Review Article Volume 4 Issue 5
Nutritional Epidemiologist, Massachusetts Department of Public Health, USA
Correspondence: Stella G Uzogara, PhD, MS, RDN, LDN, CFS, Nutritional Epidemiologist Massachusetts Department of Public health, 250 Washington Street, Boston MA 02108, USA, Tel 6176246147, Fax 6176245070
Received: April 24, 2016 | Published: May 23, 2016
Citation: Uzogara SG. Obvious and hidden calories in food and their impact on weight, obesity and wellness: a review. Adv Obes Weight Manag Control. 2016;4(5):120-128. DOI: 10.15406/aowmc.2016.04.00100
Nutritionists, health and food professionals need to be skilled in recognizing the various sources of calories in consumed foods and the implications of excessive caloric intake. Such skills are necessary in order to effectively counsel consumers and patients on food choices & weight management, or to advise food manufacturers to make and market products for better health. This paper will address the growing concern on overweight and obesity epidemic and the risks of excessive consumption of calories from various sources in our food supply, especially obvious and hidden calories. The paper will define what is meant by obvious and hidden sources of calories, with real life examples. Using data from published studies, the paper will discuss how caloric consumption impacts weight gain, obesity, health and wellness. Strategies for recognizing and reducing excessive caloric intake especially from hidden calories will be suggested. Such strategies would include lifestyle changes, dietary habits, physical activity, behavior modification, reading food labels, proper food selection & preparation, food substitution, food processing & consumption among others. A joint action by food consumers and regulators, food manufacturers & marketers, nutritionists, food and healthcare professionals will help consumers in managing weight and in fighting the overweight and obesity epidemic in many populations.
Keywords: hidden calories, obvious calories, impact, obesity, epidemic, food choices, weight management, health, wellness
BMI, body mass index; USDA, united states department of agriculture; DGA, dietary guidelines for Americans; HP2020, healthy people 2020 guidelines; NGO, non governmental organizations; USA, united states of America; CDC, center for disease control and prevention; NCHS, national center for health statistics; OECD, organization of economic cooperation and development; WHO, world health organization; NHLBI, national heart, lung & blood institute
The current incidence of obesity and overweight in many US populations has reached epidemic proportions.1,2 The obesity epidemic is also rising in other countries.3–5 Obesity and related chronic diseases –the so called obesity co-morbidities-such as heart disease, diabetes, hypertension etc, were formerly regarded as ‘Diseases of Affluence’6 as these diseases were more prevalent in high income countries. However obesity is also showing an increasing trend even in developing countries.4,7,8 Nutritionists, health researchers and educators, federal and state government agencies including state public health departments are now on the alert mode. Each agency has raised awareness or taken immediate action to arrest the increasing weight trends and the obesity epidemic in both adults and children, not only in the USA9–13 but also all over the world8,14–16 including some developing countries, where obesity, overweight and underweight can coexist in the same country but in different segments of their populations.7,17–19 Obesity, overweight and underweight are all classified as different forms of unhealthy weight. Unhealthy weight, whether it is too little weight or too much weight, has so many consequences that can affect health and quality of life. Some of the factors that cause high weight gain, overweight and obesity include genetic and environmental factors as well as obesity related conditions. Obvious and hidden calories in food are some of those environmental factors that contribute to obesity. This paper, inspired following a nutrition practicum at Simmons College in Boston Massachusetts, will review overt and hidden sources of calories in the food supply and their impact on body weight and obesity. In particular, it will discuss strategies not only to maintain healthy weight but also to combat overweight and obesity epidemic in many populations.
The food calories: sources, storage and body distribution
Sources of calories: Calorie is a unit of energy, and food calorie describes the amount of potential energy contained in a particular food. The food consumed by humans can contain caloric (energy-giving) and non-caloric (non-energy giving) nutrients. The macronutrients, such as carbohydrates, fats, protein and alcohol- are caloric nutrients and, when consumed, result in accumulation of calories in the body.20 Water and the micronutrients (vitamins & minerals) are non-caloric therefore they neither lead to accumulation of calories nor fat in the body. The caloric intake from a food varies and depends on many factors. These factors include: the type of food, the total caloric content of the food, the type of ingredient and cooking method used in preparation and processing of the food, the frequency of consumption or the amount of such food consumed. Food calorie intake can also increase because of the energy content of side dishes or ingredients paired with the main food.
High caloric foods are those foods that contain large amounts of caloric macronutrients or combinations of these nutrients in liquid, solid, or semi solid forms. Caloric nutrients supply the body with energy needed for its daily metabolic, physical and mental activities. If the body has met its need for the calories needed for its daily activities, the rest or excess calories is stored as fat in adipose tissues. It should be noted that all food calories, whether they originate from proteins, carbohydrates, fats or alcohol are convertible to fat. Gradual accumulation of fat in the body leads to gradual weight gain and with time, if the fat calorie is not burnt through metabolism or lost through regular physical activity or exercise, the increase in accumulated fat contributes to weight gain and overweight. Excessive accumulation of body fat that impairs health results in obesity and metabolic problems.21 Obesity and weight status are estimated by body mass index or BMI. To determine BMI, body mass in kilograms is divided by height in meter squared. If efforts are not made to lose some weight by the obese person, the obesity becomes progressive and chronic, and this has adverse consequences for health and quality of life.21,22 It should also be noted that not all obesity result from excessive intake of calories as several non diet related causes of obesity exist.
Fat storage: Fat is stored in different regions of the body, either in the upper body (areas around the stomach and abdomen) or lower body (areas around the hip, thigh and legs) or both.23,24 Excess body fat stored mainly in the upper body results in upper body obesity, also known as apple-shape obesity or abdominal obesity.25 Other names used to describe upper body obesity include central obesity, truncal obesity or android obesity. In the layman’s language, apple shape obesity is sometimes called ‘pot belly’ or ‘beer belly’, i.e. the body structure commonly seen as protruding belly in people who consume excess amount of beer or other alcoholic drinks in addition to excess food consumption.
Excess body fat that is stored mainly in the lower body (hips, thighs, legs) results in lower body obesity or pear shape obesity.23 Pear shape obesity is also known by various other names such as rear end obesity, gluteal obesity or gynoid obesity. In the street language, pear shape obesity is sometimes called ‘hip fat’ or ‘sitter’s fat’ because this body structure is commonly seen in people who have sedentary jobs that require sitting in one place for a long time each day as observed in some long distance truck drivers, bus and train drivers. Pear shape obesity is also observed in sedentary office workers and computer users, in video game players and in people who sit on the couch or chair all day watching television with little time devoted to physical activity. Other people who display pear shape obesity are those immobilized in one place because of accidents or people who are wheel-chair bound.
Both apple shape obesity and pear shape obesity are dangerous to health; people living with such obesity should make efforts to lose weight as both types of obesity can predispose sufferers to high risks of some metabolic diseases. However, apple shape obesity which is accompanied by increased waist circumference appears to present greater risk to various metabolic diseases than pear shape obesity.25,26 People with apple shape obesity are more vulnerable to several diseases including hypertension, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, fatty liver and some types of cancer (of the colon, stomach and breast). Anecdotal reports also indicate that fat in people living with pear shape obesity is more difficult to lose than fat in people with apple shape obesity.
Pattern of body fat distribution: visceral, subcutaneous and intra-muscular fat: In upper body obesity, varied proportions of fat stores are distributed in several locations in the body, namely visceral, subcutaneous and intramuscular tissues and organs in the body. Most of upper body obesity arises from visceral fat. Visceral fat sometimes called ‘intra-abdominal fat’ or ‘organ fat’ is stored in the stomach, abdominal cavity and organs within the abdomen.23 In general, adult females tend to have more body fat stores than adult males. Adult males and females store their body fat in different body locations. Adult males store most of their body fat as abdominal or visceral fat and less as lower body fat. Adult females on the other hand store most of their body fat in the lower body-(hip, thigh, legs) and less of their fat as abdominal fat. However as women get to menopause, the amount of their abdominal fat storage increases due to hormonal changes as well as genetics, ageing and other factors.25,27 Visceral or abdominal fat accumulation increases the risk for cardiovascular disease.21,25 Subcutaneous fat is body fat stored just underneath the skin while intramuscular fat is the body fat stored in between the skeletal muscles. Environmental factors and genetics influence body fat distribution but genetics appears to have a greater role in fat distribution while diet and exercise have more effect on total body fat content.28
Some published causes of overweight and obesity
Basically excess weight results from energy imbalance caused when there is surplus energy intake (i.e. Eating more calories than is actually needed), or decreased energy expenditure (not burning enough of consumed calories through regular physical activity, exercise & metabolism) or a combination of surplus energy intake and decreased energy expenditure. This situation where energy intake is more than energy output leads to positive energy balance and energy storage. Excess energy storage manifests as fat accumulation, weight gain, overweight and obesity. It should also be noted that obesity may sometimes be caused by factors not associated with diet and activity.
Several factors29 published in literature contribute to or cause the obesity epidemic, and as more research in weight management continues, new contributing factors continue to be found. These include factors related to
Among the socio-cultural and environmental factors (Table 1) that cause obesity are hidden and obvious calories. This paper will discuss obvious and hidden calories as causes of obesity. A subsequent paper will treat various obesity causing factors in more detail.
Some Psycho-social, Cultural and Environmental Factors Causing Obesity |
References |
Food marketing and advertising |
|
Hidden calories |
|
Culture |
|
Family & Parental influences |
|
Migration & acculturation |
|
Psychological Factors |
|
Mood |
|
Depression |
|
Self esteem |
|
Emotional problem |
|
Food environment |
|
Table 1 Some Psycho-social, cultural and environmental factors implicated in Obesity and overweight published in literature
Questions about the causes of obesity epidemic
Why are obesity and overweight trends increasing or persisting in various populations despite measures at controlling them? |
Why does weight regain occur after losing weight for some time? |
Why are people unable to maintain healthy weight even after following guidelines like the Healthy People programs, My Plate food guide and the Dietary Guidelines for Americans? |
Why are people investing money and time participating in various dieting and weight management programs (such as Biggest Loser program and various dieting programs like Weight Watchers, Atkins Diet, Paleo Diet & Zone Diet etc) without adequate return on their investments in terms of weight loss? |
What is causing the weight gain in most people even after making efforts to control weight by modifying some factors like physical activity, diet and lifestyle? |
Is it possible that people are consuming foods high in hidden calories that they are not aware of? |
Do consumers lack knowledge of caloric content of foods they consume? |
Is it possible that consumers do not know about low calorie alternatives that can be used to substitute high caloric foods? |
Are consumers undercounting, downplaying or underestimating the caloric contents of certain foods they eat, leading to over consumption of food calories? |
Table 2 Obesity Epidemic Raises Many Questions
Coffee enriched with cream, syrup , honey, sugar, nuts and caloric ingredients |
Breads, gluten free foods, Sugary breakfast cereals |
Cappuccino, mocha, latte or chocolate coffee |
Baked potato |
Salads with excess accessories like creamy dressings, full fat mayonnaise, croutons, bacon pieces, nuts, breads crumbs |
Pancake syrup |
Sodas (soft drinks) and alcoholic beverages ,diet drinks, drink mixes consumed along with foods |
Red wine, |
Energy drinks |
White wine |
Oversized whole grain or multigrain bagels Whole grain muffins eaten at breakfast or as snacks, sugar coated cereals |
Whole milk regarded as natural |
Small size packaged convenience foods high in fat and carbohydrates such as creamy pastries, buttered popcorn |
Orange juice, dried fruits |
Fried foods such as French fries, fried fish and chips, crispy foods |
Eggnog, omelet mixed with ham, bacon, cheese or butter |
Fast food restaurant foods high in cheese and pastry, ketchup |
Peanut butter, Peanuts, nuts, trail mix, butter, sweetened applesauce, candy |
Snacks sweetened with syrup, honey or sugar; energy bars, Beverages sweetened with honey & syrup |
Dark chocolate eaten in excess, honey, chocolate candy. |
Restaurant foods loaded with fat, salt, sugar and carbohydrates to increase taste, texture, mouth feel and to increase appetite |
Salad dressings, salad dressed with mayonnaise |
Ethnic foods described as natural or traditional but filled with high caloric ingredients unknown to consumer e.g. , tortillas, burritos wrapped with caloric ingredients, Indian foods, Thai foods, African foods such as fufu , pounded yam, bean porridge. |
Soups, sushi, |
Imported foods sold without food labels and whose nutrient content is unlisted. |
Meat pie, filled with cheese, bacon and fried onions |
Juices, soft drinks and sweetened beverages |
Chocolate cake, applesauce |
Desserts, yogurts, smoothies and sauces; yogurt with fruit or honey or chocolate on the bottom; |
Red meat, tuna salad. |
Alcoholic drink mixes, |
Fish oil |
Fat free foods loaded with sugar , salt and carbohydrates such as granola bars, cereals, |
Small side dishes whose calories add up when excessively consumed. |
Veggie burgers made with fried vegetables, onions, mayonnaise, and cheese. |
Tofu |
Table 3 Sources of Hidden Calories in the food supply
Environmental causes of obesity
Few reports have implicated hidden calories as contributing to the rising obesity and overweight trends,30–33 though more has been written about overt calorie sources. Many factors (social, political, economic, lifestyle, etc) that resulted in the increasing weight trends around the world are indirect and hidden from the consumer according to some published reports.34,37 A closer look into the causes of increased body weight, especially hidden calories will clarify the trends and give a better understanding of the situation, and will highlight the need for a concerted action to fight the obesity epidemic.
Obvious sources of calories: Obvious or overt caloric food source is any food, food ingredient or food product that can be obviously identified or generally recognized as a source of caloric nutrient. Such foods can be identified through the following characteristics:
For example, sweet or sugary food, honey-sweetened beverage, nutty bread; syrup, grainy, soggy, fatty, salty, starchy foods can show that they are high in carbohydrates, fats or other macronutrients.
Obvious sources of calories can be avoided easily by persons on prescribed diets for certain conditions since such diets are known and recognized as starchy, sugary , fatty or salty. Examples of such diets include low sugar diet, diabetic diet, low calorie diet, sugar-free diet, reduced calorie food, low fat or fat- free diet, meatless or low protein diet, No Added sugar or No Added salt diets. Such diets are prescribed for various disease conditions such as diabetes, obesity, hypertension, kidney or heart disease conditions and many others. Examples of obvious caloric foods include baked foods, pastry foods, bread and pasta, white rice, whole grain pasta, macaroni, spaghetti, potatoes, noodles, cake, nuts, starchy, fried, oily foods and snacks.
Hidden food calories & how they are identified: Hidden calories are calories present in some foods or food products & ingredients that are not obvious to the consumer as being caloric or deliberately ignored as caloric, but such foods contribute calories in each day’s total caloric intake. The calories are described as ‘hidden’ because the consumer is not aware of them, or ignores them, or can neither observe nor recognize them.
Hidden calories have the following characteristics:
Sources of hidden calories in foods: Hidden calories are ubiquitous in the food supply and it needs a trained eye or knowledge of an expert such as nutritionist, dietitian, food scientist, chef, culinary scientist or trained consumer to recognize or identify them. There are so many sources of hidden calories present in the food supply and they can be found in many food categories:
Many sources of hidden calories exist in our food supply (Table 3). Being aware of the sources of these hidden calories will enable the consumer to take them into account when counting calories or trying to minimize caloric intake to achieve a healthy weight and combat obesity and overweight.30,33 Understanding and controlling the hidden calories is a cost effective way of managing weight as it puts the responsibility of weight control in the consumers’ hands.
How consumers undercount calories especially hidden calories
How to substitute high calorie foods with low calorie alternatives: Consumers can still enjoy their favorite foods by using lower calorie options without sacrificing the taste or flavor of foods they cherish. Knowledge of hidden calories would enable consumers to find better ways of substituting with healthier alternatives or options (Table 4). Best approach is to find the culprit food and remove or substitute it with a better less caloric item in the menu. Another useful method of reducing these hidden calories is by cutting down the portion size if there is no appropriate substitute e.g. dried fruits, energy bars and dark chocolate.
High Caloric Foods with Hidden Calories |
Healthy Low Caloric Substitutes |
1a. Creamy coffee |
1b. Lite coffee |
2a. Sweetened ice tea |
2b. Unsweetened ice tea |
3a. Sushi with white rice |
3b. Sushi made with whole grain(brown) rice |
4a. Sugary corn flakes cereals |
4b. Plain corn flakes |
5a. Burrito wrap with high fat mayonnaise, butter, fatty meat, bacon, sausage, cheese, refried black bean, white rice |
5b. Whole grain burrito with low fat ingredients |
6a. Oily tofu |
6b. Low fat tofu |
7a. Two slices of whole wheat bagel per serving |
7b. One or half a slice whole wheat bagel per serving |
8a. Sugary trail mix |
8b. Plain trail mix |
9a. Omelet with butter, fried onion and ham/ sausage |
9b. Omelet paired with vegetables |
10a. Several cheese slices per serving |
10b. One cheese slice per serving |
11a. Canned creamy soup |
11b. Homemade lite soup |
12a. Whole milk |
12b. Low fat or fat-free milk |
13a. Sugary ketchup |
13b. Low sugar ketchup. |
14a. Sweetened smoothies |
14b. Smoothies made with plain yogurt |
15a. Tuna salad with vegetables, cheese and mayonnaise |
15b. Tuna salad with vegetables |
16a. Veggie burgers high in butter, oil, salt , cheese & fried vegetables |
16b.Veggie burger with little olive oil, less cheese and fresh vegetables |
17a. Sweetened energy bars |
17b. Unsweetened energy bars |
18a. Yogurt with fruits or honey on the bottom |
18b. Plain yogurt |
19a. Several servings of wine , beer |
19b. Moderate serving -one serving (women); 1 to 2 servings (men). |
20a. Gluten free foods |
20b. Fat -free, sugar free food varieties. |
21a. Whole avocado fruit per serving |
21b. Cut avocado piece(1/4 or 1/8) per serving |
Table 4 Substituting Hidden High Calories Foods (a) with low calorie versions (b)
Action needed to combat obesity & its consequences
The consequences of obesity and overweight have prompted not only government agencies , but also professional organizations , non-governmental organizations (NGOs), as well as for-profit and non- profit organizations, to take active steps to raise awareness, reach out to the general public to curtail the obesity and overweight trends. These organizations include among others the Academy of Nutrition & Dietetics (www.eatright.org), American Heart Association (www.heart.org), American Diabetic Association (www.diabetes.org), and the Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA) and many other foundations.
Recent reports2,8,9 have stated that the percent of US adults aged 20 years and above who are obese was 35.1 % between 2011 & 2012, while the percent of US adults in the same age group who had excess body weight (overweight and obesity) in the same period was 69.0% . This increasing trend in obesity and overweight has also been reported in other developed and developing countries of the world.3–5,7 Proper understanding of the various causes of obesity, especially obvious and hidden calories will help in the control of the obesity epidemic. Consumers should follow strategies to recognize and reduce all sources of calories.
Strategies for recognizing and reducing excess caloric intake from food calorie sources
Consumer awareness through education, food label reading and nutrient claims interpretation: There are various strategies to reduce calories in foods and no single strategy can work for all individuals or organizations. In addition, there is no “magic bullet” or “one solution approach” to reducing calories. Sometimes “multiple approaches” work best. These strategies include creating consumer awareness and education on consequences of overweight and obesity, reading food labels and properly interpreting health and nutrient claims on the labels such as calorie free, low calorie, lite, reduced calorie, high calorie, moderate calorie , sugar free, fat free etc.
Knowledge of hidden calories and food substitutions: One important strategy is teaching consumers about hidden calories in food (Table 3) and how to substitute them with healthier options (Table 4). Consumers should watch out for the code words in hidden calorie food sources that imply high caloric content especially if a person is on reduced calorie, heart healthy or diabetic diet. Such words include “caloric’, ‘energy’, ‘high protein’, ‘high fat’, ‘high calorie’, ‘sugary’, ‘honey- flavored’, ‘crispy’, ‘glazed’, ‘hydrogenated’, ‘chocolate or sugar flavored’, ‘creamy’ ,‘sweet’, ‘honey’,’ fried’, ‘crunchy’, low fat, low sugar, butter-flavored, chocolate enriched’ etc in food labels for snacks and other foods, in restaurant meals, cafeteria & grocery store foods.
Food portion size reduction, behavior modification & daily physical activity
Other strategies include increasing physical activity, reducing food portion size and reduction of caloric macronutrients as well as modifying behaviors around food. In addition, government regulators should encourage physical activity at personal and community levels by building better walk ways, sidewalks, bicycle paths, recreation areas and healthy environments. In short, governments should create policies that encourage physical activity. For example, the Mass in Motion program in the state of Massachusetts has been successful in encouraging physical activity in many communities in the state.
Adherence to food regulatory guidelines
Consumers should also adhere to the food regulatory guidelines such as the Healthy People guidelines,61,62 My Plate food guide63 and the Dietary guidelines for Americans64 which encourage healthy eating pattern, limiting calories from added sugars and saturated fats as well as reducing sodium. These efforts will reduce the incidence of cardiovascular and other metabolic diseases such as diabetes, hypertension, stroke, musculoskeletal diseases etc which result from obesity and overweight.
The expanded list of strategies for reducing excess caloric intake from hidden and obvious calorie foods to facilitate the fight against obesity epidemic is displayed in Table 5.
Special thanks go to Dr Lisa Brown, Associate Professor of Nutrition, Simmons College, Boston Massachusetts, USA, for helpful discussions and advice on the project.
The author declares no conflict of interest.
©2016 Uzogara. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.