Literature Review Volume 6 Issue 4
1Department of Microbiology, College of Biosciences, Federal University of Agriculture, Nigeria
2Department of Microbiology, Abubakar Tafawa Balewa University, Nigeria
Correspondence: Akinrotoye Kehinde Peter, Department of Microbiology, College of Biosciences, Federal University of Agriculture, P.M.B 2240,110001, Abeokuta, Ogun State, Nigeria, Tel 2348182913048
Received: June 07, 2018 | Published: July 23, 2018
Citation: Peter AK, Umar U. Combating diarrhoea in Nigeria: the way forward. J Microbiol Exp. 2018;6(4):191-197. DOI: 10.15406/jmen.2018.06.00213
The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) calls for a reduction of child mortality by two third between 1990 and 2015, the reality is that although progress is been made, much more remains to be done. The prevalence rate of diarrhoea in Nigeria is 18.8% and is a menace in sub-Sahara Africa; and in this part of West African it accounts for an estimated 150,000 deaths yearly amongst children under five due to poor hygienic and sanitary practices. Diarrhoea’s status as the second leading killer of children under five is an alarming reminder of the vulnerability of children in Nigeria, saving the lives of millions of children at risk of death from diarrhoea is possible with a comprehensive strategy that ensures all children in need receive critical prevention and treatment measures. This report is written with the intent to let our government re-focus her attention on the prevention and management of diarrhoeal diseases as central to improving child survival in the country and justify the need to embrace Sustainability Development Goals (SDGs) set by WHO to achieve universal access to clean water and basic sanitation, which is the primary preventive measures to reduce the burden of diarrhea in the country.
keywords: public health, mdgs, sdgs, under-age children
Diarrhoea is a form of gastrointestinal infection caused by a variety of bacterial, viral and parasitic organisms or through contaminated food or drinking water, or from person to person as a result of poor hygienic practices. If Left untreated, diarrhea can typically last several days. Diarrhoea remains a major cause of mortality among under-age children (mostly under 5years) around the world, especially in developing world.1 The burden of Diarrheal disease seriously affects young children in developing countries whose incidence rates is high due to inadequate water, poor sanitation and suboptimal breastfeeding, zinc and vitamin A deficiency.2–4 Vulnerable children living in impoverished and undeveloped areas also have higher fatality rates compared to children living in developed countries due to lack of access to quality health care and timely intervention and effective treatment with oral rehydration solution (ORS) and zinc.5,6 Diarrhoea has been described as an increment in the volume, fluidity of stools and increased rate of defecation with slight changes in consistency. The measurement of stool fluid content is an indicator for diagnostic purposes and taking into account the assessment of stool frequency. World Health Organization (WHO) placed criteria for diarrhoea to occur if there is an excretion or passage of watery stools at least two-three times in a 24 h period, but factors such as stool consistency, stool frequency, and the usefulness of parental discernment in determining whether children have diarrhoea or not is clearly important to pin down if diarrhoea has occurred or not.7 Acute diarrhoeal illnesses or dysentery is often easily recognized by appearance of blood in the stool, irrespective of frequency or consistency.8,9 A diarrhoeal disorder is often divided into acute, chronic and persistent. The most common of diarrhoea disorders, acute diarrhoea often starts abruptly, are caused by infections and are subdue/resolved within 14 days. Chronic diarrhoea is majorly a product of congenital defects of digestion and absorption in the body system and last for at least 14 days.7 Persistent diarrhoea usually arises due to secondary infections in the presence of complications such as malnutrition.
Each year, an estimated 2.5 billion cases of diarrhoea occur among children under five years of age, and estimates suggest that overall incidence has remained relatively stable over the past two decades.10 More than half of these cases are in Africa and South Asia where bouts of diarrhoea are more likely to result in death or other severe outcomes. The incidence of diarrhoeal diseases varies greatly with the seasons and a child’s age. The youngest children are most vulnerable: Incidence is highest in the first two years of life and declines as a child grows older. The leading cause of childhood morbidity and mortality in developing countries remains diarrhoea. Diarrhoea diseases, a third leading cause of child mortality and infant deaths in low and middle income countries is a major cause of illness and death among young children, even though the condition can be easily treated with oral rehydration therapy (ORT). Exposure to diarrhoea-causing pathogens is frequently related to the consumption of contaminated water and to unhygienic practices in food preparation and disposal of excreta. The combination of high cause-specific mortality and the existence of an effective remedy make diarrhoea and its treatment a priority concern for health services.
According to the World Health Organization, Globally, there are nearly 1.7 billion cases of diarrhoea every year among children under five, diarrhoea is the second-leading cause of death in children under five and is responsible for killing around 760,000 children every year. Diarrhoea kills more children than AIDS, malaria and measles combined; diarrhoea is a leading cause of malnutrition and stunting in children. Mortality from diarrhoea has declined over the past two decades from an estimated 5 million deaths among children fewer than five to 1.5 million deaths in 2004, despite these declines, diarrhoea remains the second most common cause of death among children under five globally.
The burden of diarrhoea in Nigeria–a battle not yet won!
The country’s 2006 Population and Housing Census placed the country’s population at 140,431,790. Nigeria marked its centenary in 2014, having begun its existence as a nation-state in 1914 through the amalgamation of the northern and southern protectorates by Lord Lugard. Nigeria formulated a national health policy targeted at achieving quality health for all Nigerians in 1988. As a result of emerging issues and the need to focus on realities and trends, a review of the policy became necessary. The new policy, referred to as the Revised National Health Policy and launched in September 2004, outlined the goals, structure, strategy, and policy direction of the health care delivery system in Nigeria.11–13 According to the African CDC report (2014), made up of an African CDC Coordinating Centre in Addis Ababa, recent mortality rate estimates in the country stood at; Malaria 20% , Lower Respiratory Infections 9% , HIV 9% , Diarrheal Diseases 5% , Road Injuries 5% , Protein-Energy, Malnutrition 4% , Cancer 4% , Meningitis 3% , Stroke 4% , Tuberculosis 4%.
Diarrheal disease is the third leading cause of infant and child mortality in developing countries1,14 and about 1.8 million children die per annum from this disease.15 The number of diarrhoeal deaths is ridiculously on the high side despite a fall in childhood diarrhoeal diseases from 4.6 million to 0.8 million over the last three decades.1,16,17 The prevalence of childhood diarrhea in Nigeria is 18.8%, with 26% of cases treated with oral rehydration salts (ORS) solution.18,19 Amongst children below five years old, diarrhoea accounts for over 16 % of deaths, estimated at 150,000 annually.20,21 Exposure to diarrhoea-causing pathogens is frequently related to the consumption of contaminated water and to unhygienic practices in food preparation and disposal of excreta. The combination of high cause-specific mortality and the existence of an effective remedy make diarrhoea and its treatment a priority concern for health services.21
The country fails to achieve or meet the Millennium Development Goal 4 (MDG 4) in 2015; in which it must attain a two-thirds reduction in the under-five mortality rate from 230 deaths per 1000 live births from 1990 to 76 in 2015.22,23 The 2013 Nigeria Demographic and Health Survey21 gave a conclusion that if under-five mortality rate of 128 deaths per 1000 live births is to be achieved, then an additional annual 20% reduction is needed to meet the target. Although the federal government along with various NGOs make concerted effort to reduce the burden over the last decades as evidenced by the recent ranking in which Nigeria drop from 2nd to 4th position trailing Pakistan, Bangladesh and India in the rating of countries with the highest number of child death due to diarrhoea; but still there is room for improvement in order to achieve the set goals of Sustainability Development Goal 1 (SDGs) for thriving lives and livelihoods which have a time-frame of 15 years (2015-030).
The Sustainability Development Goals (SDGs) was enacted by W.H.O after the MDGs time-frame elapsed and still some countries couldn’t meet up. SDGs becomes useful tool in focusing achievement of specific development gains for the development activities of a country, for national priority-setting and for mobilization of stakeholders and resources towards common goals, therefore remaining firmly committed to its goals and achievement. Now the era of MDGs has come and gone and a blue print of SDGs initiated by WHO24 is laid out for every government to achieve within a time frame. These goals address and incorporate in a balanced way all three dimensions of sustainable development and their inter linkages which is coherent with and integrated into the United Nations development agenda beyond the time frame. The development of these goals should not divert government focus or effort from the achievement of the Millennium Development Goals, however it will be inhumane and deceptive on the part of the government to neglect the blue print of SDGs laid down by WHO, if truly the country want to win the war against the burden of diarrhoeal diseases claiming the lives of innocent children each year.
Risk factor according to World Health Organization,24 is any attribute, characteristics or exposure of an individual that increases the like hood of developing a diseases or injury. Some examples of the more important risk factor for diarrhoeal affecting children under age 5 includes unsafe water, humanitarian crises, contaminated foods, direct contact with causative microorganisms (bacteria, viruses & protozoan) and unhygienic environment etc.
Diarrhoea has been killing children for several decades and it has attained an endemic status according to data suggested by Kosek et al.,25 & WHO,26. The burden of diarrhoeal illness sits firmly in the developing world, both for morbidity (6–7 episodes per child per year compared with 1 or 2 in the developed world27 and mortality. Malnutrition and the wholly inadequate provision of safe water, sanitation, and hygiene highlight the stark inequalities that exist within our world. A quarter of children in developing countries are still malnourished, 1·1 billion people do not have access to safe drinking water, and 2·4 billion are without adequate sanitation.28–30 Deaths caused by diarrhoeal illness in developed nations are rare accounting for 4% of all hospital admissions.27
Humanitarian crises
Diarrhoea is a leading cause of death during complex emergencies and natural disasters. Natural or Man-made disaster often leads to displacement of populations into temporary and overcrowded shelters; which is often associated with polluted water sources, inadequate sanitation, poor hygiene practices and contaminated food. This all affect the spread and severity of diarrhoea in the country. At the same time, the lack of adequate health services and transport reduces the likelihood of prompt and appropriate treatment of diarrhoea cases. Nigeria as a case study is battling with “Boko haram” insurgency in the North-East region, which have led to the displacement of many families leading to the creation of IDP camp all around the region. According to Medecins Sans Frontieres/Doctors without border (MSF) in 2016,31 a report on Dalori IDP camp in Maiduguri, the capital city of Borno State was given in which women with long faces were seen seated outside a two-room clinic that serve about 19,000 Internally Displaced People (IDP), holding their weak and dying children in their hand. The children looked weak and dehydrated from severe diarrhea triggered by cholera outbreak in the camp, 16 children were reported to have died due to acute diarrhea while 172 others were left in critical condition battling for their life. Hence, reducing the burden of childhood diarrhoeal in the country depend on the readiness of the government to tackle the insurgency and take the “bull by the horn”.
Lack of adequate breastfeeding
The literature on breastfeeding practices and risk of diarrhoea has been extensive. Generally, the lowest morbidity of diarrhoea is recorded in adequately breast-fed children while the highest morbidity is clearly marked in partially weaned children.32–36 A particular risk of diarrhoea is also recorded with bottle-feeding.37,38 Numerous studies have shown the stern defensive effect of breast feeding; the risk of diarrhoea following the colonization with enteric pathogens is reduced by a concentration of antibodies, cells and other mediators in breast milk.38 Nutrients, antioxidants, hormones and antibodies needed for the survival and development of a child are contained in breast milk; government effort should therefore be doubled on campaigns relating to adequate breast feeding by engaging different NGOs in the country.
Poor personal, domestic hygiene
As a result of efforts put into meeting the MDG sanitation target which the country fails to achieve (to halve, by 2015, the proportion of the population without sustainable access to basic sanitation). About 30million people (67% of whom are concentrated in the Northern part of the country) still use unimproved sanitation facilities, practice open defecation which increases the risks of diarrhoeal diseases. Some sanitation factors, like indiscriminate or improper disposal of children's stool and household garbage,37,39–42 no existence of latrine43–45 or unhygienic toilet,40,46 sharing latrine,47 house without sewage system,42 increased the risk for diarrhea in children under five years.
Diarrhoeal deaths attributable to inadequate sanitation has been shown to be higher in several studies, since improved sanitation and even sewered connections may not include full safe management of human waste. Exposure to untreated sewage and faecal sludge in wider populations is likely to cause significant amounts of disease especially diarrhoeal diseases amongst children less than five years. Hence government should formulate policies which must have implication on all housing unit in the country such as; Provision of improved sanitation in households (flushing to a pit or septic tank, dry pit latrine with slab, or composting toilet) which will significantly reduce diarrhoea in the country at large.
Lack of access to safe drinking-water supplies
Drinking-water, even from an improved source, is not necessarily free of faecal pathogens and safe for health.48,49 Water was considered as non-contaminated when complying with the guideline values for microbial quality,50 i.e. containing zero E. coli or thermo tolerant coliforms in 100mL water sample. In order to conceptualize the risk of diarrhoea from drinking-water, drinking-water sources were categorized into five groups, namely51 viz Unimproved, Improved source (other than piped), Basic piped water on premises, systematically managed piped water (continuous and safe supply) and Effective household water treatment and safe storage. Based on the distribution of use of the different types of water sources and the associated risks of diarrhoea, about 502,000 diarrhoeal deaths in LMICs (Low and Middle Income Countries) can be attributed to inadequate drinking water. Somewhat larger health gains can be gained by shifting to basic schemes for piped water on premises. Effective household water treatment combined with safe storage can provide significant protection against diarrhoeal diseases in the country. Sustained and consistent application is necessary to realize these gains.
Eating habits
This is also a significant risk factor.47 Diarrhea can also be acquired by eating contaminated foods such as fruits, vegetables, seafood, raw meat, water, and ice cubes.52 Eating with the hands; eating raw foods; or drinking unboiled water, may increase the risk of diarrhea in children.
Effects of diarrhoea disease on children
The number of deaths caused by diarrhoea, 2.5 million yearly is a large burden. In addition, many time this number have long-term, lasting effects on nutritional status, growth, fitness, cognition, and school performance.15,25,41 Some studies have revealed the impact of diarrhoea on growth.32,53–55 It is believed that diarrhoea have a significant impact on growth due to reduction in appetite, altered feeding practices and decreased absorption of nutrients.32 Patwari53 quoted that there was a marked negative relationship between diarrhoea and physical growth and development of a child. Each day of illness due to diarrhoea produces a weight deficit of 20-40grams. Molbak et al.,38 found that infants who spent more than 20% of their time with diarrhoea had a weight deficit of approximately 370 grams at follow-up after 1 year of age.
According to Checkley et al.,57 children ill with diarrhoea in the first 24months of birth were 1.5cm shorter than children who never had diarrhoea. Hence, the adverse impact of diarrhoea on a nation like Nigeria cannot be farfetched with various scientific findings and correlation over the years.
The goals of treatment are to maintain hydration, treat the underlying causes and relieve the symptoms of diarrhoea. Rehydration and its correction of any electrolyte imbalance are critical in the treatment of diarrhoea while WHO’ s control of diarrheal deaths (CDD) programme and other organizations (UNICEF, USAID) have given first priority to the prevention of diarrheal deaths, rather than prevention of cases, and focused on promotion of ORT. It is estimated that 90% of the child diarrheal disease burden is the result of poor sanitation conditions and inadequate personal, household and community hygiene behaviors.58 Therefore, understanding environmental, behavioral risk factors and their interactions is a prerequisite for devising effective preventive approaches.59
Treatment package
Since the 1970s, oral rehydration therapy, pioneered by the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh,58–61 has been at the forefront for fighting diarrhoeal diseases and proposing treatment packages. The treatment package focuses on two main elements, as laid out in the UNICEF & WHO62joint statement viz Fluid replacement to prevent dehydration and Zinc treatment.
Oral rehydration therapy: The greatest medical invention of the 20th century is the ORT which exemplifies the transfer of technology from developing to developed countries.27,63 Based on instrctions; ORT solutions are produced by adding sodium, glucose, potassium, chloride, and alkali (bicarbonate or citrate) in specific concentrations in clean/pure water.64,65 Using the WHO formula, ORT is useful for the management of all types of dehydration.66 It has contributed a great deal to the reduction of childhood mortality from diarrhoeal disease because it’s extreme effectiveness in treating acute, persistent and watery diarrhoea.60 ORS-WHO (oral rehydration salts) can be regarded as a universal and all-purpose solution; nevertheless, it is pertinent to have a conventional formula that can be recommended and as well promoted globally.
ORS-WHO is an extremely safe therapeutic tool. More than two billion units of ORS have been administered without serious complications. Symptomatic antidiarrheal drugs should not be recommended for the treatment of acute diarrhoea in children.66,67 Antimicrobials are also not effective in uncomplicated acute diarrhoea and their use should be discouraged. In contrast, antimicrobials are indicated in dysentery, cholera, typhoid fever and diarrhoea caused by parasites, such as Giardia lamblia, Cyclospora spp and E. hystolytica.52 ORT administered through mouth or nasogastric tube has shown to be effective in the treatment of chronic dehydration caused by diarrhoea;68 even though the intravenous route is always recommended in the presence of shock. A sodium content of single oral rehydration solution (ORS) is now recommended by W.H.O (75mmol/L)
Homemade fluids: If ORS are not available to treat diarrhoea, a set of appropriate homemade fluids are also effective in preventing dehydration, Different countries have different policies on what constitutes an appropriate homemade fluid, and these policies are not always clearly defined. For example, the general acceptable homemade fluids in Nigeria are the mixture of salt and sugar in a solution. Other fluids will also serve in prevention of dehydration among children with diarrhoea, even though they are not as effective in treating children who have become dehydrated. A homemade fluid is always made at home using available and ready-made low-cost solutes. Cereal-based oral therapies and Home-made fluids has proven to be effective in checkmating diarrhoeal dehydration.69–72
Probiotics: Probiotics are microorganisms that are claimed to provide health benefits when consumed, they are considered generally safe, but may cause bacteria-host interactions mostly strains of lactobacillus spp. This live microbe works to improve intestinal-microbial balance by creating unfavourable environment through the production of antimicrobials and thereby compete with pathogens for essential nutrients and binding sites in the intestinal mucosa for the metabolism of nutrients and bile acids. This kind of immune action induced by probiotics is generally regarded as mucosa-associated immune defences.73–76
Lactobacillus GG, a probiotics involved and associated with a reduced risk of contracting traveller’s diarrhoea77,78 has been a major probiotics researcher have identified as the best microbe to induce defences in an host. Two research studies which focus on in-vitro study of fermented Palm wine on diarrhoeagenic bacteria showed that it had antibacterial activities against those organisms;79,80 hence it is suggested that it can be used as an alternative measure for the control of the diarrhoea produced by these organisms in the absence of antibiotics. It has also been proven that Probiotics reduced the frequency of diarrhoea in children under five of age.81,82
Zinc treatment: Zinc is critical for overall health, growth and development. It also supports proper functioning of the immune system. Though widely found in protein-rich and other food sources, zinc deficiency is widespread throughout the developing world and has been associated with higher rates of infectious diseases, including diarrhoea, and deaths from these illnesses. Zinc supplementation as a part of treatment programmes is critical for replenishing the body’s reserves–helping children to recover from illness and stay healthy afterwards.83 Relation between poor feeding and diarrhoeal illnesses has been correlated over time and it is evident that many of the affected children suffering from diarrhoea shows deficiency in vital vitamins and trace elements required by the body system,84 which are relevant to reducing the burden of diarrhoea in the world. Zinc play a major role in the healing process of damaged skin and it also help to boost the immunity of children less than 5 years; while vitamin A participates in maintaining the epithelium cross-linkage.85 It has been shown that children who receive zinc supplementation earlier do record low incidence, frequency and persistence of diarrhoeal illnesses;86–89 zinc also appears to increase ORS uptake and reduces inappropriate drug use with antibiotics and anti-diarrhoeal medications. Children receiving zinc tablets appeared to recover more quickly, had increased strength and appetites, and were less ill than other children in their communities.90–92
Diarrhoeal disease is caused by ingestion of pathogens, principally through faecal-oral pathways. Three separate but inter-related risk factors were considered as part of the burden of this disease analysis. In developing countries, such as Nigeria; preventive guidelines are largely hampered by social, cultural and economic factors; the government has done little to improve the situation, especially in Northern part of the country which have a high record of diarrhoeal deaths due partially to the insurgency in that region. It has been shown that appropriate water, hygiene, and sanitation interventions can decrease diarrhoea incidence by 26% and mortality by 65%.19 The prevention package focuses on some main elements to reduce diarrhoea in the medium to long term given an acronym “WASH” by the World Health Organisation meaning water, sanitation and hygiene in the late 90’s. New aspects of this approach include rotavirus vaccination, which was recently recommended for global introduction into routine schedules for immunization procedures; promotion of early and exclusive breastfeeding and vitamin A supplementation; promotion of hand washing with soap in terms of community- wide sanitation. Implementation of the prevention package (WASH) if approached in a concerted way may result to greater overall impact on the populace; hence prevention should be accompanied by clear, targeted and integrated behaviour and social change communication strategies to improve health of our children on a larger scale in the country.
Estimates of diarrhoea disease attributable to inadequate water, sanitation, lack of breastfeeding, under use of probiotics and hygiene are sensitive to the main assumptions made above, W.H.O predicts 5million deaths in children younger than five years is still expected by 2025, in which 97% of this mortality rate will still be recorded in developing world (mostly Africa and parts of Asia); in which diarrhoea will contribute a major part of the burden. Reduction in deaths due to diarrhoeal is probably at least in part to improved access to health care, oral rehydration and good nutrition, which means much more still need to be done by the Nigeria government to achieve the Sustainability Development Goals (SDGs) which aim to end preventable deaths of newborn and children under 5years of age (with all countries aiming ) to reduce neonatal mortality to at least as low as 12per 1,000 live births and under-5 mortality to at least as low as 25 per 1,000 live births in which the deadline is 2030.
Recognizing the importance of hygiene promotion especially hand washing to the overall child survival and development, government need to step up her partnership with private sector and NGOs in the promotion of hand washing campaigns at State, Local government and Community levels including in schools. Educating health-care providers’ i.e nurse, midwife, doctors, and medical microbiologist will remain the vital final pathway for dissemination of any interventions. Cultural and religious barrier remain an obstacle to the use of ORT in some communities mostly in the Northern part hence hampering its benefits to the populace. Interventional programmes on local and national scales should be step up such as educating the rural dwellers on the availability of homemade fluids and Probiotics (fluid therapy) in combating the diarrhoea diseases when ORT is not readily available.
I would like to thank Dr Umar Uzal whose critical appraisal and constructive comments were of immense value to putting up this literature review.
The author declares no conflict of interest.
©2018 Peter, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.