Journal of
eISSN: 2373-6445
Submit manuscript...
Review Article Volume 17 Issue 4
The lexicon of restraint: ethnic bias, institutional coercion, and structural harm in the Italian mental health system — the preventable death of Abderrahim Fakir
Marcello Maviglia
Received: July 28, 2026 | Published: August 17, 2026
Citation: Maviglia M. The lexicon of restraint: ethnic bias, institutional coercion, and structural harm in the Italian mental health system — the preventable death of Abderrahim Fakir. J Psychol Clin Psychiatry. 2026;17(4):152-157. DOI: 10.15406/jpcpy.2026.17.00870
Abstract
This article reconstructs, through a multidisciplinary analytic approach, the events leading to the recent death of Abderrahim Fakir, a 43-year-old Moroccan man living in Italy, which demonstrates how a profoundly mishandled psychiatric crisis resulted in a preventable fatality. Fakir was a husband and father in precarious social and economic conditions with documented medical vulnerabilities, including episodes of psychological distress with no consistent follow-up. His crisis unfolded within a context marked by isolation, limited access to care, and the structural difficulties experienced by many minority groups and immigrants. The reconstruction draws on forensic findings, verified video documentation, eyewitness accounts, and contemporary psychiatric and human-rights literature. Fakir’s death needs to be contextualized within a broader landscape of systemic incoherence: a mental-health system weakened by chronic underfunding, decades of health -care cuts, and the erosion of social determinants of health, a crisis-response apparatus overly reliant on police intervention, and custodial institutions where pharmacological and physical restraint have come to replace relational care, capable of interpreting distress as a result of precarious psychosocial conditions and not as a threat. The article introduces the concept of custodial biopolitics to describe the medicalization of control in prisons, migrant detention centers, and psychiatric wards, where sedation and containment are used to compensate for structural deficits rather than to address human suffering. It examines how structural violence, ethnic bias, ethical failures, and the erosion of relational, trauma-informed, and culturally competent practice converge to produce coercive responses and misinterpretations of distress. Drawing on international crisis-response models, the analysis highlights Italy’s critical absence of peer -support specialists and relational infrastructures capable of de-escalating crises before they become fatal. The analysis also aligns with ongoing civil society efforts—such as those advanced by Diritti alla Follia (“Rights to Madness”), a grassroots organization that documents coercive psychiatric practices and advocates for rights based, culturally competent crisis response reforms. Their work illustrates how community driven advocacy can complement structural change, including proposals for safer psychotropic tapering, improved crisis interpretation, and reform of involuntary treatment procedures. Fakir’s death reflects a deeper ethical drift. The article concludes with structural recommendations to rebuild crisis response around dignity, relationality, cultural competence, peer-support infrastructures, outlining a pathway toward a system capable of understanding distress rather than reproducing harm.
Keywords: custodial biopolitics, coercive psychiatry, ethnic bias
©2026 Maviglia. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.