vasti netra (nozzle). The vasti netra is gently inserted into the anal canal up to a specific length and vasti putaka (pouch or bag) containing mixture (vasti dravya) is pressed with a uniform pressure. The pressure is continued till only small quantity of fluid remains in the bag to avoid air insertion. Then the nozzle is removed gently and the patient is allowed to lie down on supine position till he feels urge to excrete (Figure 6). After evacuation of the bowel, the patient may take hot water bath. Madhutailika vasti, bala guduchyadi vasti, patolanimbadi vasti, vaitarana vasti, mustadi yapana vasti, tikta kshira vasti etc are commonly used vasti preparations. Matra vasti is a type of sneha vasti (oil enema) in which medicated oil given in a small dose, and it can be given daily with no risk. Matra vasti can be used irrespective of age and not much precautionary measures are required. The usual dosage is 60ml. For infants the quantity of matra vasti is 20ml (Figure 6).15
Snigdha Basti (anuvasana with balatailam) (oil enema) is said to have brimhana (nourishing) effect. It is found that vasti improves the flexibility of joints in cases of CP by vatashamana.1,2,8 Vasti is ‘Ardha chikitsa’ (half of the treatment) of vata and most important panchakarma in CP. There are many types of vasti like niruha (decoction enema), anuvasana (oil enema) and uttara (enema given through urethra in males and through cervix in females). No other treatment has the capacity to pacify and regulate the force of vata apart from vasti. Vasti is the procedure in which the administered medicine through anal canal reaches up to umbilicus, hips, waists, loins and small intestine, churns the accumulated materials like dosha and purisha (feces), spread the unctuousness all over the body and easily comes out along with purisha and dosha (impurities).3 Vasti is advised for both children and aged persons, which is excellent both for the elimination of Doshas and nourishment of the body. Vasti therapy instantaneously promotes Bala (strength), Varna (complexion), Harsha (sense of exhilaration), Mardavatva (tenderness) and Snehana (unctuousness) of the body.4 Vasti is being the most widely used and highly effective treatment modality for treating neurological disorders. The pharmacodynamic action of vasti in alleviating symptoms of neurological manifestation in exact way is still not clearly understood.9
Matravasti (oil enema in small dose) is said to be Balya (strengthening), Brimhana (nourishing) and Vatarogahara (eliminates neurological disorders). Pakwashaya (large intestine) is the moola sthana (main seat) of vata dosha. Vasti by its action on the moola sthana gets control on vata all over the body. Rectum has a rich blood and lymph supply and drugs can cross the rectal mucosa like other lipid membrane and by entering general circulation, vasti acts on whole body. Vasti may block neuromuscular transmission by binding to receptor sites on motor or sympathetic nerve terminals, entering the nerve terminals, and may inhibit the release of acetylcholine.10 Matra vasti provides more nourishment to deeper dhatu’s (tissues).11 Vasti improves fine motor functions, general motor functions like crawling, sitting, standing, walking and clasping hands in CP patients. When compared with internal medicines, Vasti has improved fine and gross motor functions in CP cases. Vasti found beneficial in spastic diplegia.14
Sneha vasti improves overall nutrition. Vasti is having two actions, expelling the Dosha & nourishing the body as it is indicated in Gambhiragata vata (neurological conditions chronic and deep seated) also. Action of vasti is related with the facilitation of excretion of morbid substances responsible for the disease process into the colon, from where they are evacuated. Vasti drugs in Pakwashaya acts on whole body in a same way that of sun, which though placed in the sky, causes evaporation of water on the earth. Vasti dravya when administered into rectum may stimulate the sensory system due to its chemical composition and pressure effects over the bowel. As the total nervous system is interrelated, the regular stimulation on enteric nervous system has positive effects over central nervous system also. When vasti dravyas are passed through the gastrointestinal tract, it probably stimulates the cells (enterochromaffin cells or entero-endocrine cells) and act as secretogogoues thus compensates neurological deficit and improves the functions.12
Matra vasti (Figure 6) is a sub type of anuvasana vasti in which oil or ghee is given by rectal route in a small quantity. When medicated oil reaches rectum and colon, presence of short chain fatty acids in oil allows direct diffusion of drugs from epithelial cells in to capillary blood villi showing its generalized effect.17 Shodhana (detoxification) karma is performed mainly by niruha or asthapana basti (decoction enema) (Figure 5). The protocol is determined according to the disease and the patient’s condition.6 Vasti is restricted till the child has attained a crawling age. But anuvasana vasti (oil enema) is promoted from early infancy. As far as possible shodhana therapies (cleansing and purifying therapy) should be avoided in children.19 In children compared to niruha vasti, anuvasana and matra vasti’s are used commonly in the management of various neurological conditions. By considering all the above facts, vasti seems to be beneficial in children with CP.
According to the authors personal observations (Figures 7-10), udwartana brings lightness in the body or limbs and especially useful in flaccidity in CP cases. Whereas procedures like sarvanga abhyanga, baashpa & naadi sweda, SSPS and matra vasti are beneficial in reducing the spasticity like scissoring phenomenon, improves mobility or flexibility of joints, improves gross and fine motor functions, and quality of life in children with CP (Figures 7–10). Ayurvedic panchakarma procedures seem to be efficacious in children with CP.
Various panchakarma procedures have proved their efficacy in the management of CP. Udwartana opens the minute channels and improves blood as well as lymphatic circulation. Udwartana is kapha, vata hara and removes aavarana or srotorodha. It provides a platform for further procedures like abhyanga, swedana and vasti. Sarvanga abhyanga, baashpa & naadi sweda reduce spasticity (especially scissoring phenomenon), improves flexibility of joints, improves circulation and reduces pain. Vasti is the major treatment for CP and it improves gross as well as fine motor functions, provides nourishment, improves overall general condition and quality of life in children with CP. Further studies on large sample with accurate methodology are required to substantiate these claims.
None
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest in the publication.
©2018 Gupta, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.