Submit manuscript...
eISSN: 2576-4462

Horticulture International Journal

Research Article Volume 5 Issue 5

Impact of home garden interventions on household access to vegetables for nutrition security in kavreplanchok district of Nepal

Dhruba Raj Bhattarai,14 Sharmila Piya,1 Divyanshi Bhattarai,2 Bishwash Poudel,1 Kumar Mani Dahal1

1National Outreach Research Centre, Nepal Agricultural Research Council (NARC), Khumaltar, Lalitpur, Nepa
2 B.P. Koirala Institute of Health Sciences, Dharan, Nepal

Correspondence: Dhruba Raj Bhattarai, National Outreach Research Centre, Nepal Agricultural Research Council (NARC)

Received: July 27, 2021 | Published: December 3, 2021

Citation: Bhattarai DR, Piya S, Bhattarai D, et al. Impact of home garden interventions on household access to vegetables for nutrition security in kavreplanchok district of Nepal. Horticult Int J. 2021;5(5):187-190. DOI: 10.15406/hij.2021.05.00228

Download PDF

Abstract

The study was conducted during 2020-2021 to identify the contribution of home garden interventions towards household access to vegetables amidst COVID-19 pandemic in Nepal. Kavreplanchok district was the selected site of study wherein checklist, focus group discussion and field observation were the major data collection methods. Women in the treatment group participated in home gardening orientation and vegetable gardening activities, however, only data collection was done in the control group. Post-intervention data showed 46% households in treatment group practiced improved organic vegetable gardening technologies as compared to 10.67% in control. Furthermore, annual vegetable requirement met from home garden was 62% in treatment group, while it was only 36 % in control group. Similarly, the knowledge on nutrition, home gardening technology and proper handling of vegetables has increased significantly.

Keywords: nutrition security, COVID-19, organic technologies, vegetable home gardening

Introduction

The COVID-19 crisis has deeply perturbed the socio-economic sectors of Nepal by creating unprecedented challenges that further exacerbated the already existing pressure on food security and livelihoods of the vulnerable households. In collaboration with the Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock Development, WFP conducted a nation-wide phone-based survey to assess the impact of the COVID-19 crisis on Nepalese households, with prime focus on nutrition security and livelihood aspects. The objective was to examine the multifaceted impacts of the pandemic also chiefly identifying profiles of households that were relatively more affected.1 Food insecurity among low-income and disadvantaged families was found to be a serious problem during the COVID-19 pandemic in Nepal.2

As per nutritionists, the pandemic has rattled the entire nation and grave risks have been wrecked upon the nutritional well-being and survival of underage children. Vegetable home garden seems to be an effective and promising method for maintaining health even during these uncertain times.

Vegetables play a significant role in the human diet, makes it balanced and supplies most of the important natural elements. The nutritional value of vegetables is well recognized as it is a vital source of essential vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and dietary fiber. However, vegetable intake is very low in Nepal due to lack of proper knowledge and awareness among rural people.3 They give low priority to vegetables on their daily use as compared to cereal crops. Due to low consumption of vegetables, malnutrition has become a serious problem in Nepal. Nepal Demographic and Health Survey, 2016 shows that the 36 percent of children under five years of age are stunted, 10 percent are wasted, and 27 percent are underweight.4

The global literature recognize positive contributions of home gardens towards enhancing nutrition security for resource poor families in developing countries.5 Vegetables from the organic home gardens are good source of micronutrients especially in poor households. Studies suggest home gardens as a low-cost option to enhance nutritional status of rural people in Nepal.6 Similarly, a study from Lao PDR on home gardens concludes it to be an effective and sustainable means of improving nutritional standards of low income families.7

In Nepal women have a great role for including more vegetables in human daily food because women are involved in food preparation and serve the families’ favorite dishes.8 Therefore, essentially more emphasis must be given through the women organizations/groups by researchers to train the women as they have more contribution and accountability towards vegetable production. So, this study was conducted with a women farmer’s group to identify the effect of home garden interventions on technology acceptance, awareness and knowledge of nutrition, home gardening techniques and consumption of vegetables.

Methodology

Research was conducted at Mandandeupur Municipality, Kavreplanchok district during 2020-2021. Randomized Control Trial (RCT) design was used for the study. In RCT design, 50interested women were identified. Among those 30 members were selected randomly and divided into 2 groups with 15 members in each group for this research. The first group was treatment group where training as well as vegetable seeds for winter production namely Radish, Cress, Carrot, Broad Leaf Mustard, Cauliflower, Coriander, Turnip, Onion, Broad Bean, Pea, Fenugreek and Spinach were provided. Similarly, vegetable seeds for summer season production were Pumpkin, Sponge Gourd, Bottle Gourd, Bitter Gourd, Cucumber, French bean and Brinjal. Along with these vegetable seeds we also distributed them 50 liter drum, yellow sticky trap, neem based pesticide, EM and waste decomposer to promote organic home garden. Effective micro organisms (EM) is the well-known mixture of natural occurring and beneficial organisms. One of the function of EM is quick decomposition of compost and farm yard manure.9 Similarly, waste decomposer developed by National Centre of Organic Farming (NCOF) is also can be used for quick composting. Average land for home garden was 300 m2. Technologies promoted in the home gardens are as follows:

  1. Improved compost (use of EM &waste decomposer)
  2. Improved nursery
  3. Use of liquid manure
  4. Use of yellow sticky trap and neem based pesticide (organic pest control)
  5. Irrigation (water harvesting & use)
  6. Own seed saving
  7. Proper harvesting
  8. Cleaning &proper cooking
  9. Proper hand washing and dietary hygiene.

The home garden orientation training included topics such as home garden establishment, crop rotation, compost making, pest management and seed saving. Similarly, orientation on the role of vegetables for family health, the nutritional content of different food items, and cooking methods to preserve the nutritional quality of vegetables were provided.

Knowledge concerning nutrition, home gardening, harvesting and proper cooking were measured by using 1 to 9 scale suggested by10 in which 1 indicates the extremely poor and 9 for outstanding (1=extremely poor; 2=insufficient; 3=below average; 4=average; 5=above average; 6=good; 7=very good; 8=excellent; 9=outstanding). For this, questions related to home gardening& nutrition were answered by the women members. Based on cumulative marks obtained in all questions, knowledge level was estimated. The pre-intervention test was designed, in order to determine the baseline pattern of technological knowledge and nutrition. The post-intervention test period began immediately after one year vegetable gardening cycle was completed. Vegetables were harvested from home gardens 2-4 times every week from July 2020 to June 2021. Before consumption, harvested vegetables were weighted for calculating total yield.

Results

Households practicing home garden technologies

Nine verified organic technologies were promoted in research site (Table 1). Maximum households (58.33%) practiced improved composting technology followed by liquid manure and use of yellow sticky trap and neem based pesticide. However, minimum practice was associated with cleaning and proper cooking (23.33% hh). As organically grown vegetables are cultivated without the use of pesticides and chemical fertilizers, they are less contaminated with pesticide residue.11 Therefore, organic vegetables ensure better nutritional benefits and health safety. In this study technology practicing rate was highly increased within the two vegetable growing seasons. A study of home gardens in Cuba reveals that they were used as a strategy to increase resilience and ensure food security in the face of economic crisis and political isolation.12

Technology/intervention

Pre-intervention (Household % practiced home garden technology)

Post-intervention (Household % practiced home garden technology)

Control

Treatment

Control

Treatment

Improved compost (use of EM &waste decomposer)

6.33

3.33

6

58.33

Improved nursery

12.33

13

14

48.33

Use of liquid manure

10

7.67

6.33

56.33

Use of yellow sticky trap and neem based pesticide

12.33

11.33

10

55

Irrigation (water harvesting & use)

3

3.67

5.67

38.33

Own seed saving

20

21.67

19

41.67

Proper harvesting

7.67

6.67

10

46.67

Cleaning &proper cooking

10

11.67

10

23.33

Proper hand washing and dietary hygiene

20

21.67

15

43.33

Average households %

11.3

11.19

10.67

45.7

Table 1 Percentage of households practicing improved home garden technologies (2020-2021)

Vegetables availability at household level

An assessment of the home garden intervention in 2020-2021 found a positive effect on vegetable sufficiency at the household level. The findings showed that 62 percent of the vegetable requirements of the rural households was met by home garden products (Table 2). After intervention, household's vegetable production increased by 69% in treatment group and that increased by 4.76% in control group.

Period

Pre-intervention

Post-intervention

Control

Treatment

Control

Treatment

July –September

53.33

56.67

58.33

81.67

October-December

35

33.33

30.33

60

January-March

26.67

28.33

27.67

53.33

April –June

31.67

30

34.67

61

Whole year

26.67

25

30.67

53.33

Average

34.68

36.67

36.33

61.86

Table 2 Vegetable requirement percent meet from home garden (2020-2021)

Similar study was conducted13 in a rural village in Kwa Zulu-Natal in South Africa and found that production of yellow and dark green leafy vegetable in home gardens significantly improved vegetable intake and Vitamin A status of children between the ages of two to five years. Likewise, a home garden model tested in rural households in Bangladesh has reported reduced expenses on vegetables, improved intake of fresh fruits and vegetables.14 Home garden interventions have improved vegetable intake, however, there is a need to strengthen their efficiency. Other strategies like capacity building, awareness and sensitization should be adopted.

Participants' knowledge on nutrition, home gardening and proper cooking

Data considering knowledge of treatment group on nutrition, home gardening and proper harvesting and cooking was recorded pre-intervention and post-intervention. Pre-intervention data revealed that the knowledge of nutrition, home gardening techniques, proper handling and cooking was very poor. However, post intervention data showed that was significantly increased after receiving the home garden treatments (Figure 1). Fresh vegetables are the cheapest source of vitamins and minerals and that are high value food source for poorest family.15 There is a great need to create awareness among the community people about importance of vegetables in human nutrition and its losses due to poor handling and cooking. Frying and mashing with lots of spices is also one reason for loss of nutrients.16 Also drying and heating of fresh vegetables result in the destruction of vitamins and antioxidants. Therefore, women (housewives) need to be made aware about loss of vitamins and nutrients during cutting, washing and overcooking.

Figure 1 Effect of home garden interventions on knowledge level of participants on nutrition, home gardening techniques, harvesting and proper cooking (2020-2021).

Vegetable yield per household per year

The yield of vegetables in home gardens were recorded from July 2020 to June 2021. Vegetables were harvested from home garden depending upon their stage of maturity. Before consumption, harvested vegetables were weighted for calculating total yield. Home gardens yielded the maximum 600 kg and minimum 290 kg vegetables annually. Average vegetable yield in treatment group was recorded to be 468 kg per household per year (Table 3). The calculated yield data suggested that home garden (300 m2 land) could significantly improve household access to vegetables in Nepal.

SN

Name of women participant

Vegetable production (Kg.)

1

Shiba Kumari Parajuli

550

2

Debaki Timalsina

480

3

Ganga Sapkota

520

4

Gouri Parajuli

570

5

Radhika Sapkota

380

6

Sabitra Parajuli

420

7

Makhamali Timalsina

500

8

Sarmila Timalsina

340

9

Gita Nepal

580

10

Kamala Sapkota

600

11

Sarmila Sapkota

290

12

Sosthani Sapkota

400

13

Dhanakumari Poudel

470

14

Radhika Parajuli

600

15

Jayanti Nepal

320

Average vegetable yield (kg) per household per year

 

468

Table 3 Average yield of vegetables per household (300 m2 land) per year (2020-2021)

Conclusion

Generally, area surrounding the houses is wasted which can be utilized to grow vegetables for fulfilling the requirement of every home. One can make his surroundings fresh and attractive by growing vegetables in home garden. Home garden also helps us maintain our health as working in the home garden is a form of good physical exercise even during the COVID-19 pandemic. If every person learns the technology of using waste land near his house as a home garden, he will be able to provide vitamins and minerals in the form of vegetables which help to improve the health of his family members. However, vegetables should be properly handled before consuming in order to maintain good health. Recognizing the value and potential of home garden in promoting nutrition security, many activities need to be initiated by the Government of Nepal.

Acknowledgments

We would like to express our sincere gratitude to the Nepal Agricultural Research Council (NARC) for providing all facilities to complete this study. We would also like to acknowledge all the members of the women farmers’ group for their enthusiastic participation and cooperation during the research.

References

  1. WFP Nepal. The Impact Of Covid-19 On Households In Nepal. WFP Nepal; 2021.
  2. Singh DR, Sunuwar DR, Shah SK, et al. Food insecurity during COVID-19 pandemic: A genuine concern for people from disadvantaged community and low-income families in Province 2 of Nepal. Plosone. 2021;16(7):e0254954.
  3. Bhattarai DR, GD Subedi, TP Acharya, et al. Effect of School Vegetable Gardening on Knowledge, Preference and Consumption of Vegetables in Nepal. International Journal of Horticulture. 2015;5(20):1–7.
  4. Nepal Demographic and Health Survey Key Findings. Ministry of Health, Kathmandu, Nepal; 2016.
  5. Galhena DH. Home gardens for improved food security and enhanced livelihoods in northern srilanka. A dissertation Submitted to Michigan State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy; 2012.
  6. Bhattarai DR, KP Poudyal. Organic agriculture networking and technology in Nepal. Proceeding of asian network for sustainable organic farming technology. Bureau of soils and water management, Quezon City Philippines; 2012.
  7. Suri S. Nutrition Gardens: A sustainable model for food security and diversity. Observer Research Foundation, 2020;369.
  8. Schreinemachers P, G Balaki, RM Shrestha. Nudging children toward healthier food choices: An experiment combining school and home gardens. Global Food Security. 2020:20.
  9. Bhattarai DR, Budathoki K. Effect of pre-harvest organic manures on postharvest physiology and consumers’ acceptability of cauliflower. Nepal Journal of Science and Technology 2005;6:11–14.
  10. Bhattarai DR, GD Subedi, P Schreinemachers. School Vegetable Gardening: Concept, Curriculum & Action, Nepal: Government of Nepal, Nepal Agricultural Research Council (NARC), Nepal. 2016.
  11. Das S, Chattergee A, Pal TK. Organic farming in India. A vision toward a healthy nation. Food Quality and Safety. 2020;4:69–76.
  12. Galhena DH, Freed R, Maredia KM. Home gardens: a promising approach to enhance household food security and wellbeing. Agriculture & Food Security. 2013;2(8):2–13.
  13. Faber M, Venter SL, Benade AS. Increased vitamin A intake in children aged 2– 5 years through targeted home-gardens in a rural South African community. Public Health Nutrition, 2002;5(1):11–16.
  14. Ferdous Z, A Datta, AK Anal, et al. “Development of home garden model for year round production and consumption for improving resource-poor household food security in Bangladesh,” NJAS- Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences. 2016;78:103–110.
  15. Chadha ML, OM Oluoch. Healthy diet gardening kit for better health and income. Acta Horticulture. 2007;752:581–584.
  16. Fabbri ADT, Crosby GA. A review of impact of preparation and cooking on the nutritional quality of vegetables and legumes. International Journal of Gastronomy and Food Science 2016;3:2–11.
Creative Commons Attribution License

©2021 Bhattarai, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.