Research Article Volume 2 Issue 2
1Theriogenology Department, Alexandria University, Egypt
2Theriogenology Department, Zagazig University, Egypt
Correspondence: Wael MB Noseir, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Alexandria University, Egypt, Tel 20 101 099 3995
Received: March 07, 2015 | Published: May 5, 2015
Citation: Noseir WMB, Sosa GAM. Treatment of ovarian cysts in buffaloes with emphasis to echotexture analysis. J Dairy Vet Anim Res. 2015;2(2):52-57. DOI: 10.15406/jdvar.2015.02.00030
The present study was conducted on 31 buffalo-cows aged 3-10years and diagnosed rectally as they had follicular cyst. The previous diagnosis of the follicular cyst was confirmed by ultrasonography and serum progesterone assay. Ultrasound images of the ovarian follicles, both mature and cystic follicles, were individually identified and monitored and were subsequently digitized for computer analysis of echotexture [mean pixel value (MPV) and pixel heterogeneity (PH)] of the follicle antrum and wall. Animals were classified into two groups (Treated, n=20 and control, n=11). The treated buffalo-cows injected i.m with 100mg progesterone oily in nature followed by i.m injection of 5000 IU HCG at days 5. Out of the twenty treated animals 14 buffaloes responded and diagnosed as they had luteinized cyst. Out of the 14 animals that had luteinized cyst 9 buffaloes injected with 25mg of PGF2a at day 14 and the other 5 buffaloes left as control. The 6 non responded buffaloes were classified into two subgroups each (n=3), one of them injected with HCG and the other left as control without any treatment. The time elapsed till luteinization of the follicular treated group was significantly different (32.67±1.45days and 15.71±0.75days respectively). The recovery rate was 27.27% in control animals and 70% in treated ones. Days elapsed till appearance of estrus was significantly shorter in treated buffaloes (22.20±1.19days) in comparison to the control ones (56.33±2.03days). The conception rates were 33.33% and 66.67% in control and treated group respectively. Days elapsed from the treated animals (36.50±1.47days) compared to the control ones (64days). Serum progesterone level was significantly different in treated animals comparing to the control ones. Changes in echotexture of bovine ovarian follicles assessed by computer analysis of ultrasound images has revealed a significant increase in echotexture parameters (MPV & PH) in cystic follicles compared with preovulatory follicles. PH of the antrum and wall of luteinized cystic follicles increased significantly compared to preovulatory and cystic follicles. Ultrasonography examination and echotexture analysis has revealed a presence of positive correlation between the cyst wall thickness and progesterone level which consequently aids in the treatment protocol. From the present study, it could be recommended that accurate diagnosis of the ovarian cyst was done by ultrasonography in combination with echotexture characteristics of ultrasound images together with progesterone profile 2weeks postpartum early as soon as possible; and the animals should be re-examined with 7-10days if possible for re-treatment of non responded cases if necessary.
Keywords: ovaries, follicular cysts, buffaloes, echotexture analysis, ultrasonography
MPV, mean pixel value; PH, pixels heterogeneity; COD, cystic ovarian disease; PRID, progesterone intravaginal device
Cystic ovarian disease (COD) in bovine is defined as the presence of large follicle-like structure on one of the ovaries having a diameter of 2.5cm or greater, that persists for at least 10days, in the absence of luteal tissue.1However recent evidence from ultrasound studies has shown that all cows with cysts conform to this definition. It appears that some cysts are less than 25mm in diameter and do not always persist for as long as 10days.2 COD remains an important cause of the extension of the interval from calving to conception3 and increased number of inseminations per conception thus decreased the reproductive performance.4 The disease is a common condition of dairy cattle characterized by ovulatory failure.1 Their incidence ranged from 5% to 8%.5 COD is more common in the early post partum period (less than 60 days) at which cows are under great metabolic stress.6 Many factors have been associated with COD although their exact mechanism of action is not known. These factors include, high milk production,7 a sever negative energy balance and ketosis,4,7,8 twinning and periparturient problems9 genetic predisposition,10 season,6 and nutritional disorders11 suggested that, COD results from the failure of the pituitary gland to release sufficient amounts of LH to induce ovulation.
However many studies of the endocrine profiles of cows with COD, showed that, concentrations of serum LH are high12 or normal13 serum FSH are low or normal,12,14 and serum inhibin are high.13 In addition to the alteration in gonadotropin levels, there is a deficiency in LH and FSH receptors at the ovarian level.15 Many treatment strategies have been used to resolve the cystic condition. These include manual rupture, dexamethasone, progesterone GnRH, hcG and PGF2a.16 GnRH is currently the treatment of choice for undifferentiated COD.16,17 PGF2a alone is the treatment of choice for luteal cysts.18 A new protocol GnRH/PGF2a GnRH (ovsynch) has also been used to treat COD.19 The use of progesterone for treatment of COD has been well documented and is known to relieve COD.20,21
Computers have been used for quantitative measurement of changes in ultrasonographic morphology22 and echotexture23 of the reproductive tissues. The present study was designed to evaluate the efficacy of progesterone-hcG combination in treatment of ovarian follicular cyst with the aid of rectal palpation, diagnostic ultrasound, echotexture analysis of ultrasound images and progesterone profile.
The present work was carried out on 31 Egyptian buffalo-cows (aged 3-10years) diagnosed as follicular cyst. Animals from the veterinary clinics of Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (Moshtohor & Alexandria Universities) were studied during the period from January to October 2003. Cystic ovaries were diagnosed by palpation per rectum a cystic structures more than 2.5cm in diameter of follicular antrum on one or both ovaries and persisted for three successive examinations. Ultrasonography examination was performed at 7days interval in the absence of a corpus luteum.24 Confirmatory diagnosis by progesterone determination was done using RIA technique25 after collection of blood samples twice (at the time of initial diagnoses and 7-14days later). The level of progesterone was <1.0ng/ml for follicular cyst and >1.0ng/ml for luteal cysts. Animals under investigation were in good body condition, healthy, had no history of other reproductive disorders or treatment with other hormones.
Following diagnosis, animals were classified into two main groups (treated and control) as follows
Group I (treated animals): Twenty buffalo cows with follicular cyst were injected with 100mg Progesterone oily in nature (Lutone, Misr Comp. for pharm., Egypt) followed by im injection of 5000 IU hcG at day 5 (Proffassi, E.I.P.I. Co, Egypt) to induce luteinization, from the fourteen responded animals nine were injected 25mg PGF2α (Lutalyse, Upjohn, Belgium) at 14days, while the remaining five animals were left as control. The non-responded buffalo-cows (6 out of 20) to progesterone and hcG were classified into two subgroups (each included 3 animals) one of which was injected hcG and the other one left as control.
Group II (control animals): Eleven buffalo cows with follicular cyst were injected with saline. The observation of a CL was substantiated by an increase in serum progesterone to a level above 1ng/ml. The positive ovarian response to treatment or recovery was defined by formation of CL 7-14days after stop of progesterone injection26,27 or luteinization of the cyst which characterized by increased cyst wall thickness with granular echogenic appearance as visualized by ultrasound27 or by an increase in serum progesterone correlated to the presence of a cyst and absence of CL. Animal that did not come in heat, and had a CL on the ovary, which was palpated per rectum or scanned ultrasonography 12-14days after progesterone treatment was stopped, were considered responded to the treatment as well. A negative ovarian response or no recovery was defined by persistence of cyst or development of a new one without luteal progress, absence of both estrus and no CL 14days after progesterone injection was stopped.26,28 The obtained data of CL appearance, cyst disappearance, and some fertility indices (appearance of estrus, conception rate, and No. of services per- conception) were statistically analyzed according to Shedecor & Cochran29 using chi-square and student “t” test for significance evaluation of the treatment.29
Ultrasound images of ovarian follicles were saved to a floppy disk for later computer analysis. Special software was used for analysis of ultrasound images (Scion Image for Windows V 4.0, based on NIH Image for Macintosh. National Institute of Health, USA). The software was designed to quantify characteristics of user- selected regions. Pierson & Adams22 defined echotexture in terms of mean pixel value (MPV) and pixel heterogeneity (PH).22 Mean pixel value (average of gray-scale values) was quantified using values ranging from 0 (black) to 255 (White), and the degree of deviation from the mean (standard deviation) of pixel values within the user-defined region was used as indicator of heterogeneity. Greater standard deviation was taken as indication of greater heterogeneity among pixel values within selected regions. Evaluation of the follicle antrum involved sampling a circular region covering 80% of each quadrant of each image of the antrum (Figure 1). Evaluation of images of the follicle wall involved sampling from two circle regions (Figure 1) within 10 and 2 o’clock positions.30,31 Statistical analysis for MPV and PH was carried out using ANOVA, while multiple comparisons were made by LSD. Pearson’s correlation coefficients were used to examine the relationship between ultrasound image attributes.32
Thirty one buffalo-cows diagnosed rectally to have follicular cyst and confirmed by serum progesterone and ultrasonography. Rectal diagnosis of follicular cyst was based on the presence of single or multiple follicular structure of at least 25mm in diameter on one or both ovaries in the absence of CL. Ultrasonography examination revealed that, the follicular cyst appeared as an uniformly nonechogenic ovarian structure >25mm in diameter with a wall <3mm (Figure 2). Serum progesterone confirms the diagnosis of follicular cyst as their level < 0.9ng/ml. Out of 20 treated buffalo cows 14 (70%) were diagnosed sonographically and confirmed by serum progesterone to have luteinized cyst within 11-18day (15.71±0.75days). The other 6 buffalo-cows, which not responded to the treatment, were classified into two subgroups (3 animals treated with hCG and 3 animals left without treatment as control). The recovery rate was 33.33% in both subgroups (indicated with presence of CL formation and appearance of estrus in animals treated with hCG and CL formation without estrus) in control subgroup. Out of 11 control animals 3(27.27%) have luteinized cyst within 30-35days (32.67±1.45days) (Table 1).
Criteria |
Control (n = 11) |
Treated (n = 20) |
Days till Appearance of Luteinized Cyst |
32.67±1.45a |
15.71 ± 0.75b |
Recovery Rate |
3/11 |
14/20 |
Days to Estrus |
56.33 ± 2.03a |
22.20 ± 1.19b |
Conception Rate |
1/3 |
10/14 |
Days to Conception |
64.00 ± 0.00a |
36.50 ± 1.47b |
Table 1 Clinical findings in animals with follicular ovarian cyst
Values with different alphabetic within the same raw were significantly different at P<0.05
The 14 buffalo-cows, which have luteinized cyst, classified into two subgroups (the first, 9 animals injected i.m. with PGF2α and the second, 5 animals left without treatment). Out of 9 animals treated with PGF2α 7 animals (77.78%) came in estrus earlier. Three animals (60%) out of 5-control subgroup came in estrus later. The other 6 buffalo-cows, which not responded to the treatment, were classified into two subgroups (3 animals treated with hcG and 3 animals left without treatment as control). The recovery rate was 33.33%(1/3) in both subgroups (indicated with presence of CL formation and appearance of estrus in animals treated with hcG and CL formation with no heat in control subgroups). The days to estrus appearance was 22.20±1.19days in treated animals and 56.33±2.03days in control one. The conception rate was significantly (66.67%) in the treated group than in the non-treated one (33.33%). Days elapsed to conception was increased (64days) in control animals than in treated one (36.5±1.47days).
The mean level of serum progesterone in responded and non responded follicular cysts of treated animals was significantly differed at 7days pre treatment and 14days post treatment with progesterone and hcG; and 7days post treatment with PGF2a in previously responded animals. Regarding the effect of the treatment on responded follicular cyst (Table 2), the progesterone level was significantly increased (P<0.01) 14days post treatment with progesterone and hCG (1.40±0.03ng/ml) in comparison to their level at 7days pre treatment (0.35±0.02ng/ml) and 7days after PGF2a showed significant decrease (P<0.01) in serum progesterone level (0.41±0.03ng/ml) compared to their level before PGF2α injection. The level of progesterone in non responded cases significantly increased (P<0.01) at day 14 post treatment with progesterone and hCG (0.59±0.02ng/ml) compared to that 7days pre treatment (0.42±0.01ng/ml).
Criteria |
Responded Follicular Cyst |
Unresponded Follicular Cyst |
7 days Pre-treatment with Progression and hcG |
0.35 ± 0.02c |
0.42 ± 0.01b |
14 days Post Treatment with Progesterone and hcG |
1.40 ± 0.03a |
0.59 ± 0.02**a |
7 days Post Treatment with PGf2α |
0.41 ± 0.02b |
0.61 ± 0.03a |
Table 2 The mean level of serum progesterone (ng/ml) in treated group
**Significant difference within the same raw
Values with different alphabetic within the same column were significantly different at P<0.05
The mean level of progesterone was significantly decreased (P<0.01) in animal injected with PGF2α (0.41±0.02ng/ml) compared to their level before PGF2α injection. On the other hand progesterone level significantly increased (P<0.01) in non responded animals after injection of hcG (0.61±0.03ng/ml) compared to their level before hcG injection (0.59±0.02ng/ml). The relationship between progesterone level and the thickness of the cyst wall was positively correlated as the cyst wall thickness increased the progesterone level increased.
Results of echotexture analysis of ultrasound images of ovarian follicles have shown that there was a significant (P<0.001) increase in MPV of the wall of luteinized cystic follicles compared with preovulatory and cystic follicles (Figure 3), while there was a non significant decrease in MPV of the wall of cystic follicles compared to preovulatory follicles. There was a significant correlation between MPV and PH of the follicle wall (r=0.84, r=0.81, respectively, P=0.001) and antrum (r=0.80, r=0.79, respectively, P=0.001), with the advancement of follicular development [preovulatory, cystic, then luteinized cystic follicles] (Figure 4).
A significant increase in MPV and PH of the follicle antrum was observed in the luteinized cystic follicles compared with preovulatory and cystic follicles (Figure 3) (Figure 4). On the other hand, changes in PH of the wall and antrum of cystic follicles were not significant compared with preovulatory follicles, while a significant increase was observed in PH values of the wall and antrum of luteinized cystic follicles compared with cystic follicles (Figure 4). A significant correlation was also observed between MPV of the wall of luteinized cystic follicles and serum progesterone level (r=0.87, P<0.001).
Ovarian cysts were diagnosed clinically on the basis of behavioral abnormalities and rectal palpation of the ovaries confirmed with progesterone and ultrasonography. These findings came in accordance with Ridabu et al.33 In the same aspect Jeffcoate & Ayliffe21 found that, plasma progesterone concentration was a useful adjunct to ultrasound interpretation of the cysts serum progesterone concentration was similar for cows diagnosed by rectal palpation as having luteal cysts compared with those having follicular cysts.2
They added that, diagnosis of cysts by ultrasonography showed higher progesterone level for luteal cysts (1.01±0.16ng/ml) than for follicular cysts (0.30±0.01ng/ml). The successful treatment of cysts was utilized by crud pituitary extracts that were high in LH content, human chorioric gonadotropin (hCG) with a success rate of 65 to 80%,34 synthetic GnRH analogues with success about 80%28,35 and administration of progesterone for treatment of the thin wall non estrogenic cyst.36,37 The present study revealed that, 70% of treated buffalo-cows having luteinized cyst within 11-18days. The recovery rate was similar to those observed after GnRH 70-80%.16
These findings came in agreement with Nakao et al.28 Luteotropic agents as hCG and GnRH in case of follicular cysts to induce luteinization.28 They also explained that, the combined treatment of follicular cysts with 1500IU hcG/150mg progesterone or 5000IU hcG/300 mg progesterone was effective even when performed long after calving and recommended for practical application. Recently, Zulu et al.27 concluded that, exogenous progesterone might play a role in restoring hypothalamus sensitivity, to estradiol in cows with ovarian cysts.27 Additionally Nanda et al.20 reported that, there was no difference in recovery rates between treatment of follicular cyst with GnRH and progesterone intravaginal device (PRID).20 The recovery rate in the other non-responded animals was 33.33% if treated with hCG injection. This might explained that, injection of hCG during luteal phase caused delayed regression of CL or the cows having luteinized cysts and treated with hCG need longer period to exhibit estrus than their herd mates.34
The present study revealed that the recovery rate of control animals was 27.27%. These findings came in accordance with Bierschwal et al.38 and Garverick39 who found that, approximately 20% of cows with cysts spontaneously resume ovulatory ovarian cycles. In the same respect, Jou et al.1 reported that, the follicular cysts do not interfere with normal ovarian function. Other researchers recorded that, 15% of dairy cows showed ovarian cysts during the early postpartum period and in most cases these cysts disappear spontaneously while in the remainder initiation of the cycle in inhibited.40 Animals showing luteinization of the cyst and injected with PGF2a came in estrus with a recovery rate 77.78% and their conception rate was 66.67%.
Similar results were obtained by Garverick39 at which cysts responded to hCG or GnRH by leutinization of the cystic structure, PGF2a cause lysis of luteinized cysts. These findings were supported by Kesler and Garverick,41 Nada et al.,20 and Archibald et al.42 who reported that, PGF2a appeared to be more effective in inducing luteolysis when given 9 to 14days after GnRH or hCG than when given earlier. The days to estrus and conception was significantly (P<0.01) shorter in treated animals than in control ones.
These finding came in accordance with Kesler & Garverick41 and Zulu et al.27 Similarly Nakao et al.28 found beneficial effect of the GnRH-PGF2a combination in the treatment of follicular cysts resulted in shorter intervals from treatment to estrus, as well as conception and higher conception rates in comparison to the untreated animals.28 The luteinized cysts responded very rapidly to PGF2a treatment, collapsing within 2-4days and the newly formed CL were observed within one week after the treatment confirmed by a rapid decrease of plasma progesterone.21On the other hand, Stolla et al.43 disagreed with the previous results and could not record any beneficial effect of PGF2a given 14days after GnRH.43
The present study revealed that there was a positive correlation between the thickness of cyst wall and progesterone level. These findings come in agreement with Douthwaite & Dobson.36 Thick-walled cyst produce progesterone whereas thin-walled cyst in the absence of other follicles of more than 5mm diameter produce estradiol, but thin-walled cyst in the presence of other follicles of more than 5mm diameter are not estrogenic.44‒46 All thick-walled cysts should respond immediately to PGF2a.35 On the other hand, Tebble et al.,37 found no influence of follicular cyst wall thickness on the outcome of treatment either with GnRH or PRID.37
Computer-assisted echotexture analysis offers the potential of a highly sensitive and quantitative method of assessing follicular and luteal status.22,23 Changes in pixel values and pixel heterogeneity of the follicle antrum and wall were documented and specific correlations were assessed between them and serum progesterone levels. MPV obtained by spot analysis of the antrum, is a measure of the overall (average) gray-scale value of the pixels falling under the measuring circle, while PH of the antrum is a measure of the variation in gray-scale value of pixels falling under the measuring circle. Luteinized cysts have a thicker wall than non luteinized cysts; this thick wall of luteal cysts is composed of luteal tissue.39 In the present study, a significant increase was observed in MPV of the wall and antrum of luteinized follicles compared to cystic and preovulatory follicles. Similar results were reported by Schrick et al.47 who stated that luteal cyst has an obvious wall with a rougher inner lining and has the echotexture of a mature corpus luteum.47 They added that the antrum of luteal cysts have an echoic band-like network.
A significant positive correlation between MPV of the wall of luteinized cystic follicles and serum progesterone level was observed in the present study. Similar finding was reported by Singh et al.23 who stated that pixel values of ultrasound images were highly correlated to plasma and luteal tissue progesterone concentrations.23
In conclusion the present study evaluate some ultrasound parameters used as diagnostic tool for ovarian cyst in buffaloes with emphasis to the wall thickness in differentiation between follicular and luteal cases and consequently in suggesting the treatment. Ultrasonography and echotexture analysis provides a visible method for evaluating wall thickness and distinguishing types of ovarian follicles in buffaloes, and aid in diagnostic and treatment purposes.
None.
Author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
©2015 Noseir, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.