Review Article Volume 7 Issue 3
1Fellowship Oncoanaesthesia, Assistant Professor, Dr Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital & PGIMER, India
2Associate Professor, Department of Anaesthesiology, Pain and Palliative Care, Dr BRAIRCH, AIIMS, India
Correspondence: Rakesh Garg, Department of Anaesthesiology, Pain and Palliative Care, Dr BRAIRCH, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Room No. 139, Ist floor, Ansari Nagar, India, Tel +91 9810394950
Received: January 06, 2017 | Published: March 2, 2017
Citation: Hariharan U, Garg R (2017) Sedation and Analgesia in Critical Care. J Anesth Crit Care Open Access 7(3): 00262. DOI: 10.15406/jaccoa.2017.07.00262
Sedation and analgesia go hand in hand in achieving success in management of critically ill patients. It is of great importance in all types of intensive care units: surgical, medical, neurosurgical, oncology and cardiac. A patient-based approach is incorporated, taking into consideration the predisposing and causative factors of pain, agitation and delirium as well as patient-safety. A successful outcome can be achieved by using patient-appropriate analgesia and sedation scales; proper medication selection; monitoring; and protocol-based weaning strategies from sedative-analgesic medications. This narrative review chapter is intended to elucidate the reasons and techniques to achieve adequate sedation and analgesia. Focus is also given on the various scales used for its accurate assessment.
Sedation and analgesia outside the operation theatre is a dynamic and systematic procedure intended to achieve the goals of optimum critical care management. In this regard, nurse anesthetists and intensive care nursing personnel are indispensable. Their dedicated efforts guided by the intensivists are undoubtedly responsible for improved patient outcomes. This article is primarily intended for them and other budding critical care enthusiasts as a mark of recognition to their tremendous contribution.
Pain, agitation and delirium are termed the “ICU triad” and appropriate sedation-analgesic techniques must be adopted to mitigate the ill-effects of this triad. Several randomized trials advocate the principle of “sedation holiday” with daily sedation interruptions to reduce drug side-effects or a protocolized reduction of sedation to minimum possible dose for facilitating weaning. Recent guidelines prefer the use of nonbenzodiazepine sedatives (either propofol or dexmedetomidine) over benzodiazepines for improving clinical outcomes in mechanically ventilated adult ICU patients. Despite several comparative studies, no single agent has been shown to be superior to other agents for ICU sedation. Deep sedation is required only in patients having severe respiratory failure, intra-cranial hypertension, status epilepticus, tetanus and concurrent use of muscle relaxants. In particular, some studies highlight that accurate assessment and measurement of pain in critical care patients is difficult. With advancements in drug discoveries, newer drugs can satisfy our unending quest for an ideal analgo-sedation agent.
Definitions
Analgesia1 is defined as pain control in the form of diminution or elimination of pain. American Society of Anesthesiologists2 and the American Dental Association have defined sedation and analgesia to comprise a continuum of states ranging from mild sedation (anxiolysis) to general anesthesia. Minimal sedation is defined as a minimally depressed level of consciousness, which retains the patient’s ability to independently and continuously maintain an airway and to respond normally to tactile stimulation and verbal command. Moderate sedation (conscious sedation) is a drug induced depression of consciousness during which patients respond purposefully to verbal commands or light tactile stimulation, with patent airway and spontaneous ventilation. Deep sedation/analgesia is a drug induced depression of consciousness during which patients cannot be easily aroused, but respond purposefully following repeated or painful stimuli. Patients may require assistance in maintaining a patent airway and the cardiovascular function is usually maintained.
Why sedation and analgesia?
Sedation is important in the ICU to facilitate amnesia during critical illness, to prevent delirious patients from causing harm to self and others, to facilitate invasive management, to promote ventilator-patient synchrony, to circumvent post-traumatic stress disorder3 and to relieve dyspnea. Inability to meet goals of proper sedation and analgesia has deleterious consequences in the form of increase in adverse events, poor overall outcomes, longer ICU stays and economic effects. Analgesia is as important a component of ICU patients as is sedation. An “analgesia-first” approach can prove beneficial in agitated or delirious patients. Following are the potential consequences of poor pain management:
Children4 of all age groups and neonates (including premature) experience pain, just like adults. Lack of proper guidelines, reluctance to incorporate pain relief as a part of overall management and inadequate training of intensive care nurses are responsible for improper sedation or analgesia practices. Multi-modality should be the dictum for pain management in both pediatric and adult population.
Sedation scales
One of the most important and technically challenging tasks in this entire topic is, how to quantify a patients’ current and desired level of sedation. Critically ill patients, especially intubated ones may not be able to express their requirements correctly. Hence, several scores or scales were developed for measuring degree of sedation at any given point and to guide therapy. Two commonly used sedation scales in ICU include: Ramsay sedation.5 scale and Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale (RAAS).6 In Ramsay sedation scale, scales 1 to 3 constitute awake states and scales 4 to 6 constitute asleep levels.
Sedative agents
There is a wide choice of sedative medications which can be used to achieve the desired level of sedation:
Benzodiazepines7: They are metabolized in the liver by hepatic microsomal oxidation or glucoronidation. Their metabolism may be impaired in elderly and in patients with liver disease. Metabolites of diazepam (dose 2-10mg) can accumulate and prolong its sedative effects. Hence it is not used as infusion. Midazolam (Dose 1-5mg) has a fast onset and short duration of action. It is highly lipophilic, with an elimination half-life of 1-4 hours. It is the most commonly used sedative agent which can be used for continuous infusions. Alpha-hydroxy midazolam is the active metabolite which accumulates with prolonged infusions. Lorazepam (dose 1-5mg) is the slowest onset, longest acting benzodiazepine, whose metabolism is not affected by liver disease. It can lead to ethylene glycol toxicity on prolonged infusions.
Drug |
Dose |
Remarks |
Midazolam |
1-2 mg bolus I.V 2-3mg per hour infusion |
Metabolite active, accumulates in liver disease |
Lorazepam |
1-2mg bolus I.V 1-5mg per hour infusion |
Metabolism not affected by liver disease |
Diazepam |
5 or 10mg bolus I.V |
Not suitable for infusions, Metabolites active & accumulate |
Propofol |
Induction dose: 1.5 – 2.5mg/kg I.V Maintenance: For sedation 25-75mcg/kg/min For hypnosis 100-200mcg/kg/min |
Rapid recovery; Causes pain on injection, apnea, cardiovascular depression, anti-emetic properties, hyperlipidemia, anti-oxidant activity, neuro-protective effects. |
Propofol8: It is one of the most commonly used intravenous sedative in all ICUs. It can be given in a bolus dose of 2mg/kg followed by a maintenance infusion of 5 – 50 microgram/kg/min or 4-5 microgram/kg/hour. Onset of action is 1-2 min and elimination half life is 1-4hours. It has no active metabolite, but it can accumulate in fatty tissues (being lipophilic) and cause delayed effects. It is rapidly cleared from central circulation by hepatic metabolism. Hypotension is a common side effect. Prolonged infusions can lead to propofol infusion syndrome, characterized by bradycardia, cardiac failure, metabolic acidosis, rhabdomyolysis and hyperkalemia.
Ketamine: It is a unique agent as it provides both sedation and analgesia. It has a quick onset of action (30 seconds) and is suitable for procedural sedation in the ICU, especially in patients with reactive airway disease and those with depressed cardiac function. Its side effects include increase in intra-cranial pressures, oral/airway secretions and hallucinations. It can be administered in a continuous infusion dose of 10-50 mcg/Kg/hour.
Newer agents
Fospropofol9: is a prodrug which is converted to propofol inside the body. It is water soluble as opposed to propofol (lipophilic) and has a much smaller volume of distribution. Drug contamination (which is a problem with propofol) is less of a concern here. Its onset of action is slightly longer than propofol and it is safe to use in renal insufficiency.
Dexmeditomidine10: It is a specific alpha-2 agonist that acts centrally to inhibit nor-epinephrine release. Its combined sedative and analgesic effect make it an ideal drug for ICU sedation. It does not cause respiratory depression and allows for a more awake and interactive patient, with lesser incidence of delirium. Its primary side effects are bradycardia, hypotension and sore throat. Discontinuation of a prolonged infusion can cause a withdrawal syndrome characterized by agitation, tachycardia and hypotension. Dose: 0.2 – 0.6 microgram/Kg/Hour.
AnaConDa system11: It is an inhalational anesthesia system designed in Sweden for use with ventilators in the ICU. It is attached to the mechanical ventilators to recycle the anesthetic agents. Volatile anesthetics have a better pharmacokinetic profile than many intravenous sedatives, resulting in quicker and reliable awakening and extubation, which can be a boon for the critically ill patient.
Role of muscle relaxants: The neuromuscular blocking agents12 have been used since time-immemorial for critically ill patients on ventilatory support. They have gone into disrepute as they are associated with prolonged mechanical ventilation, delayed awakening, residual muscular weakness and its economic implications. They are also known to cause critical illness myopathy and neuropathy. Monitoring of the neuromuscular block is recommended if their use is prolonged or longer acting agents are employed. Nevertheless, they are important to facilitate intubation, promote patient- ventilator synchrony and to decrease work of breathing. It is better to use a shorter-acting agent which does not accumulate on prolonged use and which is not dependent on body metabolism for elimination.
The following are the muscle relaxants used:
Precautions
The titration of the sedative dose to a defined endpoint is recommended with systematic tapering of the dose or daily interruption with re-titration to minimize prolonged sedative effects. Patients who were woken up on a regular basis during their ICU stay had lesser days on ventilator. It is important to use titrated doses and infusions to prevent the occurrence of side effects. Over-sedation in a patient with unprotected airway can be disastrous, leading to aspiration, unplanned intubations, raised intracranial pressure and even death. Inadequate sedation can be very distressing for the patient leading to unwanted alteration in physiological parameters, increased work of breathing, exhaustion and increased myocardial oxygen demand. Institutions must device their own sedation guidelines, depending upon the resources available, so that patient safety and comfort is not compromised. Antagonist or reversal agents 13 must be readily available for treating drug overdoses, viz. Flumazenil (0.2-1mg I.V) for Benzodiazepines and Naloxone Hydrochloride (0.4-2mg) for Opioids. Muscle relaxants must be used sparingly, only to tide over the crisis and they must not be substituted for sedatives. Adequate pain control is the pre-requisite to achieving desirable sedation.
Special concern in current day Critical Care: Delirium
Delirium.14 is characterized by an acute onset of disturbance in cognitive abilities with a fluctuating course over time. It is a multifactorial form of brain dysfunction leading to increased mortality, ventilator days and ICU length of stay. The Society for Critical Care Medicine recommends daily noting of delirium in mechanically ventilated patients. There are 2 well validated tools for delirium assessment: CAM-ICU (Confusion Assessment Method for the Intensive Care Unit, consisting of noting the presence or absence of Acute onset/fluctuating course, Inattention, Disorganized thinking and Altered level of consciousness) and ICDSC (Intensive Care Delirium Screening Checklist). Use of simple measures such as reorientation to time/place/person, enhancement of sleep environment, early mobilization and minimization of medications associated with delirium can help decrease its incidence. Critical nurses play a significant role both in the quantification and management of delirium.
Haloperidol, an anti-psychotic, is the drug most commonly used to treat delirium. It acts by blocking dopamine receptors in the brain, which causes tranquility, decreased initiative and drowsiness. It may be administered in the doses of 1-2 mg intravenously and titrated to the effect with a doubling of the dose every 30 minutes as necessary. It may be repeated every 8-12 hourly. It can cause extra-pyramidal side effects such as dystonia, akathisia, pseudo-parkinsonism, heart rhythm disturbances and neuroleptic malignant syndrome. Newer agents, such as Rivastigmine (a cholinesterase inhibitor), are being tried for treatment of ICU delirium. Needless to emphasize here, prevention is better than cure.
Pain and analgesia
Pain not only causes human suffering, but also leads to relationship or job disruption and has a tremendous economic impact on society. Pain is an universal aftermath of injury. Despite the tremendous scientific and technological advances, pain still remains inappropriately or inadequately treated. The word pain is derived from the Latin poena, meaning punishment.Pain is defined by IASP.15 (International Association for Study of Pain) as: an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with actual or potential tissue damage, or described in terms of such damage.” It has 3 components: sensory-discriminative, motivational-affective and cognitive-evaluative. Acute pain16 is defined as a physiologic response to adverse chemical, thermal or mechanical stimulus, associated with surgery, trauma and acute illness. Unmyelinated C or thinly myelinated A delta afferent fibres convey pain sensation. Pain mediators include bradykinin, phospholipase C and nitric oxide, leading to the final common pathway of increase in intracellular calcium and protein kinase levels. Allodynia implies pain by a stimulus, which does not normally provoke pain. Incident pain is generated by mechanical factors characteristic of movement and position. Hyperalgesia is an increased response to a stimulus that is normally painful, due to abnormal processing of nociceptor input. Paresthesia is any abnormal sensation, whether spontaneous or evoked. Neuropathic pain is that initiated or caused by a primary lesion or dysfunction in the nervous system.
Chronic pain17 is defined as pain persisting for longer than the expected time for an injury to heal and temporally, pain lasting beyond 3 months is deemed chronic. Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) is divided into 2 disorders: type 1, which occurs following a soft tissue injury (similar to reflex sympathetic dystrophy) and type 2, occurring after well-defined nerve injury (similar to causalgia). Analgesia means absence of pain in response to stimulation, which would normally be painful. It can be produced peripherally or centrally.
Pain scoring scales
Assessment of the severity of pain is a very important part of pain management. It is of special importance in the critically ill, as pain not only causes deleterious physiologic effects but also the patient may not be able to express pain properly. There are various scales or pain scores available to help the caregiver. Assessment can be difficult in the pediatric population, where more pictorial representations and expertise are required to elicit pain levels.
The following is a brief description of the pain assessment scales18:
Pain scoring scales in mechanically ventilated patients
Mechanically ventilated cannot effectively communicate symptoms of pain. The following are the tools available to assess pain objectively19:
Importance of pain relief
Relief of pain is one of the great goals of medicine. Prevention is still the key to avoiding the consequences of chronic pain. Acute pain causes autonomic hyperactivity in the form of hypertension, tachycardia, sweating and vasoconstriction, which are deleterious for the critically ill. Adequate pain management often reduces the need for sedation. Multimodal sedation and analgesia (both systemic and regional) must be utilized for ICU patients with adequate monitoring and scoring for optimum results.
Critically ill patients may not be able to communicate pain effectively. Hence it has to be assessed both subjectively and objectively. Pain can occur in ICU in the following situations20: intubation, mechanical ventilation, tube suctioning, peripheral neuropathies, cannulation, invasive monitoring, positioning, tracheostomy, sampling, wound dressing, and use of restraints. All these factors need to be addressed in every patient to improve overall outcome.
Methods of analgesia
The first pain clinics were established in the 1940sand∈the1960sand∈the1960s, multidisciplinary approach to pain management was born. In India, the holy Rig-Veda (written in 4000B.C), describes hundreds of methods deriving from mineral, plant and animal sources, many still in use. The current day pain management is complex and multi-modal. It can be divided into: pharmacological and non-pharmacological methods.
Non-pharmacological methods20
Hypnosis, Massage therapy, Music therapy, TENS (trans-cutaneous electrical nerve stimulation), Auriculotherapy and Acupuncture are some of the non-pharmacological methods which are in vogue. But their efficacy is limited and unpredictable. They are usually devoid of any side-effects and repeatable. The ambience of the ICU, its lighting, noise levels, color of the walls/screens and behavior of the staff are equally important in giving a better experience for the critically ill patient.
Pain relief medications
Analgesic agents can be administered via several routes: Enteral/oral, Parenteral (intra-muscular or intravenous), Transdermal/trans-mucosal, Neuraxial (Intrathecal/Epidural), Intra-arterial and Regional techniques. Opioids are the mainstay of analgesia in most ICUs. Pure as well as partial opioid agonists are useful, depending upon the situation and patient profile. Other non-opioid analgesics which are commonly used include: Paracetamol, NSAIDs (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug), Ketamine, Clonidine and Dexmeditomidine.
Following are the opioid agents21 used in ICU and their dosages:
Role of regional anesthesia and blocks
Acute as well as chronic pain is amenable treatment by regional techniques. Trauma and postoperative patients will be in severe pain due to multiple injuries or tissue trauma. Blockade of the various peripheral nerves and plexuses with local anesthetics (lignocaine and bupivacaine hydrochloride) is being practiced widely in surgical and trauma ICUs. Caution needs to be exercised on the dosage of local anesthetic agents used to avoid toxicities. Use of (USG) ultrasound22 (real time ultrasonography) in accurately locating the nerves and plexuses have improved the success rates and decreased the complication rates. Continuous brachial or lumbar plexus catheters can be inserted for extremity pain using nerve stimulators and USG-guidance, to facilitate reduction in systemic analgesics. Opioids can also be used for regional blocks and epidural infusions.
Patient-controlled analgesia (PCA)
PCA pumps23 have revolutionized the field of pain management. It is an electronic programmable device which can be tailored with respect to patient’s requirements. Initially nurse-controlled pumps were in vogue, especially for pediatric patients. In PCA, the patient decides when he wants to take a bolus of the analgesic agent. A preset baseline infusion of the analgesic is given and supplemented with top-ups at the press of a button, at pre-set intervals. It gives a greater sense of control to the patient and improves their general well-being. Both parenteral (intravenous PCA pumps) and neuraxial (epidural PCA pumps) are available for use. This of special importance in analgesia for post-operative and post-traumatic critical care patients. Opioids and local anesthetic agents are the most commonly used agents in PCA Tables 1 & 2.
Sedation Level |
Description Level |
1 |
Anxious, Agitated |
2 |
Cooperative, oriented, tranquil |
3 |
Responds only to verbal commands |
4 |
Asleep with brisk response to light stimulation or loud auditory stimulus |
5 |
Asleep without response to light stimulation (glabellar tap) |
6 |
Non-responsive |
Table 1 Ramsay sedation scale
Target RAAS |
RAAS description |
4 |
Combative, violent, danger to staff |
3 |
Pulls or removes tubes and catheters, aggressive |
2 |
Frequent non-purposeful movements, fights ventilator |
1 |
Anxious, apprehensive, but not aggressive |
0 |
Alert & calm |
1 |
Awakens to voice (eye opening/contact>10s |
2 |
Light sedation, brief awakening to voice, eye opening/contact < 10s |
3 |
Moderate sedation, movement or eye opening. No eye contact |
4 |
Deep sedation, no response to voice, but movement or eye opening to physical stimulation |
5 |
Un-arousable, no response to voice or physical stimulation |
Table 2 Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale (RAAS)
Interventional pain management
Interventional pain management24 is a relatively recent feather in the cap of critical care pain management. It includes procedures which are done for intractable, resistant pain, when conventional techniques have failed. Epiduroscopy, Radiofrequency neuro-ablation, Intra-thecal pumps and Vertebroplasty have been used in various chronic pain states (like CRPS), failed back syndromes and spasticity. Spinal cord stimulators can be used in some neuropathic pain states. Most of these require the use of radiographic image for insertion and are usually done under sterile conditions and sedation in the operation theatre. Cost, equipment availability, expertise and long-term follow-up are the chief considerations in this field.
Pitfalls
Patient safety is more important than the choice of sedative-analgesic agent in any ICU. But inadequate therapy can be deleterious in more ways than one. Critically ill patients may have dysfunction of one or more organ systems. Liver or kidney function derangement can cause the primary drug or its metabolite to accumulate in the body. This can lead to delayed drug toxicity or prolonged effects, which can significantly delay weaning. Any drug which produces active metabolites in the body can lead to such complications. Proper assessment of the level of sedation required and achieved is important in deciding about the duration of ICU stay of patients. Similarly, the severity, site and nature of pain may not be accurately measured in pediatric, elderly, neurosurgical and psychiatric patients. This can lead to faulty therapy and increase in morbidity.
Sedation is incomplete without analgesia and vice-versa. Not only the correct agent needs to be chosen, but also its dose, route, side-effect profile and duration of dosing needs to be understood for all patients. Any error at any stage of assessment or treatment can have far-reaching implications. A combined, multi-modal sedative-analgesic regime may be preferable. The Society for Critical Care Medicine (SCCM) frequently reviews and updates its recommendations on ICU sedation and analgesia, which can be followed for better results. Nurse anesthetists and paramedical staff play a pivotal role in helping the intensivist attain a balanced sedation-analgesic regime in critically-ill patients.
Clinical pearls
All ICU staff must remember the pneumonic “ABCDE”.25, as vital steps of critical care. ‘A’ stands for Awakening, ‘B’ for Breathing, ‘C’ for Choice of sedative and analgesic, ‘D’ for Delirium monitoring and ‘E’ for Early mobilization. It is an evidence based bundle shown to decrease morbidity and mortality in critical care units.
None.
There is no conflict of interest.
None.
©2017 Hariharan, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.