Submit manuscript...
MOJ
eISSN: 2574-9935

Sports Medicine

Short Communication Volume 7 Issue 2

An exploration of Magnus effect role in sports, especially in football

Victor Christianto

Malang Institute of Agriculture, Indonesia

Correspondence: Victor Christianto, Malang Institute of Agriculture, East Java, Indonesia

Received: June 29, 2024 | Published: July 17, 2024

Citation: Christianto V. An exploration of magnus effect role in sports, especially in football. MOJ Sports Med. 2024;7(2):74-76. DOI: 10.15406/mojsm.2024.07.00167

Download PDF

Abstract

The present review article can be considered as an exploration in recreational mathematics. The Magnus effect, a phenomenon arising from the interaction between a spinning object and a fluid, plays a crucial role in various sports. This paper delves specifically into its impact on football (soccer). We explore the fundamental principles behind the Magnus effect, explaining how a spinning ball creates a pressure difference that leads to a lateral force, causing the ball to deviate from its expected trajectory. Additionally, the discussion explores the limitations of the Magnus effect and how external conditions can affect its influence. Finally, the paper concludes by highlighting the importance of mastering spin techniques to achieve tactical advantage and enhance ball control.

Keywords: Magnus effect, football, spinning ball, fundamental principles

Abbreviations

MB, Mitochondrial diseases; mtDNA, mitochondrial DNA; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; GTCS, generalized tonic-clonic seizure; HSV, herpes simplex virus; ENMG, electroneuromyography

Introduction

The Magnus effect

Have you ever observed a soccer player unleash a capable free kick that plunges and swerves past the divider of guards? These deeds of physicality depend on a captivating wonder called the Magnus effect.1–4

The Magnus effect portrays the era of a sidelong constrain on a turning question moving through a liquid (fluid or gas). This constrain acts opposite to the course of movement and the pivot of turn, causing the protest to veer off from its straight way. Envision tossing a turning Frisbee. The discuss streaming over the Frisbee interatomic in an unexpected way depending on the heading of turn. On one side, the turn includes to the air's speed, making a locale of lower weight. On the inverse side, the turn contradicts the wind current, driving to a better weight zone. This weight lop-sidedness makes a sidelong drive, causing the Frisbee to bend within the heading of its turn.

The essential offender behind a football's bend is the Magnus impact. When a turning ball flies through the discuss moving over its surface interatomic in an unexpected way depending on the heading of the turn. On one side, the turn includes to the air's speed, making a locale of lower weight agreeing to Bernoulli's rule. On the inverse side, the turn restricts the wind stream, driving to a better weight zone. This weight lop-sidedness makes a lateral force, avoiding the ball within the heading of the turn. The speedier the turn, the more prominent the weight distinction and, subsequently, the more articulated the bend.

The Magnus impact plays a significant part in different ordinary applications. Here are a few examples:

  1. Helicopters: The rotating blades of a helicopter generate lift using the Magnus effect. The spinning blades create a pressure difference between the top and bottom surfaces, pushing the helicopter upwards.
  2. Sailing Ships: The curved sails of sailboats exploit the Magnus effect to a certain extent. As the wind flows over the curved sail, it creates a pressure difference that helps propel the boat forward.
  3. Baseball Pitching: Different types of pitches, like curveballs and sliders, utilize the Magnus effect to achieve their characteristic movement. Pitchers impart spin on the ball, causing it to deviate from a straight path and confuse the batter.

The Magnus impact could be a captivating case of how apparently basic physics science standards can lead to complex and intriguing marvels. By understanding the interplay between turn, weight, and liquid stream, we will appreciate the momentous deeds of physicality and the bright plan of ordinary objects that depend on this momentous impact.1,3,4

Possible simplified model of Magnus effect

While Newton's gravity isn't directly involved, there's another force at play that creates these dramatic curves. The key ingredient is the ball's spin. When a soccer ball or tennis ball is hit with a spin, the air around it gets dragged along. This creates a difference in air pressure on opposite sides of the ball.

Think of it like this:

  1. Imagine the ball spinning counter-clockwise. On the right side of the ball (as it moves forward), the air gets pushed forward with the spin. This creates a region of slightly higher pressure.
  2. On the left side, the air gets pushed against its natural flow (backward). This creates a region of slightly lower pressure.

According to a principle in physics, air naturally flows from high pressure to low pressure. This creates a sideways force (called the lift force) that pushes the ball in the direction of the lower pressure in our example, to the left.

The Magnus effect doesn't rely on gravity, but on the interaction between the spinning ball and the surrounding air. This creates a sideways force that curves the ball's path, surprising opponents and adding another layer of skill to the beautiful games of soccer and tennis.

While this is a simplified model, the actual Magnus effect involves factors like turbulence and boundary layer effects.

Speed matters: introduction to Bernoulli’s rule

The Magnus impact can be clarified utilizing Bernoulli's rule, which states that for a moving liquid, weight diminishes with expanding speed. As the turning protest moves, the layer closest to the turning surface gets dragged along. On the side where the turn includes to the air's characteristic stream, the combined speed increments, driving to a lower weight zone. Then again, on the inverse side, the turn contradicts the wind stream, lessening the by and large speed and making a better weight zone. This weight distinction produces a sideways lift drive, causing the protest to bend.

Whereas turn directs the heading of the bend, speed plays a pivotal part in its size. Higher speeds permit the Magnus impact to have a more grounded impact. In any case, intemperate speed can moreover present turbulent airflows that disturb the smooth interaction between the balls and discuss. Turbulence can make the bend unusual and indeed diminish the by and large diversion. Finding the sweet spot between turn and speed is key to accomplishing a controlled and sensational twist.

The drag coefficient could be a degree of how much resistance a question encounters. A lower drag coefficient implies the protest can move through the discussion with less drag, permitting the Magnus impact to act more successfully. Footballs, with their dimpled surface, have a lower drag coefficient compared to a smooth circle. This permits the turn to have a more conspicuous impact on the ball's direction.

Whereas turbulence can disturb a culminate bend, it can moreover be saddled to a degree. Talented players can utilize a particular kicking method to present a slight wobble to the ball's turn pivot. This controlled turbulence can make a plunging or rising impact, including another layer of complexity to the free kick.

Simplified model with Mathematics

It is known that the complex interaction between turn, speed, turbulence, and a football's bend utilizing the total Navier-Stokes conditions is computationally costly and past the commonplace capabilities of promptly accessible mathematics code. Here's a breakdown of the challenges:

  1. Navier-Stokes Equations: These equations govern the motion of viscous fluids. Solving them for a turbulent flow around a spinning football requires advanced computational fluid dynamics (CFD) techniques.1,2
  2. Turbulence Modelling: Turbulence is a highly complex phenomenon. Accurately modelling it requires sophisticated turbulence models, which can be computationally intensive.
  3. Football Geometry: A football's dimpled surface adds another layer of complexity to the simulation. Accurately incorporating this geometry requires advanced meshing techniques.

However we can simplify the model by taking into consideration: simulating the flight of a football requires considering numerous factors beyond the Magnus effect:

  1. Air resistance: Drag force proportional to the square of velocity.
  2. Ball shape: The dimpled surface affects air flow and lift.
  3. Spin axis orientation: The angle between the spin axis and the velocity vector influences the Magnus force.
  4. Turbulence: Random fluctuations in air velocity can affect the trajectory.

We can explore a simplified model in mathematics to understand the basic principles, see Appendix I.

Discussion

Role of vortex trail to simulate negative Magnus effect

As we discuss in the aforementioned section, the Magnus effect is a cornerstone of any discussion on curving a football. But what happens when the curve goes the other way? Recent experimental simulations suggest the existence of a "negative Magnus effect," where the ball curves in the opposite direction to its spin. This article explores the potential role of vortex trails in simulating this intriguing phenomenon.5–7

Typically, the Magnus effect dictates that a spinning ball curves in the direction of its spin. As the ball flies, the air flowing across its surface interacts differently depending on the spin direction. This creates a pressure imbalance, with a lower pressure zone on one side and a higher pressure zone on the other. This pressure difference, in turn, generates a lateral force that deflects the ball's trajectory.

However, experimental simulations have shown instances where a spinning ball curves in the opposite direction of its spin. This "negative Magnus effect" defies the traditional understanding. So, what might be causing this reversal?

Vortex trail and vortex shedding

Vortex shedding, a phenomenon where swirling air trails behind a moving object, could be the key to unlocking the negative Magnus effect.1,2 Here's how:

  1. Spin and Asymmetry: When a ball spins, it creates an asymmetric flow of air around it. This asymmetry can lead to the formation of counter-rotating vortices in the wake of the ball.
  2. Vortex Interaction: These counter-rotating vortices can interact with the spinning ball in a complex way. Depending on the strength and position of these vortices, they could potentially exert a force that pushes the ball in the opposite direction of its spin.
  3. Negative Pressure and the Curve: The interaction between the vortices and the ball could create a pressure distribution that favours a deflection opposite to the spin direction. This negative pressure zone could then induce a "negative Magnus effect," causing the ball to curve in the unexpected direction.

Simulating the negative Magnus effect: a computational challenge

Simulating the negative Magnus effect using vortex shedding is a computationally challenging task. Accurately modelling the complex interactions between the ball's spin, the formation of vortices, and their influence on the pressure field requires advanced computational fluid dynamics (CFD) techniques.1,2

For simplified modelling, see Appendix II.

Whereas the concept of vortex shedding offers a potential clarification for the negative Magnus impact, more inquiry is required. Future consideration with progressed CFD recreations and high-speed wind burrow tests can offer assistance for this hypothesis and shed light on the particular conditions required for this marvel to happen.

The negative Magnus impact may be an interesting inconsistency within the world of ballistics. Understanding its causes might have noteworthy suggestions for different sports, particularly those including turning objects like football and baseball. It moreover highlights the complex exchange between turn, liquid flow, and the unforeseen ways nature can shock us.6,7

Conclusion

The present review article can be considered as an exploration in recreational mathematics. The Magnus effect, a phenomenon arising from the interaction between a spinning object and a fluid, plays a crucial role in various sports. Understanding the interplay between spin, speed, drag coefficient, and turbulence is what separates a hopeful from a free-kick maestro. By mastering this intricate dance of forces, players can bend the ball to their will, leaving defenders and goalkeepers in awe. The next time you witness a wonder strike, remember the science behind it a testament to the beauty of physics in motion.

The Magnus impact could be a captivating case of how apparently basic material science standards can lead to complex and intriguing marvels. By understanding the interplay between turn, weight, and liquid stream, we will appreciate the momentous deeds of physicality and the bright plan of ordinary objects that depend on this momentous impact.

Hint to practical football games

Moreover, the negative Magnus impact may be an interesting inconsistency within the world of ballistics. Understanding its causes might have noteworthy suggestions for different sports, particularly those including turning objects like football and baseball.

All in all, this review article is not to suggest to implementing directly negative Magnus effect whenever one soccer player has to do a free kick or a sidekick. The dramatic dips we see are often a combination of factors:

  1. Topspin: A strong topspin creates a downward force (lift) that pulls the ball slightly down towards the goal.
  2. Dipping Trajectory: As the ball loses speed, gravity plays a larger role, causing a natural downward bend.

While a negative Magnus effect exists, it's not a practical strategy for curving a football in a free kick. Mastering topspin and understanding the interplay of spin, gravity, and air resistance remain the keys to bending free kicks like a pro.

Acknowledgments

Discussions with Robert N. Boyd, PhD., Prof Florentin Smarandache, and others are gratefully appreciated. Sections of the present article were written with assistance of a large language model / AI.

Conflicts of interest

The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest.

Funding

None.

References

Creative Commons Attribution License

©2024 Christianto. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.