A clinical profile of patients with traumatic perforation of tympanic membrane in South Kashmir

doi:10.15406/joentr.2018.10.00348

Journal of

eISSN: 2379-6359

Otolaryngology-ENT Research

Research Article Volume 10 Issue 4

A clinical profile of patients with traumatic perforation of tympanic membrane in South Kashmir

Dr Irfan Ul Shamas

Verify Captcha

Regret for the inconvenience: we are taking measures to prevent fraudulent form submissions by extractors and page crawlers. Please type the correct Captcha word to see email ID.

MS ENT and Head and Neck Surgery, India

Correspondence: Irfan Ul Shamas, MS ENT and Head and Neck Surgery, ENT Specialist, Srinagar, India

Received: August 23, 2017 | Published: July 17, 2018

Citation: Irfan UIS. A clinical profile of patients with traumatic perforation of tympanic membrane in South Kashmir. J Otolaryngol ENT Res. 2018;10(4):217-218. DOI: 10.15406/joentr.2018.10.00348

Download PDF

Abstract

Objectives: To study various etiologies of tympanic membrane perforation, clinical presentations, management and determine the group who are most likely to benefit from conservative management.

Methods:

Design: Prospective observation study in District Hospital Pulwama.

Participants: 227 patients who had otoscopic evidence of tympanic membrane perforation from May 2016 to May 2017 participated in the study.

Results: Males (n=187) were found to be five times more likely than females (40) to have a traumatic perforation. It affects all groups with highest incidence in second decade of life. Left ear was involved in 182(80%) patients. The most common cause was assault/slap in 160(70%). Tinnitus was the most common presenting complaint followed by ear block.178(79%)patients had grade 1 perforation with a size of less than 30 percent of the entire TM.143(62%) patients had perforation of posterior quadrant of tympanic membrane. Residual perforation after 3 months was noted in 36(16%) patients.29 (80%) patients who had residual perforation had grade 2 or more sized traumatic perforation.

Conclusion: The size of perforation may be a significant risk factor in predicting non healing of traumatic perforation.

Keywords: tympanic membrane perforation, risk factors, South Kashmir

Introduction

In our daily ENT practice we come across patients with traumatic rupture of tympanic membrane secondary to either blunt (slap, explosion, rapid descent of aeroplane, deep water diving) or penetrating (ear buds, pencils, syringing for foreign body or wax removal) trauma. The tympanic membrane heals spontaneously in 80% of cases as per most studies.¹ The masterly wait and watch policy for 3 months unnecessarily exposes the patients to symptoms of tinnitus, ear block and life style modifications like keeping the ear dry. If we can identify the causes of non healing of traumatic perforation we can intervene surgically at an earlier stage and reduce the morbidity. This paper aims to study various etiologies of traumatic tympanic membrane perforation; evaluate the factors involved in healing of traumatic tympanic membrane perforation; and identify the patients who are unlikely to benefit from conservative management so that early surgical intervention may be recommended.

Methods

A prospective observational study was conducted in ENT section of District Hospital Pulwama a secondary care hospital in Kashmir from May 2016 to May 2017. The inclusion criterion was a traumatic perforation of the tympanic membrane irrespective of time of presentation. Patients with history of previous ear discharge or impaired hearing, ear surgery or chronic otitis media in the same ear and patients who were lost to follow up were excluded. A total of 227 patients enrolled in this study. After obtaining a history in terms of perforation etiology and duration from occurrence to patient presentation, all patients underwent ENT and general examinations. All the patients were advised to keep their ear dry and follow up regularly every two weeks. All the patients were followed up serially up to three months.

Results

Two hundred twenty seven (227) participants, 187(82%) males and 40 (18%) females with a male: female ratio of 4.6:1 completed the study. The median age was 19 years with a range of 7-61 years. 102(44%) belonged to the second decade of life. Left ear was involved in 182(80%) patients and 45(20%) patients had traumatic perforation of right ear.

Most (60%) of the traumatic perforations were due to assault/slap (Chart 1).

The most common presenting complaint was tinnitus (90%). Ear block was complained by 185 patients (84%).17(7%) patients had bleeding from ear and 5(2%) patients had vertigo.

178(79%) patients had grade 1 perforation with size not more than thirty percent of the tympanic membrane. 37(16%) patients had grade 2 perforation with size not more than sixty present. 12(5%) patients had grade 3 perforation with size more than sixty present (Chart 3).

One hundred ninety one (84%) patients had spontaneous closure of traumatic perforation over a course of 3 months. Thirty six (16%) patients had residual perforation. Twenty nine (80%) patients with residual perforation had grade 2 or more sized traumatic perforation.

Discussion

The TM is an important component of sound conduction as its vibratory characteristic is necessary for sound transmission in human beings.² Trauma to TM can be caused by over pressure, blunt or penetrating injuries and barotraumas.^3,4 In this study, over pressure was the most common cause of trauma to TM similar to various studies elsewhere.^4,5 The current study focused on tympanic membrane perforation as a consequence of trauma. While the management of the otologic complications of trauma is well validated, tympanic membrane perforation has been considered to be mostly a self-healing condition. Almost all standard textbooks and previous large scale studies consider a ‘wait and watch’ policy of management for traumatic tympanic membrane perforation.⁶ However, there is still a subset of patients, albeit small, who will not spontaneously heal and tend to suffer increased morbidity for three months. Our study attempts to identify this subset of patients who may benefit from early intervention based on certain risk factors, etiology and characteristics of the perforation.

In this study high ratio of males (82%) may likely be due to unrest in South Kashmir prevailing during the time of study with 60% patients having traumatic perforation due to assault/slap. The difference in line with other Indian studies⁷ may be due to peculiar circumstances prevailing in valley due to terrorism/ unrest.

After 3 months of masterly inactivity, almost 84% of the perforations healed spontaneously. Among the 36 unhealed cases, 12 developed discharge, a marker of increased morbidity. Other studies show similar rates of spontaneous healing.¹ In this study residual perforations were more likely to occur if the size of perforation was more than grade 2. That larger perforations have fewer chances to heal spontaneously has also been shown by other studies.^8–11

In conclusion, tympanic membrane perforation size >30% may be significant risk factors predicting non-healing of the perforation. Early intervention for those with big perforation may lessen unnecessary morbidity. Bigger multicenter future studies are necessary to confirm these initial findings.