Research Article Volume 6 Issue 6
Department of Anthropology, University of Calcutta, 35, Ballygunge circular Road, Kolkata – 700019, India
Correspondence: Arup Ratan Bandyopadhyay, Department of Anthropology, University of Calcutta, 35, Ballygunge circular Road, Kolkata – 700019, India
Received: November 19, 2018 | Published: December 28, 2018
Citation: Ghosh K, Bhattacharya P, Maitra S, et al. Stature estimation from digit length, bi-acromian and bi-illiac length: a study among two populations from eastern and north eastern India. Forensic Res Criminol Int J. 2018;6(6):523?525. DOI: 10.15406/frcij.2018.06.00253
Background: Identification of human remains in medico-legal situation contribution of forensic anthropology is imperative. Forensic anthropology deals with identification of age, sex and ethnicity. Apart from that estimation of stature is found to be one of the major parameters of forensic anthropology, is an essential element of medico-legal investigations when identifications of unknown dismembered remains are involved. The publication regarding estimation of statute seems to be scanty from Eastern India and specially from North East India.
Aim: The present study was conducted with an aim to estimate stature from 2D, 4D, Bi-acromian length and Bi-illiac length of adult age matched females belonging to Bengalee Hindu Caste Population from Eastern India and one of the ethnic groups (Chakmas) of North East India (Tripura).
Materials and methods: To achieve the purpose, the participants of the present study were comprised of 100 Chakma females and 100 Bengalee females of 25 to 35 years age ranges. Prior to the study verbal consent were obtained from the participants. The ring finger is the fourth digit (4D) of the human hand and the second most ulnar finger located between the middle finger and the little finger while the index finger is the second digit (2D), located between the thumb and the middle finger and usually the most dexterous and sensitive finger of the hand were measured using standard method. Along with digit measurements, stature was obtained using standard technique. Obtained data were doubly checked and analyzed using the SPSS (Version- 16.0). Descriptive and inferential statistics were done in appropriate places and cut off was set as p=0.05.
Results: Distributions of the anthropometric variables including 2D and 4D demonstrated significant (p<0.05) between the age matched Bengalee and the Chakma females for all the characteristics. Examination of estimation of stature using multiplication factors revealed least mean value for the bi-illiac length while, the highest being the mean value for 2D among both the population. However, the comparison between the population the mean multiplication factors for estimation of stature, the length of 2D, 4D and Bi-illac length demonstrated significant (p<0.05) difference between the two population groups. So far the forensic issues concern regarding the stature estimation by multiplication factors, the best predictors were Bi-illica length followed by Bi-acromian length for both the studied populations. The correlation analysis demonstrated most of the measurements demonstrated significant (p<0.05) positive correlation with stature except bi-acromian and bi-illiac among the Bengalee females and Chakma females respectively.
Conclusion: The study concludes that stature estimation from 2D and 4D lengths along with bi-acromian and bi-illiac lengths could be utilized for specific population group.
Recognition of human remains is an indispensable element in medico-legal aspects and at the same time one of the major undertaking by the forensic anthropologist is the identification of fragmentary and mutilated remains. The identification of stature of the deceased, and comparisons with the ante-mortem data and age and sex assessment, has been subject matter of many forensic anthropology researches over the time and space.1,2 The process of identification is generally imperative in cases of mass disasters, explosions, and assault cases where the body is fragmented and establishing the identity of the victim being the challenge for investigator.3 It is here that accurate sexing of the human remains has the potential to primarily narrow down the search to a particular sex thereby giving sense of direction to the ongoing forensic investigation. Although genetic analysis of human population does not support concepts of innate racial differences with respect to innate abilities or characteristics, but human as polytypic and allopatric species demonstrate wide range of morphological, quantitative, polymorphic variations across the word. Being at the crossroads of migration, Indian populations have undergone complex and ancient admixture events over a long period4‒6 and have been the melting-pot of disparate ancestries originating from different parts of Eurasia and South-East Asia.6 Although the date of entry of modern humans into India remains uncertain but it is reasonable to consider by the middle Paleolithic period (50,000–20,000 years before present [ybp]), humans appear to have spread onto many parts of India.7 Contemporary ethnic India is a land of enormous genetic, cultural, and linguistic diversity.8,9 A more recent study exploring Indian genomic diversity demonstrated four major ancestral genetic components in mainland India that included four dominant ancestries in populations from mainland India: Ancestral North-Indian (ANI), Ancestral South-Indian (ASI), Ancestral Tibeto–Burman (ATB) and Ancestral Austro-Asiatic (AAA).6 Dismembered remains including the terminal parts of the human body such as hands and feet are often found in cases of mass disaster and homicides. Studies have highlighted on the role of hand and foot measurements in establishing the biological profile of individuals in forensic investigations.1‒4,10 Besides the lengths of the fingers such as 2D:4D ratios have also been used for predicting sex of an individual. Since, the relative lengths of digits are set before birth,11 therefore, intra uterine environment that affect the limbs in the critical period of limb formation also related to normal development of limbs which might reflected through the ratio of the parts of the limb dimensions. Apart from finger digit ratios (2D:4D), androgyny score involving bi-acromial and bi-illiac lengths are also found to be the measures, which has significant effect on sexual dimorphism.12 On the basis of the literature review on major and contributing publications regarding the stature estimation from hand, other long and finger bones dimensions10‒13 concerns, it has been found that studies on the indigenous population of Tripura seems to be under represented. In this backdrop, the present study, to best of the knowledge is the first attempt to understand the above mentioned issues on one Tibeto-Burman speaker endogamous ethnic populations (Chakmas-the migrant group) of North East India (Tripura) and compared with Bengalee population from Eastern India (West Bengal).
The participants of the present study were comprised of 100 Chakma females and 100 Bengalee females of 25 to 35 years age ranges. Prior to the study verbal consent were obtained from the participants. The ring finger is the fourth digit (4D) of the human hand and the second most ulnar finger located between the middle finger and the little finger while the index finger is the second digit (2D), located between the thumb and the middle finger and usually the most dexterous and sensitive finger of the hand.14 Stature was obtained using standard technique.15 Obtained data were doubly checked and analyzed using the SPSS (Version- 16.0). Descriptive and inferential statistics were done in appropriate places and cut off was set as p=0.05.
Distributions of the anthropometric variables including 2D and 4D (Table 1) demonstrated significant (p<0.05) between the age matched Bengalee and the Chakma females for all the characteristics. Furthermore, the analysis revealed except the bi-acromian length all the anthropometric variables were significantly (p<0.05) higher in Bengalee females. Examination of estimation of stature through multiplication factors (Table 2) the present study revealed least mean value for the bi-illiac length while, the highest being the mean value for 2D among both the population. However, the comparison between the population the mean multiplication factors for estimation of stature, the length of 2D, 4D and Bi-illac length demonstrated significant (p<0.05) difference between the two population groups belonging two discrete geographical, ecological and linguistic affiliation, indicated differential dimensions in body proportions. So far the forensic issues concern regarding the stature estimation through multiplication factors, the best predictors were Bi-illiac length followed by Bi-acromian length for both the studied populations. Apart from the analysis of multiplication factors, to understand the relationship of stature and other measures such as bi-acromian, bi-illiac lengths, digit measurements (2D and 4D) correlations have been computed (Table 3). Majority of the measurements demonstrated significant (p<0.05) positive correlation with stature except bi-acromian and bi-illiac among the Bengalee females and Chakma females respectively. Bengalee females revealed significant (p<0.05) negative correlation between stature and bi-acromian length, while Chakma females showed in contrast the negative correlation between stature and bi-illiac length. It would be apparent from the analysis that, since the Chakmas and Bengalee population are the two discrete ethnic groups and resides in discrete geographical zone, the body structure concerning the bi-acromian and the bi-illiac dimension seems to be variable might be due to adaptability. Furthermore, the comparative analysis of these aspects remains unresolved, since no previous study has been encountered regarding reconstruction of stature by these anthropometric measures for either of the population. So far the coefficient of determination (R2) concern, 2D length showed highest (38.3%) value to determine the stature for Chakma females, while for Bengalee females highest coefficient of determination (7.1%) for stature revealed by bi-illiac length. In this circumstance, the study concludes that stature estimation and /or reconstruction from digit (2D and 4D) lengths along with other anthropometric variables (bi-acromian and bi-illiac) lengths should be utilized for specific population group. Therefore, the present study stimulates further studies in different population.
Population |
Stature (cm) |
2D (cm) |
4D (cm) |
Bi-Acromial Length (cm) |
Bi-Illiac |
Bengalee |
155.81±7.48* |
7.39± 0.49* |
7.89 ±0.51* |
26.48 ± 6.28 |
30.37±2.91* |
Chakma |
151.21 ±4.98 |
6.22±.0.41 |
6.52±.0.66 |
29.65 ± 5.19* |
29.28± 3.64 |
Table 1 Distribution of anthropometric variables of the studied population
*p<0.05
Variables |
Bengalee |
Chakma |
Height/2D length |
21.17±1.67 |
24.21±1.26* |
Height/4D length |
19.79±1.49 |
23.37±1.71* |
Height/Bi-acromial length |
6.21±1.53 |
6.06±6.47 |
Height/Bi-iliac length |
5.14±0.51 |
5.62±1.07* |
Table 2 Distribution of multiplication Factors for estimation of stature of the studied population
*p<0.05
Variable |
Predictors |
Bengalee |
Chakma |
||
r |
R2 |
r |
R2 |
||
2D |
0.216* |
0.046 |
0.619* |
0.383 |
|
4D |
0.258* |
0.067 |
0.525* |
0.275 |
|
Height |
Bi-acromial |
- 0.298* |
0.089 |
0.237* |
0.056 |
Bi-iliac |
0.266* |
0.071 |
-0.126 |
0.016 |
Table 3 Correlation between stature and anthropometric variables of the studied population
Though the case report of the homicide as reported here adds nothing new contextually, this case brings to light along with other such cases the increasing phenomenon of infidelity and homicide in Rural India where till now the strong social foundations of marriage and fidelity are being eroded gradually. There has been a steady rise in matricides in areas which were untouched by this occurrence.
None
The corresponding author confirms on behalf of all authors that there have been no involvements that might raise the question of bias in the work reported or in the conclusions, implications, or opinions stated.
©2018 Ghosh, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.