Forum Article Volume 9 Issue 4
1ENT Specialist Laser Specialist in Otolaryngology, Iraq
2ENT Specialist Head of ENT Department in Al Yarmouk teaching hospital MOH, Iraq
3ENT Specialist, Iraq
Correspondence: Adnan Qahtan Khalaf ENT Specialist Laser Specialist in Otolaryngology Al Yarmouk teaching hospital MOH, Iraq, Tel +964 770 084 3208
Received: November 26, 2017 | Published: December 13, 2017
Citation: Khalaf AQ, Abdullah AH, Taher FS, Abdalrida EM (2017) Intra-Capsular Tonsillotomy by Ultrasonic Method. J Otolaryngol ENT Res 9(4): 00296. DOI: 10.15406/joentr.2017.09.00296
This descriptive prospective study, (non - controlled clinical trial) was conducted during period of February 2016 to February 2017 in AL-Jadryia private hospital total of 80 patients age range (8-64years old) Gender distribution was 55% male, 45 % female. The patients where compelling from Tonsil hyperplasia, Chronic tonsillitis, Recurrent acute tonsillitis not responding to medical treatment. Surgical Ultrasound (Intra-capsular tonsillotomy) technique was done to them under L.A
Aim of study:
Patient and methods: The patients where compelling from Tonsil hyperplasia, Chronic tonsillitis, Recurrent acute tonsillitis not responding to medical treatment. Surgical Ultrasound tonsilletomy technique was done to them under L.A; the patient was placed in semi sitting position.
Use of 10% xylocaine spray as regional anesthesia for 7minute. Ultrasound generator until adjusted 44 - 55 intensity. The probe was introduced through tonsillar crypt while the a devise is activated, probe introduce for few second until the shrinkage has been occurred before leaving out probe, circular movement on entry point to ensure good hemostasis for few second (5-10sec.) 4-6 entrance in different site of tonsil may applied according to the size and the shrinkage that had been occurred (A phenomenon known as cavitations).
Results: There is minimal to no bleeding and pain , Slough can be seen in the first week after that disappear ,slight shrinkage in the size immediate (intra-operation) but can be seen obvious after 6weeks, there is subjective improvement in the snoring as per patient partners.
Conclusion: The results suggest that surgical Ultrasound tonsillectomy technique is an efficient & well tolerated procedure for the management of chronic tonsillitis and tonsillar hyperplasia.
Today's physicians are paying more attention to enlarged tonsils, realizing that this upper airway obstruction leads to obstructive sleep disordered breathing in children, the cause of a myriad of behavioral and health problems. The conventional treatment for this medical condition is complete removal of the tonsils (total tonsillectomy) by a variety of surgical procedures (cold dissection, electrocautery, microbipolar, and harmonic scalpel). In their search for a less invasive, but equally effective technique, a team of ear, nose, and throat specialists revisited an old procedure, tonsillotomy, or partial tonsillectomy, but in this case, performed with contemporary technology. The procedure involves a reduction in the tonsil size, partially shaving them away using an endoscopic microdebrider, a very small, high-speed device that shaves soft tissue. The partial tonsillectomy eliminates the obstructive portion of the tonsil while preserving the tonsillar capsule. The capsule integrity is maintained, and a natural biologic dressing is left in place over the pharyngeal muscles, preventing them from injury, inflammation, and infection. The procedure results in less post-operative pain, a more rapid recovery, and perhaps fewer delayed complications.1
Tonsillotomy is partial Tonsillectomy where eliminate the obstructive portion of Tonsil, while preserving the Tonsillar capsule. The capsule integrity is maintained and natural biologic dressing is left in place over the pharyngeal muscles, preventing them from injury, inflammation and Infection.
Only the medial part of the tonsil is re-moved. It requires that the (well-perfused) lymphatic tissue is resected, and that the remaining crypts remain open to the oropharynx.2,3 Active lymphatic tissue, with secondary follicles and crypts, is left in the tonsil fossae.4 Tonsillotomy can be done with most dissecting and coagulating methods. The most common method is laser tonsillotomy and radiofrequency tonsillotomy.
Tonsil hyperplasia
Tonsil hyperplasia, also known as (idiopathic) tonsillar hypertrophy, refers to abnormal enlargement of the palatine tonsil.5,6 It has to be distinguished from physiological pediatric palatine tonsil hyperplasia7,8 which is not a sign or consequence of recurrent inflammation.9,10 Also, children with tonsil hyperplasia do not suffer from acute tonsillitis11,12 or middle ear infections.13 A pediatric tonsil is only "pathologically" hyperplastic if snoring (with or with-out obstructive sleep apnea) or rarely dysphagia14 or even more rarely dysphonia occur.15
Grade of tonsillar hyperplasia:
Grade 1: Tonsils hidden within tonsillar pillars.
Grade II: Tonsils, extend the pillars.
Grade III: Tonsils, are beyond the pillars.
Grade IV: Tonsils, extend to midline (Figure 1).
Chronic tonsillitis
Also called “chronic (hyperplastic) tonsillitis”, it is not well-defined and thus should not be used.16 It is better to speak of (chronic) recurrent tonsillitis,17,18 because true chronic tonsillitis with persistent symptoms lasting >4 weeks with adequate treatment and recovery of the mucosa (as in rhinosinusitis) does not exist.
Recurrent acute tonsillitis
Also called “recurrent tonsillitis” or “recur-rent throat infections”,19 this refers to recur-rent bouts of acute tonsillitis. In contrast to a single attack of acute tonsillitis, it is usually caused by many different bacterial pathogens20,21 and flare up again a few weeks after cessation of antibiotic therapy.22 Depending on the frequency and severity of such episodes.
Indications for tonsil surgery
Surgery is done for infections, to relieve air-way obstruction, for halitosis and for diagnosis when a tumor is suspected. Surgery for recurrent tonsillitis depends on its frequency and severity, and the presence of additional diseases (antibiotic allergies, immunosuppression and PFAPA syndrome).
Paradise criteria for tonsillectomy
Paradise (1984) reported that tonsillectomy significantly lowers the frequency of severe recurrent sore throats in children aged 3-15yrs. Most published guidelines incorporate the so-called Paradise criteria for tonsillectomy:
Intracapsular techniques may use the microdebrider, bipolar, radiofrequency ablation (which can also be used to remove the entire tonsil), and carbon dioxide laser. Either extracapsular or intracapsular tonsillectomy can be performed for thepediatric patient with obstructive sleep apnea, but only extracapsular techniques should be used for patients undergoing tonsillectomy as a result of tonsillitis or peritonsillar abscess.
In addition, tonsils can be ablated using a laser or monopolar radiofrequency (somnoplasty). In a cooperative adult in a clinic setting. Harmonic scalpel, Bipolar radiofrequency ablation.
The harmonic scalpel Figure 2 can be used to perform an extracapsular tonsillectomy (Ethicon Endo-Surgery Inc. Cincinnati, OH). It uses ultrasonic energy to vibrate its blade at 55,000 cycles per second. The vibration transfers energy to the tissue, providingSimultaneous cutting and coagulation, so, typically, no additional instrument is needed for hemostasis. The components of the device include a generator, a hand piece, and a disposable blade. A high-frequency power supply provides energy to the hand piece. The blade oscillations dissect tissues by creating intra-cellular cavities as pressure waves are conducted through the tissues. The expansion and contraction of these cavities results in the lysis of cellular connections, resulting in tissue dissection (Figure 2).
Indication of tonsillitomy
Back ground and physics
Ultrasound energy is a mechanical power, it is not electrical, and the mechanism of separation and detachment of tissue is based on formation of cavities through high frequency vibration which is in conjunction with low pressure at the end of the ware glide cause explosion of cell and tissue separation in various level (A phenomenon known as cavitation’s photo destruction effect).2
Ultrasound frequency
Ultrasound were discovered in 1880 via the piezoelectric effect A quartz crystal vibrate when it gets to be part of an electrical circle , The frequency of vibrations of the crystal is set by electrical circuit , this crystal vibration second depend on the set value the electrical circuit delivers.2 In 1920 the first therapeutic use of ultrasound occurred when ultrasound were use to warm muscular tissue.3
Surgical ultrasound tonsillar tissue reduction: Is a minimally invasive surgical option that can reduce tissue volume in a precise, target with minimal impact on surrounding tissue.
Ultrasound probe is unipolar which insert in the Tonsillar crypt submucosally and induce explosion of cell and tissue separation in various level (A phenomenon known as cavitation).
The advantage of Surgical ultrasound are
This descriptive prospective study, (non - controlled clinical trial) was conducted during period of February 2016 to February 2017 in AL-Jadryia private hospital total of 80 patients age range (8 - 64years old) Gender distribution was 55% male, 45 % female. The patients where compelling from Tonsil hyperplasia, Chronic tonsillitis, Recurrent acute tonsillitis not responding to medical treatment. Surgical Ultrasound tonsilletomy technique was done to them under L.A. after describing the procedure to the patient and each patient had to sign a consent form.
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
D & A UltraSurge II Device was used in this study (Figure 3).
Table 1 shows the commercial information of the device.
No. |
Item Description |
Details |
|||
1 |
Dimensions |
30 x 27 x 10 cm |
|||
2 |
Generator |
4,33 Kg |
|||
3 |
Hand piece – Acoustical transducer |
157 gr |
|||
4 |
Electric supply Voltage |
230V AC |
|||
5 |
Frequency |
50-60 Hz |
|||
6 |
Electric power |
max 40W |
|||
7 |
Power Cord |
Detachable cable 1,50 m (3×1.5mm) |
|||
8 |
Electrical Safety |
Class I, Type B |
|||
9 |
Protection category solid object and water ingress |
IP 31 |
|||
10 |
Functioning environment temperature |
15° - 35°C |
|||
11 |
Relative humidity |
30 - 90% |
|||
12 |
Transport and storage conditions |
0° - 40°C |
|||
13 |
Unit’s operating frequency |
48,50 KHz (+ 0,5 KHz) |
|||
14 |
Maximum continuous operation for every operating cycle |
400 sec |
|||
15 |
Minimum pause duration needed after maximum continuous operation |
200 sec |
|||
16 |
device certification |
CE0653 |
Table 1 Commercial information of D&A ULTRASURG II
The patient was placed in semi sitting position.
Use of 10% xylocaine spray as regional anesthesia for 7minute.
Ultrasound generator until adjusted 44 - 55 intensity. As shown in Figure 4.
The probe was introduced through tonsillar crypt while the a devise is activated , probe introduce for few second until the shrinkage has been occurred before leaving out probe , circular movement on entry point to ensure good hemostasis for few second (5-10sec.)
(4-6) entrance in different site of tonsil may applied according to the size and the shrinkage that had been occurred. As show in Figure 4 & 5.
Sterilization of probe was done by immersion of probe in the cidex, also can be done by auto-sterilization by immersion of probe in the N/S for 2minutes with the activation of the device.
Mechanism of action
The tonsillar tissue is heated interstitially, subsequent Scarring cause shrinkage of lymphoid tissue. No tissue is removed and large part of lymphoid allegedly remain function,2 Figure 6.
Post - operative assessment
The patients were observed for about 1hour for any bleeding or other complication.
All the patients were discharge home on the following management.
Acetaminophen (Panadol) 500mg on need.
Eating soft cold food on 1st day.
Advised to follow his or her normal daily activities.
Augmintin tab
All patients were assessed post - operatively for
Post- operative pain, bleeding 1 st week Grade of Tonsil hypertrophy
Complication during and after surgery, as shown in the tables below, there is minimal to no bleeding and pain, Slough can be seen in the first week after that disappear, slight shrinkage in the size immediate (intra-operation) but can be seen obvious after 6weeks, there is subjective improvement in the snoring as per patient partners.
Bleeding
Paste hear Table 2
Duration |
No. |
Description |
Percentage % |
Intra Operative |
4 |
Oozing |
5% |
1st Week |
0 |
No |
0% |
2nd Week |
0 |
No |
0% |
Table 2 Bleeding follow-up
Pain
Paste hear Table 3
Duration |
No. |
Description |
Percentage % |
Intra - Operative |
2 |
Mild |
2.50% |
1st Week |
10 |
Sore throat |
12.50% |
2nd Week |
0 |
No |
0% |
One Mouth |
0 |
No |
0% |
Table 3 Pain follow-up
Slough
Immediate white distortions of Tonsillar, after 3 - 4day slough of tonsillar tissue appear, all of them disappear later (Table 4).
Duration |
No. |
Slough |
Percentage % |
Intra – Operative |
60 |
Mild |
75% |
1st Week |
40 |
Mild |
50% |
2nd Week |
0 |
No |
0% |
One Mouth |
0 |
No |
0% |
Table 4 Sloughing follow-up
Size
About 80% of the patient included in this study shows reduce in the size of the tonsil.
1st post- operative look are one week is mild reduce in size in comparsim to the pre -operative.
There is obvious reduce in size at 3 mouth later (Table 5).
Duration |
No. |
Size |
Intra – Operative |
60 |
5-Jan |
1st Week |
50 |
5-Jan |
2nd Week |
40 |
4-Jan |
One Mouth |
40 |
4-Jan |
Table 5 Size follow-up
Snoring
Both subjective &objective improvement in snoring was observed post – operatively the patient was very satisfy.
Infection and debris
Most of patient did not complain of acute infection in the 1st 6 mouth.
Debris, only 2 of patient had once time recurrent.
There is great debate about the relative merits of the various tonsillectomy techniques published in many studies, with many more ongoing that compare the techniques. The existing literature consistently reports that the intracapsular (partial) techniques result in less postoperative pain, however, the degree of lessened pain continues to be much debated.24‒26 In addition; there is a small risk of tonsil regrowth and the necessity for an additional procedure with the intracapsular techniques. Of the extracapsular techniques, “cold” tonsillectomy results in less postoperative pain compared with an electrocautery or” hot” tonsillectomy; however, the latter procedure is typically faster and has less intraoperative blood loss.27
The equipment involved withvarious techniques varies in price, although the largest cost factor in any tonsillectomy is theoperating time.
Appreciation of the indications and the use of new tonsilletomy techniques and technologies, as well as an awareness of the economic ramifications of their adoption, will ultimately provide the best care for tonsillectomy patients.
The results suggests that surgical Ultrasound tonsillectomy technique is an efficient & well tolerated procedure for the management of chronic tonsillitis and tonsillar hyperplasia.
None.
Author declares there are no conflicts of interest.
None.
©2017 Khalaf, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.