Submit manuscript...
MOJ
eISSN: 2475-5494

Women's Health

Research Article Volume 8 Issue 5

Awareness of sexual trafficking and associated factors among youth females in debre birhan town, north shewa, Ethiopia, 2017

Ayele Mamo Abebe,1 Fikir Alebachew Mengistu,2 Mesfin Wudu Kassaw,3 Mulugeta Mihrete Tefera4

1Department of Nursing, Debre Birhan Health Sciences College, Debre Birhan 37, Amhara, Ethiopia
2Department of nursing, Dessie health sciences college, Amhara, Ethiopia
3Department of nursing, College of health sciences, Woldia University, Amhara, Ethiopia
4Pharmacy Department, Bahir Dar health science college, Ethiopia

Correspondence: Ayele Mamo Abebe, Department of Nursing, Debre Birhan Health Sciences College, Debre Birhan 37, Amhara, Ethiopia

Received: August 10, 2019 | Published: September 27, 2019

Citation: Abebe AM, Mengistu FA, Kassaw MW, et al. Awareness of sexual trafficking and associated factors among youth females in debre birhan town, north shewa, Ethiopia, 2017. MOJ Women’s Health. 2019;8(5):275?284. DOI: 10.15406/mojwh.2019.08.00250

Download PDF

Abstract

Background: The International Labor Organization estimated that there are 4.5 million victims of forced sexual exploitation worldwide; 98% of whom are estimated to be women and girls due to low awareness of sexual trafficking. In recent years, there has been a great attention of sexual trafficking in Africa in general and the sub-Saharan African region in particular as a real challenge due to low awareness about it. Youth females are the most targeted group of sexual trafficking. This study was used to assess Awareness of sexual trafficking and associated factors among youth females in Debrebirhan town, North Shewa, Ethiopia, 2017.

Methods: Community based cross-sectional study was conducted. The participants in the study were selected using systematic random sampling techniques. A structured Amharic version questionnaire was used to collect data. Data were entered, cleaned and analyzed using SPSS 22. Logistic regression analysis was used to identify factors associated with sex trafficking awareness. The study findings were displayed by using texts, tables and figures.

Result: In this study, a total of 582 respondents were included. About 300(52%) of respondents reported that they had awareness about sexual trafficking. Mother’s education status (elementary& secondary)[AOR=2.068, 95%CI(1.079-3.963)] and[AOR=3.446, 95% CI(1.298-9.154)],parents’ occupation (Gov’tal employee)[AOR=2.2, 95%CI(1.02-4.747)],Youth females’ occupation(gov’tal work)[AOR=6.203, 95% CI(1.099-35.005)],having television at home [AOR=2.083, 95% CI(1.305-3.326)] and taking training on gender issues [AOR=3.887, 95% CI: (2.591-5.832)]were the possible independent risk factors for awareness of sexual trafficking.

Conclusion: In this study, sexual trafficking awareness was low among youth females. Mother education status, parents’ occupation, current jobs of participant, having television in home and have taking training on gender issues were significantly associated with awareness of sexual trafficking. Therefore, providing education about sexual trafficking will help to increase sexual trafficking awareness among youth females.

Keywords: sexual trafficking, associated factor, youth female, harboring, deception, violence, poverty, unemployment, vulnerability, smuggled

Abbreviations

AIM, Action and Investment to Defeat Malaria; CDC, Center for Disease Control; FGD,Focus Group Discussion; HC, Health Center; HEP, Health Extension Program; HP, Health Post; HSB, Health Seeking Behavior; HH, Household; IEC, Information Education Communication; IMNCI, Integrated Management of Neonatal and Childhood Illness; MOH, Ministry of Health; NMV, Non-Mobile Clinic Village; MV, Mobile Clinic Villages; PHC, Primary Health Care; RDT, Rapid Diagnostic Tests; SSA, Sub Sahara Africa; TM, Traditional Medicine; WHO, World Health Organization

Introduction

The United Nation defines sex trafficking as “the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harboring, or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability” for the purposes of sexual exploitation and for economic and other personal gains.1 Sexual trafficking is not synonymous with prostitution but it is an umbrella term that may include commercial sex work such as prostitution, but also pornography, exotic dancing, stripping, live sex shows, mail-order brides, military prostitution, and sexual tourism.2 According to the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime worldwide report, most migrant women and girls have no awareness about sexual trafficking.3According to the United Nation Office on Drugs and Crime(UNODC) report, the numbers of trafficked women have increased both in developed and developing countries.4 It is difficult to estimate accurately the global prevalence of sexual trafficking due to its hidden nature.5 But a recent estimate indicated that trafficking reaches between one and two million people each year worldwide; 60-70% of which are young girls.6 The International Labor Organization (ILO) estimated that there are 4.5million victims of forced sexual exploitation worldwide; 98% of whom are estimated to be women and girls.7 According to the ILO report the related causes of unawareness of sexual trafficking are its hidden nature, Access of source of information, socio-demographic condition of the families and the participant, training on gender based violence, poverty, unemployment and political conditions.7

Sexual trafficking in Ethiopia, mostly takes the form of transporting migrants by fraud, deception and different forms of coercion and it causes a number of serious problems, turning the hope of many young girls to tragedy.8 As explained by UNODC in the above, Most of Ethiopian women and young girls migrant do not have awareness about sexual trafficking.4 According to a survey report by UNICEF, sexual trafficking is considered as either severe or very severe problem in more than 70% of West and Central African counties; it is identified as so in 33% of the East and Southern African counties.9 According to U.S. Department of State report, in the first half of 2012 alone, over 160,000 migrants migrated regularly to Saudi Arabia to work in the domestic sector, using the services of Private Employment Agencies (PEAs).10,11 ILO estimates that irregular Ethiopian migration to Saudi Arabia is double the size of regular migration.12 The US Department of State reports that Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs (MOLSA) even estimates that the 200,000 regular labour migrants in 2012 represent just 30 to 40% of all Ethiopians migrating to the Middle East, implicating that the remaining 60% to 70% are either sexually trafficked or smuggled with the facilitation of illegal brokers.13 The above report also shows that of the migrants of the year 2012, more than 85% are youth female students who either dropped or quitted schools at primary or secondary level. Similarly, the ILO report of 2013 on migrant workers indicated that, one of the largest current international migration flows is Ethiopian women and girls migrating to the Middle East as domestic workers, which also often occurs through trafficking. In recent times the number of sexually trafficked Ethiopian women to the Middle East has dramatically increased.14 Because the migrants do not have awareness about the sexual trafficking and they do not know what they will do in the foreign countries after they arrive.4

The studies conducted in Bahir Dar city in 2014 and in 2015 in Nepal showed that 60% and 76% of the respondents had awareness of sexual trafficking respectively.15,16 According the Nepal’s study, relatives and friends were mentioned as mediators for sexual trafficking by 51.4% and 34.2% of the respondents respectively whereas in Bahir Dar study Friends and brokers were mentioned as mediators for sexual trafficking by 87% and 74% of the study participants respectively.16,15 The above findings are consistent with the studies done in Nigeria and South Africa.17–19 Based on the study done in Nepal,62.2%, 58.6%, 56.8%, and 25.2% of the respondents mentioned poverty, lack of awareness, interest on big money, and illiteracy respectively as reasons for being trafficked.16 Similarly the study done in Bahir Dar city, 45%, 50% and 72% of the study participants mentioned poverty, unemployment and hoping for a better life elsewhere respectively as reasons for sex trafficking.15 These findings are consistent with those reported in studies in South Asia, Nigeria, and South Africa.17,20,21 A Cross-Sectional Study carried out in Nepal revealed that 58.6% and 25.2% of the respondents mentioned lack of awareness and illiteracy respectively as associated for being trafficked.16 Correspondingly, the studies done in Nigeria and Ethiopia (Bahir Dar) had shown 56.1 % and 18% of the participants reported illiteracy as factors associated with sex trafficking respectively.18,15

The consequence of sexual trafficking is multifold including the physical, psychological, social, economic and political problems. Different studies also reported that sex trafficking has high negative impact on the physical, mental, social and psychological wellbeing of women and girls.10,22–25 Sexually-trafficked women and girls are more likely to contract HIV/AIDS and other STDs.26 Infectious diseases such as tuberculosis are also a frequent consequence for trafficking victims.27 When intervention efforts are concerned, Ethiopian government and non-government al organizations are tried to protect the human right of sexual trafficked women in Ethiopia and out of the Ethiopia. Despite efforts made by the government and non-governmental organizations, victims of sex trafficking are increasing. Still, many women and young girls want to go abroad without knowing the situations there.4,28 There are also some studies conducted by individual researchers on human trafficking in Ethiopia,29–33 Most of these studies are highly concerned on the investigation of the challenges, prospects, and different kinds of right violations that Ethiopian domestic workers experience in the Arab Middle East. However, during this time, there is no enough research on youth females’ awareness about sex trafficking in the study area as well as in Ethiopia. So, reliable evidence on awareness of sex trafficking at grass root level is important to formulate evidence based approaches for effective preventative interventions against sexual trafficking. Therefore, this study is designed to assess awareness of sex trafficking and associated factors among youth females in Debre Birhan town, North-Shewa, Ethiopia

Methods and materials

  1. Study area and period

The A community based cross-sectional study design was conducted in Debre Birhan town, the capital city of North Shewa, which is located 120kms North of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. According to Debre Birhan town administrative office report of 2009 E.C population census, the total population of the town was estimated 97969(44,300 males and 53,669 females). There were 14437 youth girls in Debre Birhan town. The study period was from February 7 to April 7, 2017. The source population was all youth females aged 15-24years who were living in the Debre Birhan town.

  1. Eligibility criteria

Inclusion Criteria: All youth females aged 15-24years who were living in the selected kebeles at least for six Months.

Exclusion criteria: Youth female girls who were mentally ill, chronically ill who could not reply interview and have hearing problem. 

  1. Sample size determination and sampling procedure

Sample size: Single population proportional formula was used to determine sample size based on the following assumptions: 95% level of confidence (Zα/2=1.96), the proportion of respondents who heard about sex trafficking in a previous study (p=60%),26 and margin of error (d=5%). The sample size will be calculated as follow.

The sample size was 582 by using design effect 1.5 and then 5% contingency.

  1. Sampling techniques

The multi-stages sampling method was employed. The Debre Birhan town had 14kebeles. Then, by using simple random sampling technique six kebeles were selected. By using population proportion to size each Kebele had its own sample size. Household was used as a sampling unit in this study. By listing the households, I gave code for every household for those with youth female starting from North direction and goes to East, South and West direction.

Households were selected using systematic random sampling. The sampling interval (K) was obtained by dividing each selected kebele’s total house hold number with youth female to the sample size of each selected kebele, so that k=N/n= every 7th house hold(hh) was visited until we got 582 youth female. The first house hold was selected by lottery method from the sampling interval (K). If there was more than one youth female in a household, lottery method was used to select one participant. If the selected youth was not available at home at the time of visit, revisit for the second time was made to contact the selected youth for interview. If I did not get again I took the reserved on from the house which had more than one girls. The data collection time was afternoon after the class for students and weekend (Saturday and Sunday) since most of the participant were students (Figure 1).

Figure 1 Schematic representation of sampling procedure for debrebirehan town, Ethiopia 2017.

  1. Data collection tool and procedure

Structured self-administered questionnaire was used to elicit information about sexual trafficking from the study participants. The questionnaire was taken from previous similar study in Bahir Dar town.26 The English version questionnaire was translated to Amharic version questionnaire. Again the Amharic language questionnaire was back translated to English language to check for its original meaning. The questionnaires had two sections. The first section was about socio-demographic characteristics of the youth females and their parents and the second section was on sexual trafficking awareness. Five health extension workers and one BSc nurse were recruited as data collectors and supervisor for this study, respectively. The data collection time was afternoon after the class for students and weekend (Saturday and Sunday).

  1. Data quality control

To assure high quality of data, training was given for data collectors and supervisors for one day and the questionnaire was pre-tested on 10% of youth girls from non-selected kebeles and correction was made accordingly. Continuous supervision was done at the spot both by the primary investigator and one recruited supervisor to check completeness of data and to monitor the whole data collection process. Finally before beginning the analysis, accuracy of data was verified during the time of data entering into SPSS version 22.

  1. Data processing and management

The collected data was checked manually for completeness, coded and entered in to SPSS Version 22. After the entry was completed, data cleaning was performed by running frequency of each variable to check accuracy, inconsistency and missed value of the data.

  1. Data analysis

Analysis was done using SPSS version 22. Descriptive statistics was calculated using frequency and percentage. All Variables having p value <0.25 in the bivariate analysis was fitted in to the multivariable logistic regression. Variables having p-value less than 0.05 in the multivariable binary logistic regression model were declared as significantly associated with the dependent variable. Finally, findings of the study were presented by using texts, tables and figures.

Results

  1. Socio-demographic characteristic of respondents’ parents

 In this study, a total of 582 respondents were included with 100% response rate. Four hundred forty nine (77.1%) participants’ parents were married. About 517(88.8%) of the respondents’ parents’ religion were Orthodox and 41(7%) were Muslim. Two hundred sixty participants’ fathers (44.7%) and 214(36.8%) participants’ mothers were able to Read and write. Concerning family size, 517(88.8%) of youth females had greater or equal to four families in their house. Regarding to estimated monthly income of youth females parents’, almost half of respondents (272(46.7%)) earned from 2001-3500birr per month. With regard to the participants job status, most respondents’ 336(57.7%) were farmers and 82 (14.1%) were governmental workers (Table 1).                       

Variables

Category

Frequency

Percent

Parent’s Marital status

Married

449

-77.1

Divorced

79

-13.6

Widowed

54

-9.3

Parents Religion

Orthodox

517

-88.8

Muslim

41

-7

Protestant

18

-3.1

Catholic

6

-1

Educational status of father

Illiterate

115

-19.8

Read &write

260

-44.7

Elementary

88

-15.1

Secondary

45

-7.7

College and above

74

-12.7

Educational status of mother

Illiterate

222

-38.1

Read and write

214

-36.8

Elementary

79

-13.6

Junior/Secondary

35

-6

College and above

32

-5.5

Family size in house

<=3

65

-11.2

>=4

517

-88.8

 Monthly income

<=2000

118

-20.3

2001-3500

272

-46.7

>=3501

192

-33

Parents’ occupation

Farmer

336

-57.7

Merchant

77

-13.2

Gov’tal worker

82

-14.1

Private employee

50

-8.6

Daily wages

37

-6.4

Table 1 Socio-demographic characteristics of youth females' parent's in debrebirehan town, north shewa, Ethiopia2017 (N=582)

  1. Socio-demographic characteristics of youth females

The mean age of youth females was 19.14+2.679 years and most of participants’ age group (58.1%) was 15-19 years. Most of the youth females 517(88.8%) had single marital status. According to this study, about 521 (89.5%) and 522(89.7 %) participants were Orthodox and Amhara correspondingly. The educational status of youth females revealed that, 216 (37.1%) and 208(35.7%) were have College and above and secondary educational status respectively. Four hundred forty one (75.8%) of the participants’ house had radio and 271(46.6%) of the participants house had television in their home. Regarding social media, 196 (33.7%) of the youth females used face book. Two hundred thirty nine (41.1%) of respondents lived with Parents and 393(67.5%) of the respondents’ job was Schooling/student. Majority of the youth females (60.5%) took training on gender issues (Table 2). 

Variables

Categories

Frequency (%)

Awareness of sexual trafficking

Yes

No

Age

15-19

338(58.1)

159

179

20-24

244(41.9)

141

103

Marital status

Single

517(88.8)

265

252

Married

65(11.2)

35

30

Religion

Orthodox

521(89.5)

259

262

Muslim

42(7.2)

33

9

Protestant

19(2.1)

7

12

Catholic

7(1.2)

1

6

Ethnic group

Amhara

522(89.7)

263

259

Oromo

31(5.3)

16

15

Tigary

9(1.5)

2

7

Guragie

20(3.4)

14

6

Education status

Illiterate

9(1.5)

6

3

Read & write

35(6.0)

7

28

Elementary

114(19.6)

52

62

Secondary

208(35.7)

109

99

College and above

216(37.1)

126

90

Presence of radio at home

Yes

441(75.8)

227

214

No

141(24.2)

73

68

Presence of Television at home

Yes

271(46.6)

172

99

No

311(53.4)

128

183

Using social media like, face book

Yes

196(33.7)

129

67

No

386(66.3)

171

215

With whom are you living now

Parents

239(41.1)

130

109

Boyfriend/fiancé/husband      

96(16.5)

50

46

Mother

37(6.4)

24

13

Father

11(1.9)

6

5

Step parents

6(1.0)

3

3

Relatives

69(11.9)

26

43

Alone

124(21.3)

61

63

Current job of the respondents

Doing nothing/Jobless

47(8.1)

25

22

Schooling/student

393(67.5)

207

186

Trading

37(6.4)

22

15

Hair dressing

21(3.6)

9

12

Gov’tal worker

21(3.6)

16

5

Daily wages

63(10.8)

21

42

Taken education or training
on gender issues

Yes

352(60.5)

226

126

No

230(39.5)

74

156

Table 2 Socio-demographic characteristics of youth females in debrebirehan town, north shewa, Ethiopia, June2017 (N=582)

  1. Awareness sexual trafficking among the youth female

Regarding the source of information, about 56.6% and 56.0% of the youth females mentioned television, radio, respectively as sources of information. Brokers, friends and family were mentioned as mediators for sex trafficking by 85.5%, 30.5% and 14.9% of the youth females respectively. According to this study, about 70% of the respondents mentioned that they had heard of women being taken abroad for better work was become victim of sexual trafficking and 55.9%, 53.7% and 21.9% of the respondents mentioned radio, television and friends respectively as sources of information for it. Concerning about the cause of sexual trafficking, 53.3%, 32.7% and 29.0% of youth females mentioned poverty, unemployment and hoping for a better life elsewhere respectively as reasons for being trafficked. Regarding the vulnerability age, about 56% of the participants reported that they did not know vulnerable age for sexual trafficking whereas about 24.3%of the participants reported that youth female’s ages less than 25years were vulnerable for sexual trafficking. About 72 (24%) of the participants reported that they had been approached by someone else to assist them go abroad. One hundred eighty nine (63%) of the respondents had good awareness of sexual trafficking (Table 3) of all youth females, about 300(52%) of respondents had awareness about sexual trafficking (Figure 2).

Variables                                                                                                

Category                                                       

Frequency(582)                  

Percent                  

Source of information about
sex trafficking*(n=300)

Radio

169

56.00%

Television

171

56.60%

Friend

67

22.20%

Relative

24

7.90%

Others

39

12.90%

Do you know about the mediator of
sexual trafficking (n=300)

Yes

248

82.7

No

52

17.3

Mediators for sexual trafficking*(n=300)

Friends

76

30.50%

Brokers

213

85.50%

Family

37

14.90%

Othersb

19

7.60%

Have you heard of women being taken
abroad for better work was become victim of
sexual trafficking(n=300)

Yes

210

70%

No

90

30%

Source of information forgoing
to abroad become victim of Sexual trafficking*(n=300)

Radio

151

55.90%

Television

145

53.70%

Family

21

7.80%

Relative

23

8.50%

Friend

59

21.90%

Othersc

58

21.50%

Perceived reasons for
sexually trafficked*(n=300)

Poverty

160

53.30%

Unemployment

98

32.70%

Hope for better life elsewhere

88

29.00%

Illiteracy

22

7.30%

Low social status

16

5.30%

Do you know that there are
people send women for better work to
abroad to get money (n=300)

Yes

178

59.3

No

122

40.7

Which age groups are most likely
to be trafficked (n=300)

 Age under 25 years old

73

24.3

Age more than 25 years old

23

7.70%

Female of any age

36

12%

I don’t know

168

56%

Has anybody approached you
to assist you in going in other area or abroad (n=300)

Yes

72

24%

No

228

76%

Level of sexual trafficking
awareness

Poor awareness of sexual trafficking

111

37

Good awareness of sexual trafficking

189

63

Table 3 Awareness sexual trafficking among youth females in debrebirehan town, north shewa, Ethiopia, June 2017(N=300)
*Multiple responses are there, a NGO’s written materials, mini medial, newspaper; b news paper, internet; C newspaper, face book, mini media

Figure 2 Awareness of sexual trafficking among youth females in debre birhan town, north shewa, Ethiopia 2017.

  1. Factors associated with awareness of sexual trafficking

In bi variate logistic regression analysis, parent’s religion, father’s education, Mother’s education, Parent’s occupation, participant’s age, Participant’s education, having television at home, using social media like, face book, current job of the respondents and getting training on gender issues were significantly associated with awareness of sexual trafficking. However, in multivariable binary logistic regression analysis, mothers’ education status, parents’ occupation, current jobs of participant, having television in home and have taking training on gender issues were significantly associated with awareness of sexual trafficking with a p-value <0.05. According to this study, youth females whose parents’ education status was elementary and secondary were 2.068(AOR=2.068, 95% CI: 1.079-3.963) and 3.446(AOR=3.446, 95% CI: 1.298-9.154) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking respectively compared to those youth females whose parents’ education status was illiterate.

Youth females whose parents’ occupation was Governmental workers were about 2.2(AOR=2.2, 95% CI: 1.02-4.747) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to those youth females whose parents’ occupation was farming. Youth females who had governmental work were about 6.203(AOR=6.203, 95% CI: 1.099-35.005) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to those youth females were jobless.

Based on this study, youth females who had television at home were about 2.083 (AOR=2.083, 95% CI: 1.305-3.326) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to their counterparts. Youth trained on gender issues were 3.887 (AOR=3.887, 95% CI: 2.591-5.832) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to those youth females who did not take the training (Table 4).

Awareness of sexual trafficking

Variables                                                                        

Category                                                       

Total                                    

Yes                            

No                     

COR (95% C)                            

AOR(95% C)                             

Parents Religion

Orthodox

517

257

260

1

1

Muslim

41

34

7

44.914(1.139-11.28)*

3.57(0.403-9.083)

Protestant

18

8

10

.809(0.314-2.083)

0.395(0.128-1.213)

Catholic

6

1

5

.202(0.023-1.744)

0.091(0.008-1.041)

Illiterate

115

55

60

1

1

Educational status of father

Read &write

260

123

137

0.979(0.631-1.52)

0.798(0.435-1.464)

Elementary

88

42

46

0.996(0.571-1.736)

0.457(0.199-1.048)

Secondary

45

28

17

1.797(0.888-3.636)

0.737(0.261-2.077)

College& above

74

52

22

2.579(1.389-4.785)*

0.330(0.103-1.060)

Educational status of mother

Illiterate

222

98

124

1

1

Read & write

214

100

114

1.11(.761-1.618)

0.998(0.645-1.546)

Elementary

79

52

27

2.437(1.427-4.161)*

2.068(1.079-3.963)**

Secondary

35

26

9

3.655(1.638-8.159)*

3.446(1.298-9.154)**

College& above

32

24

8

3.796(1.634-8.818)*

1.800(0.622-5.215)

Parents’ occupation

Farmer

336

151

185

1

1

Merchant

77

42

35

1.47(0.894-2.418)

0.626(0.322-1.215)

Gov’tal worker

82

64

18

4.356(2.475-7.667)*

2.2(1.020-4.747)**

Private worker

50

24

26

1.131(0.624-2.05)

0.788(0.380-1.635)

Daily wages

37

19

18

1.293(0.655-2.552)

0.863(0.381-1.951)

Age

15-19

338

159

179

1

1

20-24

244

141

103

1.541(1.106-2.15)*

1.560(0.993-2.451)

Educational status of participant

Illiterate

9

6

3

1

1

Read & write

35

7

28

0.125(0.025-0.628.)

5.019(0.992-25.382)

Elementary

114

52

62

0.419(0.100-1.760)

0.197(0.069-0.564)

Secondary

208

109

99

0.551(0.134-2.260)

0.911(0.507-1.637)

College& above

216

126

90

0.700(0.171-2.873)

0.787(0.481-1.285)

Presence of Television at home

Yes

271

172

99

2.484(1.777-3.47)*

2.083(1.305-3.326)**

No

311

128

183

1

1

Using social media like, face book

Yes

196

129

67

2.421(1.694-3.46)*

1.277(0.804-2.030)

No

386

171

215

1

1

Current job of the respondents

Jobless

47

25

22

2.273(1.046-4.94)*

1.564(0.628-3.897)

Student

393

207

186

2.226(1.271-3.897)*

1.498(0.736-3.050)

Trading

37

22

25

2.933(1.267-6.79)*

1.703(0.630-4.603)

Hair dressing

21

9

12

1.500(0.546-4.121)

0.419(0.117-1.507)

Gov’tal worker

21

16

5

8.667(2.224-33.78)*

6.203(1.099-35.005)**

Daily wages

63

21

42

1

1

Taking education or training on gender issues.

Yes

352

226

126

3.781(2.659-5.377)*

3.887(2.591-5.832)**

No

230

74

156

1

1

Table 4 Factors associated with awareness of sexual trafficking, June 2017(N=582)

Discussion

 The study was aimed to assess awareness of sexual trafficking and associated factors among youth females. It was supposed that, this study provided important information and created overall image on Awareness of sex trafficking and associated factors among youth females in Debrebirhan town, North Shewa. In this study, 52 % of respondents had awareness of sexual trafficking which was lower than studies conducted in Nepal, Nigeria and Ethiopia (Bahir Dar) showed that 76%, 86.1% and 60% of the respondents had awareness of sexual trafficking, respectively.26–28 Similarly, a cross sectional study conducted in Nigeria showed that 97.4% of the women reported that they had heard of women being taken abroad for commercial sex work.29 This discrepancy may be due to the implementation of sexual trafficking prevention interventions, as well as cross-cultural variation. Regarding the source of information, the youth females stated television (56.6%), radio (56.0%) and friends (22.2%) as sources of information in this study whereas in the Bahir Dar study the youth females mentioned television (64%), friends (46%) and radio (37%) as sources of information.26 On the other hand, the study done in Nepal, 94.6%, 49.5%, 36%, 24.3%, and 15.3% of the respondents mentioned media (i.e., radio or television), friends, family/relatives, schools and NGOs/health professionals as sources of information respectively.27 The possible reason might be due to the presence of difference source of information among different area.

Brokers and friends were mentioned as mediators for sex trafficking by 85.5% and 30.5% of the study participants; individually whereas in a study done in Bahir Dar friends and brokers were mentioned by 87% and 74% of the respondents, respectively as mediators for sex trafficking.26 Similarly, the study carried out in Nepal, relatives (51.4%) and friends (34.2%) were mentioned as mediators for sexual trafficking.27 The above findings were inconsistent with the studies done in Nigeria and South Africa.28,30 This might be due to the Knowledge difference about the mediators and existence of different mediators in different areas. Concerning about the cause of sexual trafficking, 53.3%, 32.7% and 29.0% of the youth females mentioned poverty, unemployment and hoping for a better life elsewhere, respectively as reasons for being trafficked. Similarly, the study done in Bahir Dar city, 45%, 50% and 72% of the study participants mentioned poverty, unemployment and hoping for a better life elsewhere, one by one as reasons for sex trafficking.26 These findings were not in line with those reported in studies from Nigeria, South Asia, and South Africa.28,31,32 On the other hand, the study done in Nepal showed that 62.2%, 58.6%, 56.8%, and 25.2% of the respondents mentioned poverty, lack of awareness, interest on big money, and illiteracy correspondingly as reasons for being trafficked.27 The possible explanation might be due to having knowledge difference on the causes of sexual trafficking and might be the presence of different causes in different countries.

Regarding to the vulnerability age group, about 24.3% of the participants reported that youth female’s aged less than 25 years were vulnerable for sexual trafficking which was lower than the studies done in Nepal (48.6%), Bahir Dar (71.4%) and South Asia (72%).27,26,31 The difference might be due to gap of knowledge on vulnerable age group for sexual trafficking among youth females. In this study, about 24% of youth females had been approached by someone to assist them to go abroad which was lower than the studies done in Bahir Dar town in Ethiopia (25%) and Benin city in southern Nigeria (31.9%).26,29 This discrepancy may be due to the extent of the problem and sexual trafficking promotion activities. Based on this study, 352 (60.5%) of the participants took training on gender issues. The finding of this study was higher than the study done in Bahir Dar city in which about 29% of study participants had taken some training on gender issues.26 This might be due to the fact that the stake holders might be understands the issue of sexual trafficking and in turn, this might increase their intention to give training.

This study also revealed that youth females whose mothers’ education status was elementary and secondary were about 2.068(AOR=2.068, 95% CI: 1.079-3.963) and 3.446(AOR=3.446, 95% CI: 1.298-9.154) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking respectively compared to those youth females whose parents’ education status was illiterate. However, study done in Nepal showed that the educational status of mother was not associated with awareness of sexual trafficking. This might be due to the fact that educated mothers, simply due to their tied up life style, might not have intimate approach with their daughters which might in turn influence the awareness of their daughters’ regarding about sexual trafficking. Regarding the parents’ occupation, the study revealed that youth females whose parents’ occupation was Governmental employment were about 2.2(AOR=2.2, 95% CI: 1.02-4.747) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to those youth females whose parents’ occupation was farming. This finding was supported by the Nepal study (AOR=3.89,95% CI:1.58–9.58).27 The reason might be due to the fact that governmental workers might have high access of social media and mass media than farmer as source of information for sexual trafficking. The reason might be due to the Government workers might have different life status and awareness about sexual trafficking from country to the country.

In this study, youth females who had governmental worker at current situation were about 6.203(AOR=6.203, 95% CI: 1.099-35.005) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to those youth females who had doing daily wages. This finding was not supported by the findings of Bahir Dar town study and Nepal study.26,27 The reason might be due to the fact that governmental workers might have high access of social media and mass media than farmer as source of information for sexual trafficking. This might be due to the fact that youth females might have different work from place to place and this might affect the awareness of youth females about sexual trafficking. According to this study, youth females who had television at home were about 2.083(AOR=2.083, 95% CI: 1.305-3.326) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to their counterparts. In line with this study, the study done in Bahir Dar town revealed that youth girls who had television at home were about 2.19(AOR=2. 19, 95% CI: 1.31-3.67) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to their counterparts. This study finding was also supported by the study done in Nepal (AOR=6.67, 95% CI: 3.99–9.54).27 This might be due to the youth females were not watch television programs which relate to sexual trafficking. This might be due to using radio or television together as one variable rather than using separately for each radio and television in Nepal study.

Based on this study, youth females trained on gender issues were 3.887(AOR=3.887, 95% CI: 2.591-5.832) times more likely to be aware about sexual trafficking compared to those youth females who did not take the training. This finding was aligned with the study done in Bahir Dar town (AOR=3. 59, 95% CI: 2.11-6.10).26 This might be due to the fact that the stake holders might be understand the issue of sexual trafficking and in turn, this might increase their intention to give training.

Limitations

  1. The study design s cross-sectional. So, it has its drawback (this does not show which one is first effect or cause).
  2. Because of the self-administered questionnaire, social desirability bias may have occurred to some degree.
  3. There were shortages of literatures (studies) for discussion.

Conclusion

The awareness of youth females about sexual trafficking in this study was low (52%). According this study, having a television at home, parents’ education status, parents’ occupation, current jobs of participant, and have taking training on gender issues were significantly associated with awareness of sex trafficking. Therefore, providing education about sexual trafficking will help to increase sexual trafficking awareness among youth females.

Declarations

Ethics approval and consent to participant

Ethical clearance was obtained from Mekelle University College of health science, ethical review board and permission got from Debre Birhan town administrative office and administrative of selected kebeles. The research proposal evaluated and approved by the Research Ethics Review Committee [HRERC 0910/2017] of College of Health Sciences, Mekelle University and ethical clearance gained. Official cooperation and permission found from Debre Birhan town administrative office and selected Kebele administrative office. Moreover, prior to commencing the study, a written informed consent took from each respondent before data collection. Informed consent found from a respondent whose age is equal and greater than 18. Assent consent given by parents for ageless 18 youth young women. Confidentiality kept by omitting their name and personal identification of participant no compelled to the study.

Acknowledgements

None.

Conflicts of interest

The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime. Protocol to prevent, suppress and punish trafficking in persons, especially women and children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. 2000.
  2. Neha A Deshpande, Nour NM. Sex Trafficking of Women and Girls. Rev Obstet Gynecol.2013;6(1):e22–e27. 
  3. https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/human-trafficking/global-report-on-trafficking-in-persons.html.
  4. International Organization for Migration (IOM): Assessment of Trafficking in Women and Children in and from Ethiopia. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: IOM 2010.
  5. Konstantopoulos WM, Ahn R, Alpert EJ. An international comparative public health analysis of sex trafficking of women and girls in eight cities: achieving a more effective health sector response. J Urban Health. 2013;90(6):1194–1204.
  6. International Labour Organization (ILO): ILO Global Estimate of Forced Labour 2012: Results and Methodology. Geneva: International Labour Organization; 2012.
  7. United Nations Crime and Justice Information network (UNCIJIN), Annual Report on human trafficking crimes. 2010.
  8. UNICEF. Trafficking in human beings especially women and children in Africa. 2nd edn. Italy: UNICEF Innocent Research centre Florence; 2005.
  9. Tom Gardner. Ethiopian women face new threat of human trafficking as economic gains slow to trickle down. 2016.
  10. https://2009-2017.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/2013humanrightsreport/index.htm#wrapper
  11. nternational Labour Organization (ILO). Trafficking in persons overseas for labour purposes the case of Ethiopian domestic workers. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: ILO country office. 2011.
  12. United State Department of State, Trafficking in persons Report –Ethiopia: 2012.
  13. International Labour Organization(ILO). Trafficking in persons overseas for labour purposes:The case of Ethiopian domestic workers. ILO country office. Addis Ababa,Ethiopia:2013.
  14. Zimmerman C, Hossain M, Watts C. Human trafficking and health: a conceptual model to inform policy, intervention and research. Soc Sci Med. 2011;73(2):327–335.
  15. Hossain M, Zimmerman C, Abas M, et al. The relationship of trauma to mental disorders among trafficked and sexually exploited girls and women. Am J Public Health. 2010;100(12):2442–2449.
  16. Ostrovschi N, Prince MJ, Zimmerman C, et al. Women in post-trafficking services in Moldova: diagnostic interviews to assess common mental disorders over two time periods among returning women. BMC Public Health. 2011;11:232.
  17. Abas M, Ostrovschi NV, Prince M, et al. Risk factors for mental disorders in women survivors of human trafficking: a historical cohort study. BMC Psychiatry. 2013;13:204.
  18. Silverman JG, Decker MR, Gupta J, et al. Syphilis and hepatitis B Co-infection among HIV-infected, sex-trafficked women and girls. Nepal Emerg Infect Dis. 2008;14(6):932–934.
  19. Barrows Jeffrey, Finger Reginald. Human Trafficking and the Healthcare Professional. South Med J. 2008;101:521–524.
  20. https://www.ecoi.net/en/document/219987
  21. Beydoun, Khaled. The Trafficking of Ethiopian Domestic Workers into Lebanon: Navigating through a Novel Passage of the International Maid Trade. Berkeley Journal of International Law. 2006; 24(3):1009–1045.
  22. Mesfin D. The Challenges and prospects of female labour migration to the Arab Middle East: A Case study of women returnees in the town of Girana, North Wollo, Ethiopia. 2011.
  23. Asefach Haileselassie. An Investigation in to the experiences of Female victims of Trafficking in Ethiopia. University of South Africa: Cape Town, South Africa. 2012.
  24. Elias Ashine. Trafficking of Ethiopian women and girls to the Middle East. Hungary:Central European university. 2013.
  25. Azage M, Abeje G, Mekonnen A. Sex trafficking awareness and associated factors among youth females in Bahir Dar town, North-West Ethiopia: a community based study. BMC women's health. 2014;14:85.
  26. Shrestha R, Karki P, Suwal A, et al. Sex Trafficking Related Knowledge, Awareness, and Attitudes among Adolescent Female Students in Nepal: A Cross-Sectional Study. PLoS One. 2015;10(7): e0133508.
  27. Omorodion FI. Vulnerability of Nigerian secondary school to human sex trafficking in Nigeria. Afr J Reprod Health. 2009;13(2):33–48.
  28. Okonofua FE, Ogbomwan SM, Alutu AN, et al. Knowledge, attitudes and experiences of sex trafficking by young women in Benin City, South Nigeria. Soc Sci Med. 2004;59(6):1315–1327.
  29. Woolman S, Bishop M. State as pimp:sexual slavery in South Africa. Dev South Afr. 2006;23(3):385–400.
  30. Huda S. Sex trafficking in South Asia. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics. 2006;94: 374–381.
  31. Ghimire D. Editor Prevention, Care, Rehabilitation and Reintegration of Rescued Girls: ABC’s Experience. Technical Consultative Meeting on Anti-trafficking Programmes in South Asia. 2001.
  32. Utility Service Provision fromPlanning Perspective(The case of Debre BirhanTown, ANRS, Ethiopia: 2016.
Creative Commons Attribution License

©2019 Abebe, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.