Review Article Volume 15 Issue 5
1Mental Health Research Group (MHeRG), Faculty of Medicine, Alfonso X el Sabio University, Spain
2Department of Psychology, Faculty of Biomedical and Health Sciences, Universidad Europea de Madrid, Spain
3Department of Medicine, Faculty of Biomedical and Health Sciences, Universidad Europea de Madrid, Spain
4Department of Personality, Assessment and Clinical Psychology. Faculty of Psychology, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Spain
Correspondence: Pedro V. Mateo-Fernández, PhDC, Department of Psychology, Faculty of Biomedical and Health Sciences, Universidad Europea de Madrid, Mental Health Research Group (MHeRG), Faculty of Medicine, Alfonso X el Sabio University, Department of Personality, Assessment and Clinical Psychology. Faculty of Psychology, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid, Spain
Received: August 23, 2024 | Published: September 17, 2024
Citation: Mateo-Fernández PV, Osa-Subtil IL. Parental interference in custody variation proceedings: a forensic psychology perspective. J Psychol Clin Psychiatry. 2024;15(5):251-257. DOI: 10.15406/jpcpy.2024.15.00789
Parental interference in judicial proceedings for variation of custody arrangements is a phenomenon that profoundly impacts family dynamics and the well-being of children. This article addresses this issue from the perspective of forensic psychological assessment, highlighting the critical importance of a thorough and rigorous analysis in these contexts. Custody variation, whether physical or legal, often generates tension and conflict between parents, which can lead to parental interference behaviors. These interferences can manifest themselves in a variety of ways, including emotional manipulation of children, denigration of the other parent, and obstruction of parenting time.
The relevance of this article lies in the need to understand how these interferences affect both the children and the adults involved, and the importance of having accurate and objective psychological assessments to inform court decision-making. The work of the forensic psychologist is essential in these processes, providing an unbiased assessment based on standardized techniques and tools to identify harmful family dynamics and their impact on the psychological well-being of children.
Throughout this article, the importance of early intervention and the implementation of effective strategies to mitigate parental interference is highlighted. In addition, recommendations for courts and other legal professionals on how to appropriately integrate findings from psychological evaluations into judicial decision making are highlighted. Ultimately, this approach seeks to promote the well-being of children and ensure that custody decisions are based on the best interests of the child, informed by rigorous and detailed forensic psychological evaluations.
Keywords: forensic psychologist, parental interference, custody modality, court proceedings, psychological assessment and intervention
Parental interference in judicial proceedings of variation of custody modality is a complex and worrisome phenomenon that significantly affects the welfare of children and judicial decisions in family courts.1,2 This problematic refers to the actions of one or both parents that seek to negatively influence the child's relationship with the other parent, through tactics such as emotional manipulation, misinformation, parental alienation and obstruction of contact. In many cases, these behaviors are intended to harm the other parent, which can exacerbate family conflicts and make it difficult to peacefully resolve custody disagreements.
The relevance of the issue is highlighted by its direct impact on the emotional and psychological stability of children. Studies and clinical reviews3,4 have shown that parental interference can lead to confusion, stress, anxiety and decreased self-esteem in children, affecting their emotional and social development. In addition, these behaviors can perpetuate cycles of conflict and violence, negatively affecting long-term family relationships.
From a judicial perspective, the assessment of these dynamics becomes crucial. Courts rely on forensic psychological reports to make informed decisions that prioritize the welfare of the child. However, the detection of parental interference requires a specialized approach that includes interviews, observations, and the use of standardized instruments to identify patterns of behavior and assess the impact of these behaviors on children.5,6
Therefore, understanding and properly managing parental interference in custody proceedings is not only a matter of justice, but also of protecting and promoting child welfare. Early intervention and training of professionals in the identification and management of these behaviors are essential to mitigate their adverse effects and ensure that judicial decisions are made in the best interests of the child.7
The main objective of this article is to present a detailed forensic psychologist's perspective on parental interference and its impact on judicial custody variation proceedings. Through this approach, it is intended to underscore the critical importance of forensic psychological assessment in these proceedings, highlighting how parental interference dynamics can influence judicial decisions and, ultimately, the well-being of the children involved.
First, the definition and characteristics of parental interference will be addressed, including behaviors such as emotional manipulation of children, delegitimizing the other parent and fostering negative attitudes towards the other parent. These behaviors not only complicate custody proceedings, but can also have long-term consequences on the mental and emotional health of children.
Next, the role of the forensic psychologist in the identification and assessment of these interferences will be discussed. The methodologies and tools used in the assessment, such as clinical interviews, direct observations, and the use of standardized questionnaires, will be explored. In addition, it will discuss how these assessments inform the courts, helping them to make fairer decisions focused on the best interests of the child.
The article also aims to highlight the challenges and limitations faced by forensic psychologists in these contexts, including parental resistance to cooperate and the complexity of differentiating between normal parental conflicts and pathologically interfering behaviors.
Finally, practical recommendations will be offered to improve intervention and decision making in cases of parental interference, emphasizing the need for ongoing training for the professionals involved and the implementation of early intervention strategies to mitigate the negative impact of these behaviors on children and families.
Ultimately, this article seeks to provide an in-depth and practical understanding of parental interference from the perspective of the forensic psychologist, highlighting the relevance of his or her role in judicial custody proceedings and the importance of protecting the welfare of affected children.
Parental interference: definition and impact on custody
Definition of parental interference
Parental interference refers to a range of behaviors and strategies used by one parent with the goal of manipulating or negatively influencing the child's relationship with the other parent. These behaviors can be subtle or overt, and their impact can range from creating temporary tensions to causing significant long-term emotional and psychological harm.8,9
In the custodial context, parental interference often manifests itself in the following ways:
Not with standing the above, it is crucial to distinguish between parental interference and other types of family conflict, since not all disagreements or tensions between parents qualify as interference as they would:
Thus, while conflicts and disagreements are a natural part of family dynamics, parental interference represents a pattern of harmful behaviors intended to damage the child's relationship with the other parent. This distinction is vital for forensic psychology professionals and the judicial system to properly identify and address these interferences, thereby protecting the child's well-being and fairness in custody proceedings.
Impact of parental interference on custodial care
Parental interference can have a significant and detrimental impact on custody proceedings. These interferences, which may include behaviors such as emotional manipulation, denigration of the other parent, and impediment of communication and contact, seek to destabilize the relationship between the child and the targeted parent.11,15 This type of behavior not only harms the affected parent but also causes considerable psychological harm to the children involved.
From the forensic psychologist's point of view, it is critical to assess how these parental interferences influence family dynamics and judicial decision making. Interferences can generate feelings of divided loyalty in children, which can lead to parental alienation, where the child unjustifiably rejects one parent.14 This phenomenon can significantly complicate court proceedings, as the judge must determine the best interests of the child in a context of exacerbated parental conflict.
The impact of parental interference in custody is also reflected in the mental and emotional health of children. Studies have shown that children exposed to these dynamics may experience anxiety, depression, and behavioral problems.17 In addition, the stress associated with custody disputes can lead to less stable court decisions and more long-term litigation.18
The forensic evaluation should include a thorough review of parental behaviors and their impact on the child. Techniques such as clinical interviews, direct observations, and review of court documentation are essential for a thorough assessment.20 Early and appropriate intervention can help mitigate the negative effects of parental interference, promoting a healthier environment for the child and facilitating a more fair and equitable resolution of the custody conflict.16
Legal and psychological context
Laws and regulations related to the custody of minors
In the legal area, child custody is governed by laws and regulations designed to protect the welfare of children. These laws vary from country to country, but generally share fundamental principles that seek to ensure that custody decisions are based on the best interests of the child. In many countries, the regulations state that courts must consider a variety of factors when determining custody, including the emotional and economic stability of the parents, the ability of each parent to provide a safe and loving environment, and the existing relationship between the child and each parent.
In Spain, Law 15/2005, which reforms the Civil Code and the Civil Procedure Law on separation and divorce, introduced shared custody as a viable, although not necessarily the preferred, option in cases of separation and divorce.21 This law emphasizes that “the best interests of the minor must be the primary consideration”.22 Likewise, the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child states that in all decisions concerning children, “the best interests of the child shall be a primary consideration” (Article 3).
In the United States, custody laws vary by state, but many have adopted the “best interests of the child” standard as the primary criterion. In addition, some states have implemented laws that promote shared custody as a default option unless it is shown that such an arrangement would not be beneficial to the child.23
Review of previous studies on parental interference in judicial proceedings for variation of the custody modality
Parental interferences in judicial proceedings for variation of custody arrangements, as we have already mentioned, are a phenomenon widely studied in the psychological and legal literature. These interferences, which may include behaviors such as emotional manipulation of the children or sabotage of the child's relationship with the other parent, can have significant consequences for both the children and the parents involved.
Numerous studies have documented the negative effects that parental interference can have on children. Johnston and Roseby24 note that children exposed to interparental conflict and parental alienation behaviors may experience high levels of stress, anxiety, and depression. In addition, these children may develop behavioral problems and difficulties in forming healthy relationships later in life.14 In a longitudinal study, Baker and Darnall25 found that children subjected to parental interference may suffer deterioration in their academic performance and present self-esteem problems. These effects are more pronounced in cases where interparental conflict is intense and prolonged.
Similarly, for parents, parental interference can intensify emotional stress and aggravate conflicts during custody court proceedings.26 Research by Baker15 and Ellis and Boyan27 suggests that parents who are victims of parental interference may feel powerlessness and frustration, which can negatively affect their ability to participate effectively in court proceedings. In addition, this stress can lead to mental health impairments, such as depression and anxiety.15 Likewise, Fidler and Bala17 note that parents affected by parental interference often experience feelings of alienation and hopelessness, which can hinder their ability to maintain a positive relationship with their children. These parents may also face additional legal challenges, as allegations of parental alienation can complicate custody proceedings.
In addition to the more than proven impact on both children and their parents, in the context of legal proceedings, parental interference can complicate decision-making and prolong litigation. Studies such as Fidler and Bala17 highlighted that high-conflict cases, where parental interference is present, often require more extensive and detailed evaluations by mental health and legal professionals. In addition, the lack of a unified approach in the treatment of parental alienation cases can lead to inconsistent judicial decisions.28 Thus, it is posited to us that the variability in how courts address these situations reflects the need to develop clear, evidence-based guidelines for managing parental interference.
The role of the forensic psychologist in evaluation
It is common knowledge that the most important aspects of any assessment are the tools and methods used by forensic psychologists which, in our case, are essential for assessing the essential elements in judicial custody proceedings. These evaluations provide an objective and detailed basis for judicial decision-making, ensuring that decisions focus on the well-being of the children and the reduction of parental conflict.29
Description of the tools and methods used by forensic psychologists to assess the emotional distress of parents
In the field of parental interference assessment in custody proceedings, forensic psychologists employ a variety of specialized techniques and tools. These methodologies allow for a comprehensive and objective assessment of family dynamics and the impact of parental interference on the child and parents. The main techniques and tools used are detailed below:
Clinical interviews: Clinical interviews are central to forensic assessment. These interviews, which may be structured, semi-structured, or unstructured, allow the psychologist to obtain detailed information about family members' experiences, perceptions, and behaviors.10 Interviews with parents and children are designed to identify patterns of behavior, possible signs of parental alienation, and other factors relevant to the case. It is crucial that these interviews are conducted with sensitivity and professionalism to minimize the emotional impact on participants and to obtain valid and reliable data.30
According to Ackerman and Ackerman,31 “clinical interviews provide a rich and detailed context for understanding the underlying factors that contribute to the emotional distress of parents in custody proceedings.”
Psychological tests and questionnaires: Forensic psychologists also use a variety of standardized questionnaires and scales to assess specific aspects of parent and child psychology. These tools include:
Direct observations: Direct observations of interactions between parents and their children are also an essential tool in psychological assessment. These observations, such as supervised visits and family interviews, are essential in assessing the interaction between parents and children. These observations allow the psychologist to observe behaviors in real time, identify communication patterns, attitudes and family dynamics.37 Observations can be conducted in natural settings, such as the child's home, or in controlled settings, such as forensic assessment centers. According to Johnston et al.,38 direct observations are also important in this type of procedure as they provide a fairly complete picture of family dynamics that cannot be captured through questionnaires or interviews.
Documentation and records review: Document and record review is an integral part of the forensic evaluation. This includes review of medical, school, psychological, and legal reports, as well as correspondence and other relevant documents that may provide additional context and evidence about the case.10 Documentation may reveal historical patterns of behavior, mental health issues, abuse or neglect, and any previous interventions performed.
Witness interviews and expert testimonials: In some cases, it is relevant to interview key witnesses and obtain testimonials from other professionals, such as teachers, therapists, and social workers. These testimonies can provide additional information about family behavior and relationships.39 Forensic psychologists can also collaborate with other professionals, such as psychiatrists and pediatricians, to obtain a more comprehensive and multidisciplinary assessment.
Use of technology and recordings: Finally, in modern assessment, the use of technology, such as video recordings of visits and therapy sessions, has become increasingly common. These recordings allow for an objective review of parent and child interactions and behaviors, facilitating the identification of patterns of behavior and assessment of the veracity of the claims of those involved.16
Importance of psychological assessment in judicial decision making
Psychological evaluation in judicial custody proceedings plays a crucial role in making informed and fair decisions. Psychological reports provide the judge and attorneys with a detailed understanding of the emotional and psychological state of the parents, which is essential in determining the best interests of the child.7 Therefore, we must conduct a:
Ethical challenges and considerations
The assessment of parental interference in judicial custody variation proceedings poses a number of significant ethical and methodological challenges. These challenges require careful thought to ensure that assessments are fair, accurate, and respectful of the rights and welfare of all parties involved. Practitioners must be aware of the presence of conflicts of interest and maintain a neutral stance to safeguard the integrity of the evaluative process.42 These ethical and methodological considerations are essential to protect the rights of children and parents in a highly conflictual context. Some of these challenges and key ethical considerations are explored below:
Interventions and recommendations
Recommended intervention approaches to mitigate parental interference and promote child well-being
The literature suggests various strategies for managing parental interference during custody proceedings. Family therapy and mediation are two common approaches used to reduce interparental conflict and improve communication between parents.52 According to a study by Deutsch,53 early intervention and the use of parenting education programs can be effective in reducing parental alienation behaviors and promoting a more collaborative environment.
The implementation of structured parenting plans and visitation supervision have also been identified as useful measures to mitigate parental interference.54 These approaches not only seek to protect the child's well-being, but also to foster cooperation between parents. Within the targeted intervention strategies recommended by the scientific literature for this purpose we can find:
Suggestions for judges and attorneys on how to integrate forensic psychological evaluation into judicial decision making
The integration of forensic psychological evaluation into judicial custody proceedings is crucial to ensure informed decisions in the best interests of the child. Judges and attorneys must understand the importance of these evaluations, which provide a comprehensive view of the emotional and psychological well-being of the child and parents. Studies have shown that judicial decisions supported by forensic evaluations tend to be more balanced and fair.63,64 By considering the recommendations of forensic psychologists, courts can better address the complexities of custody disputes65,66 and favor in court proceedings:
This article explored the complexity of parental interference in judicial custody variation proceedings, highlighting the relevance of forensic psychological assessment in these contexts. Parental interference was defined, its impact on family dynamics and the mental health of minors was discussed, and the assessment tools and methods used by forensic psychologists were described. In addition, the challenges and ethical considerations inherent in these assessments were addressed and intervention strategies and recommendations for the courts were proposed.
A rigorous forensic psychological evaluation is critical to ensure that judicial decisions in custody cases are based on a thorough understanding of the family situation and the emotional and psychological needs of the children involved. Ackerman and Pritzl65 emphasize that careful assessment can prevent harmful decisions and facilitate a healthier environment for children. In addition, the implementation of effective intervention strategies can help reduce family conflict and foster a healthier environment for children.
It is essential that courts effectively integrate forensic psychological evaluations into their decision-making processes. Judges and attorneys should be informed about the benefits of these evaluations and work collaboratively with forensic psychologists to ensure that decisions are made in the best interests of the child. Bow et al.64 emphasize the importance of using evidence-based assessment principles and maintaining ongoing training in best practices to ensure the validity and reliability of results in custody evaluations. Several studies stress the importance of applying sound principles in custody evaluations,73–75 while others advocate for ongoing training of legal professionals in forensic psychology.76,77
Finally, it is important that future research delve deeper into the study of parental interference and its impact on custody proceedings. It is also suggested that judicial practices be improved through ongoing training of judges and attorneys in forensic psychology and the development of standardized protocols for the evaluation of family dynamics in custody cases. Only through a collaborative and evidence-based approach can the welfare of children in custody proceedings be ensured.78,79
None.
None.
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
©2024 Mateo-Fernández, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.