Review Article Volume 1 Issue 2
YMCA University of Science & Technology, India
Correspondence: Ahmad S, YMCA University of Science & Technology, Faridabad, Haryana, India,
Received: April 30, 2017 | Published: May 31, 2017
Citation: Ahmad S. Band gap engineering of hybrid 2-D nanomaterials some recent developments. MOJ Poly Sci. 2017;1(2):62-67. DOI: 10.15406/mojps.2017.01.00010
Successful modifications of band gaps of bulk alloy semiconductors (i.e. in binary, ternary and quaternary compounds) for electronic and optoelectronic device applications encouraged the researchers to explore similar strategies in 2D-materials involving graphene and graphene like transition metal chalcogenides and other layered materials. Being atomically thin layers, there are numerous other possibilities to explore in these 2D-materials involving lateral, vertical heterostructure formations besides substitution, and doping of other atomic species to fix their band gaps somewhere between zero of the graphene and the wide band gap, for example, of h-BN (i.e. 6eV band gap) in hybrid type h-BNC lattice. The recent developments taking place in this important area of research in band gap engineering of 2D-hybrid materials is briefly discussed in this review.
Keywords: optical transition, stoichiometric, superlattices, molecular beam, nanoscience, graphene, degradation, heterostructures, biomolecular, quantum, targeted therapy
CCSM, crystalline condensed state material; EEBS, electron energy band structure; BGE, band-gap engineering; NPMs, nanoparticulate materials; NCs, nanocrystals; DES, discrete electron states; GBs, grain boundaries; SB, schottky barrier
Physico-chemical properties of a crystalline condensed state material (CCSM) are decided by its electron energy band structure (EEBS) generally computed theoretically and validated by optical transition studies. Modifying the EEBS of such a CCSM would certainly amount to engineering its properties. Consequently, a number of studies were carried out in the context of band-gap engineering (BGE) of a large number of semiconducting materials by either changing their stoichiometric compositions in thermodynamically stable alloys or constructing layered epitaxial thin films with alternating compositions with matching lattice constants at the interfaces involving appropriate elemental and compound semiconductors. BG controls could facilitate easy access to their modified electronic/optoelectronic properties usable in respective device applications. Material growth processes based on molecular beam, and atomic layer epitaxy have been exploited to a great extent in this context, in the past, to prepare superlattices for not only controlling the resultant energy gaps but also arrive at heterostructures supporting 2D-Electron/Hole Gas sheets resulting in very high carrier mobilities in the absence of impurity scattering as discussed already in detail in earlier publication.1
With subsequent introduction of nanoscience and technology, the concept of BGE became still better realizable by controlling the size and shape of the nanoparticulate materials (NPMs).2 Extension to the idea of preparing comprehensive hierarchical molecular complexes involving further combinations of strong and weak interactions due to conjugations provided better options for preparing nanomaterials possessing smart and intelligent features, which not only employed BGE of the materials species of not only inorganic, and organic (polymeric) origin but also of the biomolecular species to mimic some sort of intelligent behavior of living organisms as discussed in detail in numerous publications.3–6
With further advent of 2D layered materials like graphene and graphene like mono/multiple layers, numerous possibilities are foreseen to implement BGE strategy even without bothering for the previously mentioned restrictions of lattice matching (e.g. observed in the heterostructures of CCSM) at the interfaces of two different monolayers resulting in another new class of van der Waal’s epitaxial heterostructures in lateral and vertical configurations for improving their electronic/optoelectronic properties. Some of the recent developments discussed here in this review highlight the importance of this growing field of novel 2D-materials from BSE angle.7
Semiconducting nanocrystals (NCs) introduce tunable optical transition properties arising out of additional discrete electron states (DES) resulting from quantum confinement. Consequently they are applicable in solar photovoltaic energy conversion, optoelectronic devices, molecular and cellular imaging, and ultrasensitive detection. The light emissions from such NCs vary from UV to visible, to near-infrared, and mid-infrared spectral ranges. These NCs demonstrate additional properties like carrier multiplication, single-particle blinking, and spectral diffusion and hence used in developing complex superlattices and multimodal agents for molecular imaging and targeted therapy.8
The syntheses of these NCs offer numerous types of doped and strain-tuned QDs. Techniques based on single-particle fluorescence, extinction, and tunneling/ultrafast spectroscopies are helping in understanding their characteristic features. For instance, ZnO having wide band gap with immunity to oxidative degradation is a very useful shell material for NCs capping in core-shell type QDs. Similarly, IV-VI semiconductors having positive deformation potentials and mercury-based II-VI materials allowing for continuous tuning of their band gaps through spontaneous cation exchange reactions are known to play important roles in their future applications. For instance, in photovoltaic applications - the phenomenon like multi-exciton generation causing efficient charge carrier separation; and minimizing the steric hindrance in bio conjugated NCs in biomedical applications. Employing nonspecific protein adsorption for developing photo switchable NCs for multicolor optical microscopy in exploring the toxic properties these NCs are some typical examples already known and reported.9,10
A number of options were explored in the recent past after the discovery of graphene in developing engineered nanomaterials by design using 2-D-mono/few-layers of graphene and other materials. Instead of realizing purely uniform homogeneous phases, even patchy compositions of different constituents were formed at isolated locations as identified in structural analyses. The examples cited here show very clearly that once optimal route of synthesis is identified; the utility of the resultant band gap designed nanomaterials will start touching an altogether newer horizon of their applications in near future.11
Graphene, h-BN and h-BNC
Synthesizing large size mono/few layers of graphene, h-BN, and h-BNC in recent experiments have offered good examples cited in this context as described below before highlighting the challenges faced during their hybrid phase syntheses.
Monolayer of graphene is a planar sheet of sp2-bonded carbon atoms hexagonally arranged in a lattice possessing distinct features that are not there in 0D, 1D, or 3D forms of carbon. A variety of physical phenomena were observed including anomalous quantum Hall effect reflecting the presence of mass-less electrons, and possessing high electron mobility at room temperature made it known as a zero gap semiconductor with enhanced electronic properties. Unusual thermal and mechanical properties of graphene have been used in electromechanical resonators, stretchable and elastic matrices for flexible electronic circuitry, ultracapacitors, stable field emitters, and as fillers for electrically conducting flexible nanocomposites.12–18
Besides graphene, 2D atomically thin sheets of other materials involve nitrides, sulfides, selenides, tellurides, and oxides. Theoretical calculations predict exceptional properties possible in most of the 2D-materials by reducing them into a monolayer, such as in hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN). Out of several possible phases, h-BN is the only member possessing a layered structure, with the B and N atoms arranged in an sp2-honeycomb lattice, quite similar to that of C atoms in graphene. Structurally identical features of h-BN, graphene, and other 2D-monolayers make them appropriate for fabricating graphene-based electronics and optoelectronics devices. Out of various phases, graphene and h-BN attract much attention as they have demonstrated excellent hybrid phases by mixing them together. Electronically different phases when mixed offer interesting device applications. A controlled mixing of these two lattices in lateral and vertical stacking produces a series of superlattices. Theoretical studies of BNC nanostructures show them usable in nano-electronics, optical devices, field emission, catalysis, lubrication, and gas storage.11,12,19–22
The exploration of 2D-BNC atomic layers beyond graphene and h-BN still needs to address to many challenges including preparation of atomic layer phases with precisely controlled compositions, determining the locations of various atoms using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy (STM/STS), and correlating the measured electronic and magnetic properties to the structural and theoretical predictions.11
Other hybrid 2D-monolayers
Several methods have been attempted in preparing layered phases of BNC, BNC2, BC3 by involving synthesis of graphene and h-BN over metal substrates in CVD and other techniques besides co-doping of B and N into nano carbons. For example, instead of doping graphene with B and N, it is conversely possible C-doping in h-BN. However, during graphene or h-BN doping, it is essential to realize uniform distribution of the dopants to have the engineered phases. The unusual properties of graphene have triggered interest in doping the hexagonal lattice of graphene with boron (B) and nitrogen (N) to obtain layered BNC-structures. Individual atomic layers containing B, C, and N of various compositions conform to several stable phases in the three-component phase diagram of B-C-N. Additionally, stacking layers built from C and BN also allows for engineering the new van-der-Waals materials with novel properties.11
BGE strategy has been explored in 2D-materials to reduce the large band gap of h-BN monolayer (i.e. ~6eV) by topologically modifying its hexagonal lattice by creating grain boundaries (GBs) in its basal plane. These monolayers have 3-fold symmetry with alternative B and N atoms in the pristine form. The edges and GBs in such a lattice show characteristic optical/electronic properties. Lesser investigated GBs in h-BN compared to those in graphene and MoS2 are identified as an array of dislocations and non-hexagonal boron and nitrogen rings, which ultimately disturb the lattice symmetry causing reductions in the band gaps in some orientations. DFT calculations involving additional states created along the boundary estimate the BG reductions up to ~38%. In the alternative option, it was substituting C atoms to form hybrid lattice of h-BNC in place of h-BN. A general chemical method reported in this context to prepare different h-BN derivatives confirmed that the chemical structure could very well be modified with or without a graphene precursor to tune the BG up to ~2eV.23–25
Besides, the processes like atomic doping, alloying and hybridization were also attempted in past to alter electronic structures of h-BN monolayers by seamless inter-weaving of graphene and h-BN into one piece. Earlier studies have confirmed that B, C and N could be atomically mixed together to form various semiconducting 2D-monolayer structures with varying stoichiometry. The electronic and magnetic properties of BN monolayer are theoretically possible to modulate by adding small domains of graphene in h-BN, without disturbing its planarity. In recent experiments, co-deposition of graphene and h-BN was attempted to form hybridized h-BNC besides synthesizing atomic layers of h-BNC by substituting C atoms in graphene layer with B and N atoms. The significance of the chemical and electrical tunability achieved in these experimental methods motivated using PECVD to synthesize several other members of h-BN derivatives.23,26–29
For the introduction of h-BN domain in a pristine graphene monolayer, hydrogen is used to etch away C atoms generating vacancies that are filled by B and N atoms ultimately leading to the growth of h-BN domains. Continuing this process over a sufficiently longer duration, the graphene monolayer is completely converted into h-BN film. This kind of gradual change taking place in the graphene lattice has been confirmed, for instance, by starting with a pristine graphene film with no D peak (i.e. indicating absence of a detectable defect), the gradual conversion gives rise to the appearance of D-peak that increases in the early 40min and declines afterwards. These characteristics are in accordance with the increasing levels of defects or functionalities in graphene. It is quite likely that hybrid structure are constituted with alloys or mixed domains of h-BN, graphene and h-BNC. Especially, when the conversion exceeds 15min, the D peak of graphene starts to slowly blue shift from 1354cm−1 to the h-BN’s E2g peak at 1368 cm−1.23,26,30,31
BGE of bulk compound semiconductors (e.g. binary, ternary, quaternary and so on) using alloying of constituent crystalline compounds with matching lattice constants has already been explored in past facilitating their applications in numerous electronic/optoelectronic devices to a large extent.1 Drawing a parallel from there motivated to try similar attempts in atomically thin 2D semiconductor monolayers to grow materials with tunable band gaps for their applications in several functional devices.1,32–41
In this context, a number of monolayers (2D) with different energy gaps when alloyed were found to produce hybrid 2D materials possessing stoichiometry dependent BGs lying somewhere between the minimum and maximum limits of the band gaps of the constituent compounds used. Such hybrid materials are finding applications in nanoelectronics and nano photonics, where it is rather beneficial to have semiconducting nanostructures with continuously tunable band gaps. Recent advances in 0D and 1D ternary semiconductor structures have shown that their band gaps and light emissions could also be tuned gradually by changing their constituent stoichiometries, and based on these composition modulated nanostructures, multi-wavelength lasers, wavelength converters, optical diodes, and nano photodetectors have been realized experimentally.42–52 For their applications in integrated devices and systems, direct growth of these band gap engineered 2D monolayer materials are proving to be very useful as discussed in a recent review covering the recent progress on the BGE of atomically thin 2D semiconductor alloys. Some of the typical examples are included in the followings to highlight their future applications.32
Other hybrid 2D-materials
Thermodynamically stable alloys of sulphides, and selenides of Mo and W were, for instance, studied in great detail by varying their stoichiometries. For instance, MoS2(1-x) Se2x was studied for fixing its band gap between 1.557 and 1.856eV (i.e. corresponding to the direct band gap of MoSe2 and MoS2, respectively).53,54 Atomically thin nanosheets of 2D-MoS2(1-x) Se2x were also examined for lithium adsorption and diffusion in hexagonal monolayers for different values of x as: 0.00, 0.33, 0.50, 0.66, and 1.00. Band gap engineered nanosheets were successfully produced using precursors from mechanically exfoliated MoS2(1-x) Se2x bulk alloy showing triangular nanosheets (SEM) with the edge lengths of 30-80micron. Lateral composition-graded 2D-MoS2(1-x) Se2x nano layers were also synthesized employing a simple moving source thermal evaporation method of an improved CVD.55–68 Subsequently, 2D-WS2x Se2(1-x) alloys were prepared from WO3 (monoclinic crystal) to WS2 (1-x) Se2x (hexagonal crystal) through simultaneous sulfurization and selenization, in which, the chemical activity of S made it easy to tune the value of x by varying the weight of sulfur powder.69 The resulting alloy nanosheets were monolayers with a well-defined triangular shape, as identified by optical contrast and atomic force microscopy besides Raman spectroscopy.69
Some recent experimental studies conducted by various research groups are described here in brief to highlight the validations of theoretical computations regarding BGE aspects of 2D-monolayeres. Particularly, strain induced changes in material and device characteristics are very valuable informations regarding this aspect of material by design using 2D-mono/multiple layer materials in association with graphene.
Synthesis of monolayers containing hybridized bonds of elements B, N and C are expected to offer new material properties as discussed earlier. Synthesis and characterization of large-area atomic layers of h-BNC material was reported in case of hybridized, randomly distributed domains of h-BN and C phases with compositions ranging from pure BN to pure graphene indicating their distinct structural features and band gap from those of undoped/doped graphene, and h-BN, which is found useful for developing band gap-engineered device applications.27
In a recent study of 2-D Bx/2Nx/2C1−x (0< x <1) compounds with four stoichiometric compositions namely: Bx/2Nx/2C1−x(x =2/3, 1/2, 2/5 and 1/3) was reported using a global optimization method (CALYPSO) and DFT revealing that all monolayer Bx/2Nx/2C1−x stoichiometries adopt a planar honeycomb character and are dynamically stable. These calculations show that most of the Bx/2Nx/2C1−x phases possess direct band gaps within the optical range; thereby they can potentially be used in high-efficiency conversion of solar energy in photovoltaic modules. The band gaps of Bx/2Nx/2C1−x can be widely tuned within the optical range by changing the concentration of carbon, thus allowing the fast development of BGE in optoelectronics.70
In one method of BG-tuning of monolayer h-BN (~6eV) involves topologically reforming the hexagonal structure incorporating grain boundaries (GBs) in the basal plane. Alternately, introducing foreign atoms like C forges hybrid structures like hetero-junctions or semiconducting h-BNC materials. A general chemical method of synthesizing these different versions of h-BN derivatives was showcased for manipulating the chemical structure either with or without a graphene precursor, resulting in BG down to ~2 eV.71
The key to have exotic features from van der Waals 2D-semiconductors for device applications lies in precisely modifying their BGs. The strategy of universally tuning the band gap in the family of bulk 2H transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) was reported recently by in-situ surface doping of Rb atoms. Experimental observations confirmed a variation in band gap in the range of 0.8-2.0eV, which covers a wide spectral range from visible to near infrared, with a tendency from indirect to direct BGs. These results confirmed surface Stark effect as a universal mechanism of band-gap engineering on the basis of the strong 2D nature of van der Waals semiconductors.72
MoTe2 is an exfoliable TMD crystallizing in three symmetries: semiconducting trigonal-prismatic 2H- or α-phase; semi metallic and monoclinic 1T’- or β-phase; and semi metallic orthorhombic γ-structure. Out of these the 2H-phase has a band gap of ∼1eV making ideal for flexible and transparent optoelectronic applications. The γ-phase possesses a topologically protected non-dissipative transport channels along with possibility of locally inducing phase-transformations in TMDs, through chemical doping, local heating, or electric field to achieve ohmic contacts. It is also feasible to induce functionalities like electronic phase-change memory elements. Combining these features, it is possible to use this material for producing high performance, low dissipation optoelectronic devices in near future. Phase engineering of MoTe2 by W-substitution was revealed in the phase-diagram of the Mo1-xWxTe2 solid solution, which displays a semiconducting to semi metallic transition as a function of x. A small critical W concentration xc∼8% was observed to stabilize the γ-phase at room temperature suggesting that crystals with x close to xc might be particularly susceptible to phase transformations induced by an externally applied electric field.73
While examining 2d-monolayers, tailoring graphene/boron nitride heterostructures, which can theoretically retain the character of a single-atom thick sheet, withstand large physical strains, are easily functionalized, and have entirely different optical and mechanical properties compared to graphene providing the foundation for entirely new research fields. Knowing from theoretical predictions that carbon, boron, and nitrogen could co-exist as atomic sheets in a layered structure, a facile method of integrating boron nitride (hBN) and graphene oxide (GO) via chemical exfoliation was reported in form of BCON after examining its stability at different pH conditions indicating that a stable and a uniform solution is achievable at pH in the range of 4 to 8. An in-situ XPS was employed in detecting chemical changes while exposing it to ionization radiation specially focusing on the C/O ratio. It was observed that even with a very low energy source, this material is highly sensitive to ionizing radiation, such as neutron, alpha and beta particles.74
A continuous and reversible tuning of the optical band gap of suspended MoS2 monolayer was reported by as much as 500meV by applying very large biaxial strains. Impermeability to gas of CVD grown crystals was used to apply a pressure difference across suspended membranes to induce biaxial strains for determining the effect of strain on the energy and intensity of the peaks in the photoluminescence (PL) spectrum and find a linear tuning rate of the optical band gap of 99meV/%. These results show that as large as 5.6% strain could be applied across micron-sized areas showing strain tuning of higher-level optical transitions.75
Continuous tuning of the electronic structure of atomically thin MoS2 on flexible substrates was reported by applying a uniaxial tensile strain with a redshift @ ∼70meV/% applied strain for direct gap transitions, and @ 1.6 times larger for indirect gap transitions, as determined by absorption and photoluminescence spectroscopy. These results agree with first principles calculations demonstrating the utility of 2D- monolayers in flexible and optoelectronics.76
Substantial strain induced band gap tunability was demonstrated in TMDs based FETs as per theoretical calculations and optical experiments. Devices fabricated on flexible substrates held on cantilever type sample holder were used to apply uniaxial tensile strain. The analysis of FET’s transfer characteristics clearly proved a band gap reduction of 100meV in WSe2 under 1.35% uniaxial tensile strain at room temperature in which the band gap change is only related to a change of the conduction band edge of WSe2, resulting in a decrease in the Schottky barrier (SB) for electrons without any change for hole injection into the valence band. These experimental results, when compared with DFT calculations under strain, showed excellent agreement between theoretical predictions and the experimental data presented here.77
Developing appropriate synthesis techniques with precise control of monolayers of 2-D layered materials by combining binary and ternary phases of C, B, and N in hybrid form is theoretically predicted to tune the BGs and hence their electronic, optoelectronic and other structural properties as highlighted in this work. This could possibly be better explored than tuning the BGs using nanoparticulate materials building blocks alone as discussed in earlier publications. A combination of nanoparticulate materials and band gap engineered 2D-monolayers forming hierarchical molecular complexes would be a better option as it appears from the observations made so far.
None.
The author declares no conflict of interest.
©2017 Ahmad. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.